A88579:210
A clear and necessary vindication of the principles and practices of me Christopher Love, since my trial before, and condemnation by, the High Court of Justice. Whereby it is manifested, that a close prison, a long sword, a High Court, and a bloody scaffold, have not in the least altered my judgment. Whereas also the cruelty of the sentence, the insufficiency of the proofs, and my own innocency, are demonstrated. As also my grounds and reasons of giving in a narrative, and the lawfulness of the matter and titles of my petitions (though to usurpers) manifested and maintained. Together with a declaration of my judgement concerning Cromwells unlawful invasion of the kingdom of Scotland. Written by me Christopher Love, Master of Arts, minister of Lawrence Jury, London; penned by me the eighth of August, fourteen days before my death.A cleare and necessary vindication of the principles and practices of me Christopher Love, since my tryall before, and condemnation by, the High Court of Iustice. Whereby it is manifested, that a close prison, a long sword, a High Court, and a bloody scaffold, have not in the least altered my judgment. Whereas also the cruelty of the sentence, the insufficiency of the proofs, and my own innocency, are demonstrated. As also my grounds and reasons of giving in a narrative, and the lawfulness of the matter and titles of my petitions (though to usurpers) manifested and maintained. Together with a declaration of my judgement concerning Cromwells unlawfull invasion of the kingdom of Scotland. Written by me Christopher Love, Master of Arts, minister of Lawrence Iury, London; penned by me the eighth of August, fourteen days before my death.
London : s.n., Printed in the year 1651
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sol. As for Master Erbury, though he is fallen into dangerous opinions, yet, he being my spiritual Father, I do naturally care for him, as Timothy did for Paul, my heart cleaves to him in love, more than to any one man in the World; I speak to the praise of God, he was the instrument to my conversion, near twenty years ago, and the means of my education also in the University, for which kindness, the half I have in the World, I could readily part with for his relief. It is true, about eight or nine years since, he was plundered in Wales, and did come to see me at Windsor Castle, but a Son could not make more of a Father, than I made of him, according to my ability; when I had not twelve pounds in all the World, I let Master Erbury have six of it, indeed he afterward gave me a horse, for which I received not much above forty shillings; yea I procured him a place in the Army, to be Chaplain to Major General Skippon's Regiment, where he had eight shillings a day.
Sol. As for Master Erbury, though he is fallen into dangerous opinions, yet, he being my spirituall Father, I do naturally care for him, as Timothy did for Paul, my heart cleaves to him in love, more than to any one man in the World; I speake to the praise of God, he was the instrument to my conversion, near twenty years agoe, and the means of my education also in the Vniversity, for which kindnesse, the half I have in the World, I could readily part with for his reliefe. It is true, about eight or nine years since, he was plundered in Wales, and did come to see me at Windsor Castle, but a Sonne could not make more of a Father, than I made of him, according to my ability; when I had not twelve pounds in all the World, I let Master Erbury have six of it, indeed he afterward gave me a horse, for which I received not much above forty shillings; yea I procured him a place in the Army, to be Chaplaine to Major Generall Skippons Regiment, where he had eight shillings a day.
6 Object. Others say that what I denied in Court, was afterward proved against me, and then I did confess it.
6 Object. Others say that what I denyed in Court, was afterward proved against me, and then I did confesse it.
Sol. This is a manifest untruth; those Protestations I made the first day of my Trial, I made them also the last day, rejoicing that they were not falsified nor contradicted by any of the 8 Witnesses; but I have spoken to this more largely before.
Sol. This is a manifest untruth; those Protestations I made the first day of my Tryall, I made them also the last day, rejoycing that they were not falsified nor contradicted by any of the 8 Witnesses; but I have spoken to this more largely before.
If other slanders shall be cast upon me, I hope you will have so much charity, not to believe reports raised upon me, when I shall be silent in the Grave, not able to speak in my own vindication. This I say without vanity of falsehood, I have been kept for these twenty years, from the time I first knew God, from falling into any scandalous evil, but only into those infirmities of unavoidable and daily incursion, unto which all the Godly are subject in the course of their pilgrimage. I love not to speak in my own praise, yet I judge it lawful when other mens mouths falsely accuse me, my own mouth may modestly commend me.
