A89500:93