If other slanders shall be cast upon me, I hope you will have so much charity, not to believe reports raised upon me, when I shall be silent in the Grave, not able to speake in my owne vindication. This I say without vanity of falshood, I have been kept for these twenty years, from the time I first knew God, from falling into any scandalous evill, but only into those infirmities of unavoydable and dayly incursion, unto which all the Godly are subject in the course of their pilgrimage. I love not to speak in my own praise, yet I judge it lawfull when other mens mouthes falsly accuse me, my owne mouth may modestly commend me.
As an Appendix to what I have already written, I have but a few things to desire the Reader to take notice of.
1. I am informed that there is something blotted out of my last Petition, after it went from me, without my knowledge or consent. To assure all the World that I was no Malignant, I did put this clause in my fourth Petition, That in my place and calling, I should oppose all Malignant designs, whether in this or the Neighbour Nation, that may tend to the ruin• of this Common-wealth. Somebody blotted out the ⟨p. 37⟩word [Malignant] and would thereby hold the world in hand, as if I should engage to oppose the King and Scots which are now entered England, which was far from my Heart; I judge it no Malignant design for the Scots to defend their Nation, and the Title of their King, upon the interest of Religion, and terms of the Covenant, this is an honest and justifiable design. Indeed Mr. Owen and Mr. Bond were with me in the Tower, and desired me to put it out, but I told them I could not do it, because I said, though I would be looked upon as one that would oppose Malignant designs, yet I would not be looked upon as one that would oppose the honest Scots, or as if I thought their actings were Malignant designs. I sent the Petition to Sheriff Titchburn, if he observed it, he will justify me that the word Malignant was in the Petition. Whether they have blotted out any thing more, or put any thing in, God knows; I am not ashamed to own the Petitions. I have given you the Substance of them in my vindication. I desire you to take notice also, that by [Common-wealth] I do not understand the present Government, (I wish that were ruined) but by Common-wealth I understand the Body or Community of the People of this Nation, I shall in my place and calling oppose any Malignant designs that may tend to their ruin.
1. I am informed that there is something blotted out of my last Petition, after it went from me, without my knowledge or consent. To assure all the World that I was no Malignant, I did put this clause in my fourth Petition, That in my place and calling, I should oppose all Malignant designs, whether in this or the Neighbour Nation, that may tend to the ruin• of this Common-wealth. Somebody blotted out the ⟨p. 37⟩word [Malignant] and would thereby hold the world in hand, as if I should engage to oppose the King and Scots which are now entred England, which was far from my Heart; I judge it no Malignant designe for the Scots to defend their Nation, and the Title of their King, upon the interest of Religion, and terms of the Covenant, this is an honest and justifiable designe. Indeed Mr. Owen and Mr. Bond were with me in the Tower, and desired me to put it out, but I told them I could not doe it, because I said, though I would be lookt upon as one that would oppose Malignant designes, yet I would not be lookt upon as one that would oppose the honest Scots, or as if I thought their actings were Malignant designes. I sent the Petition to Sheriffe Titchburn, if he observed it, he will justifie me that the word Malignant was in the Petition. Whether they have blotted out any thing more, or put any thing in, God knows; I am not ashamed to own the Petitions. I have given you the Substance of them in my vindication. I desire you to take notice also, that by [Common-wealth] I do not understand the present Government, (I wish that were ruined) but by Common-wealth I understand the Body or Community of the People of this Nation, I shall in my place and calling oppose any Malignant designes that may tend to their ruine.
2. I desire you to take notice, that it is very likely they will not publish the Depositions of the Witnesses in Court, but the private Examinations taken from them in private, and patched together by Mr. Scot, and Captain Bishop; they were not ashamed to produce them and read them in open Court, and some of the Witnesses had so much honesty left, as to disavow them in open Court. Believe nothing (beloved) but what was sworn in open Court, nor all that neither, for some of the Witnesses swore falsely, as I made appear in my Defence.
2. I desire you to take notice, that it is very likely they will not publish the Depositions of the Witnesses in Court, but the private Examinations taken from them in private, and patcht together by Mr. Scet, and Captain Bishop; they were not ashamed to produce them and read them in open Court, and some of the Witnesses had so much honesty left, as to dissavow them in open Court. Believe nothing (beloved) but what was sworn in open Court, nor all that neither, for some of the Witnesses swore falsly, as I made appear in my Defence.
3 I desire the Reader to take notice, that there is a lying Pamphlet put forth, entitled, A short Plea for the Common-wealth. In which there are many gross lies, especially in things which relate to me. It is not fit for me to enter the Lists with him; It becomes not a dying man to write of Controversies, which will beget dispute; therefore I shall not answer the Book, though I could easily do it, but only sum up the many Lies he relates concerning me; As
3 I desire the Reader to take notice, that there is a lying Pamphlet put forth, entituled, A short Plea for the Common-wealth. In which there are many grosse lies, especially in things which relate to me. It is not fit for me to enter the Lists with him; It becomes not a dying man to write of Controversies, which will beget dispute; therefore I shall not answer the Book, though I could easily do it, but only sum up the many Lies he relates concerning me; As
In Page 3 second Edition.1 He insinuates, he is loath to say it out for shame, or to name me, yet he would deceive the Reader, by saying, The meetings of these Traitors here, produced the first Treaty at the Hague. And elsewhere he saith, That I am chief of these Traitors; so that in the lump, he is willing to have the Reader believe as if I were at those meetings, when I was at none, neither about the Treaty at the Hague, nor the Treaty at Jersey neither, till both were dissolved. Indeed Alford, Adams, Far, &c. who were my accusers, were at those meetings from first to last, as they themselves confessed; yet such was the wisdom of Mr. Scots Council of State, they must be acquitted, and I executed, that know nothing of all those meetings.
In Page 3 second Edition.1 He insinuates, he is loath to say it out for shame, or to name me, yet he would deceive the Reader, by saying, The meetings of these Traytors here, produced the first Treaty at the Hague. And elsewhere he saith, That I am chief of these Traytors; so that in the lump, he is willing to have the Reader believe as if I were at those meetings, when I was at none, neither about the Treaty at the Hague, nor the Treaty at Iersey neither, till both were dissolved. Indeed Alford, Adams, Far, &c. who were my accusers, were at those meetings from first to last, as they themselves confest; yet such was the wisedome of Mr. Scots Councell of State, they must be acquitted, and I executed, that know nothing of all those meetings.
In Page 7. second Edition. He saith, For what Mr. Love is concerned to say nothing of what preceded Titus his going to Jersey. Here he would insinuate also, as if he could say something of me before Titus his going to Jersey, which he cannot do, if he could, he would not have spared me.
In Page 7. second Edition. He saith, For what Mr. Love is concerned to say nothing of what preceded Titus his going to Iersey. Here he would insinuate also, as if he could say something of me before Titus his going to Iersey, which he cannot doe, if he could, he would not have spared me.
In Page 7.1 second Edition. That one was sent to Titus from my house, and that he returned, and gave an account at my study. The latter part is true, he that was sent to Titus did give an account of his journey at my House, but the first part is ⟨p. 38⟩a Lye; if it were a Truth, why would he not name the man, as he doth others? bu• for fear that every one who heard the Trial at the High Court would have bin able to cry shame upon him. Major Alford was the man was sent to Titus to Calais, but not in my house; for Potter swore Alford was sent when they met at a Tavern, yea Alford himself swore, that it was William Drake that desired him to meet Titus at Calais; and swore also, that he was never within my house, nor ever spake with me, till after he returned from Calais; yet this impudent fellow, the Author of the ••ea, doth charge me with it.
In Page 7.1 second Edition. That one was sent to Titus from my house, and that he returned, and gave an account at my study. The latter part is true, he that was sent to Titus did give an account of his journey at my House, but the first part is ⟨p. 38⟩a Lye; if it were a Truth, why would he not name the man, as he doth others? bu• for fear that every one who heard the Tryall at the High Court would have bin able to cry shame upon him. Major Alford was the man was sent to Titus to Callis, but not in my house; for Potter swore Alford was sent when they met at a Tavern, yea Alford himself swore, that it was William Drake that desired him to meet Titus at •allis; and swore also, that he was never within my house, nor ever spake with me, till after he returned from Callis; yet this impudent fellow, the Author of the ••ea, doth charge me with it.
In Page 7. second Edition.1 He saith, That upon the debate of sending a Commission, that I should say, Come, come, let it go, which is a gross lye; indeed Huntington did swear thus in Court, but was forsworn; I was against sending the Commission, and gave reasons against sending it, yea Capt. Far said upon Oath, and that 3 times together that the Company were against sending it, because private persons had not power to Commissionate, &c.
In Page 7. second Edition.1 He saith, That upon the debate of sending a Commission, that I should say, Come, come, let it goe, which is a grosse lye; indeed Huntington did swear thus in Court, but was forsworn; I was against sending the Commission, and gave reasons against sending it, yea Capt. Far said upon Oath, and that 3 times together that the Company were against sending it, because private persons had not power to Commissionate, &c.
In Page 8.1 second Edition. He saith, That a Letter wrote with B. on it, brought to Capt. Potter from Bamfield, and said by the Party that left it at Potters, that it came from Mr. Love. Captain Potter did not affirm this in Court, indeed he said he thought it came from me, or Doctor Drake, but for my part I never brought, nor sent Letter to his shop in all my life.
In Page 9.1 second Edition. He saith, That I made 3 dreadful Protestations, that I never wrote Letter to the King, Queen, Jermin, Percy, Titus, Massey, &c. That I never received Letter from any of them, That I never contributed any money •or gathered any for the King, &c. or Massey and Titus, &c. This is a loud Lye, it is well there are many Witnesses to contradict him; and surely, if the Author of this Book had not east off all fear of God, and regard to the good name of his Brother, he could not be so impudent, as to affirm that these were my Protestations. I never named Massey or Titus in my Protestations, for then I had protested a falsehood, (which I durst not do) I did write a Letter to Massey, and did contribute money to Massey and Titus, yet my Protestations are not contradicted; for I Protested, I writ no Letter to the King, Queen, Church, or State of Scotland, in the general, or to any particular person of the Scottish Nation. The truth of this I shall stand to. For though I did write and give money to Massey, yet my Protestation is not falsified, for he is of the English not of the Scottish Nation.
In Page 9.1 second Edition. He saith, That I made 3 dreadfull Protestations, that I never wrote Letter to the King, Queen, Iermin, Piercy, Titus, Massey, &c. That I never received Letter from any of them, That I never contributed any money •or gathered any for the King, &c. or Massey and Titus, &c. This is a loud Lye, it is well there are many Witnesses to contradict him; and surely, if the Author of this Book had not east off all fear of God, and regard to the good name of his Brother, he could not be so impudent, as to affirm that these were my Protestations. I never named Massey or Titus in my Protestations, for then I had protested a falshood, (which I durst not doe) I did write a Letter to Massey, and did contribute money to Massey and Titus, yet my Protestations are not contradicted; for I Protested, I writ no Letter to the King, Queen, Church, or State of Scotland, in the generall, or to any particular person of the Scotish Nation. The truth of this I shall stand to. For though I did write and give money to Massey, yet my Protestation is not falsified, for he is of the English not of the Scotish Nation.
In page 9.1 second Edition. He saith, That at my Examination I made such a deep and general profession of my Innocency, though the proof, and his Confession at the Court contradicted it, &c. The first part of this Speech is true, the latter notoriously false. As to the Questions propounded to me, about Correspondence with the King, Queen, &c. writing a Letter to the Church of Scotland, or sending Titus to Jersey; as to these things I said I was innocent, and so I say still. But as for the latter part of his words, That the proof, and my Confession at the Court contradicted my Answer at my Examination, that's abominably false; though he was not ashamed to say so in the general, yet he durst not instance in any particular, nor will any other in my life time, whilst I can answer for my self. I do affirm this to all the World, That at my Examinations I did deny nothing that was true, nor would I confess any thing that was Criminal. And because I am belied, about my examination before the Committee, and may be more abused after I am dead, therefore I am necessitated to discover that juggling ⟨p. 39⟩and baseness of Mr. Scot, and Captain Bishop, about my Examination, which I thought never to have made public. Whiles I was examined before the Committee, that pragmatical fellow Captain Bishop (who, I suppose wrote this lying Book) did put in 6 or 8 lines into my Examinations, which I never said; he supposing I would be so mease-mouthed as not to read it, or to put my hand to his forgeries with out any more ado: But I did, to his shame make him blot out at least 6 lines in my Examination, which was but very short; Some of the Committee did ingenuously say sometimes, that I did not speak such words as Captain Bishop did put in. By his abuse of me, who would not be abused by him, I cannot but think how he injured other men. I did refuse to put my hand to it, seeing I was abused by Captain Bishop, but told them, if they would give me a Copy of it, I would subscribe my hand; but they denied me a Copy, which made me suspect they did not intend to deal fairly with me; as I found true soon after. About 3 weeks after I was examined, Mr. Prideaux, and Mr. Scot came to examine me in the Tower; I still refused to accuse my self; Mr. Scot showed me a Paper, told me it was the Examination taken from my mouth;
In page 9.1
he read it to me, when I saw and heard it, I renounced it, told him plainly it was a forged paper, that it was not mine. He replied, it was that very individual paper that was written and taken from my mouth; and that he himself did endorse it with his own hand. To this I reply, whether he endorsed it, or no, I could not say, but I can say, and do affirm, the paper was not mine, and I gave him two evident and undeniable Demonstrations that it was not the paper written at my Examinations. For, 1. In that paper there were many lines blotted out, but in this there were none. 2. In the paper showed me at the Tower was written to this effect, That I should say, I was not present at the reading or hearing of any Letters read from Scotland, which I never said; and I did put him in mind, that I refused to Answer that Question, Whether I was present when Letters were read? Because (said I) then your next Question will be, Who else was present? So I must accuse others, which I shall not do: And then, further, if I should say I was not present, and you could prove that I was present at the hearing of any Letters of News from Foreign parts, you would tax me of a falsehood, which none shall be able to fasten upon. This did somewhat silence, and satisfy Mr. Scot, that it was not the paper that was taken at my Examination; wherefore, I beseech the Reader not to believe any thing that shall come forth, either pretended to be my Examination, or the Examinations of other men against me, they are but the Forgeries and Contrivements of Mr. Scot and Capt. Bishop.
he read it to me, when I saw and heard it, I renounced it, told him plainly it was a forged paper, that it was not mine. He replyed, it was that very individuall paper that was written and taken from my mouth; and that he himself did endorse it with his own hand. To this I reply, whether he endorsed it, or no, I could not say, but I can say, and do affirm, the paper was not mine, and I gave him two evident and undenyable Demonstrations that it was not the paper written at my Examinations. For, 1. In that paper there were many lines blotted out, but in this there were none. 2. In the paper shewed me at the Tower was written to this effect, That I should say, I was not present at the reading or hearing of any Letters read from Scotland, which I never said; and I did put him in minde, that I refused to Answer that Question, Whether I was present when Letters were read? Because (said I) then your next Question will be, Who else was present? So I must accuse others, which I shall not doe: And then, further, if I should say I was not present, and you could prove that I was present at the hearing of any Letters of News from Foreign parts, you would taxe me of a falshood, which none shall be able to fasten upon. This did somewhat silence, and satisfie Mr. Scot, that it was not the paper that was taken at my Examination; wherefore, I beseech the Reader not to beleeve any thing that shall come forth, either pretended to be my Examination, or the Examinations of other men against me, they are but the Forgeries and Contrivements of Mr. Scot and Capt. Bishop.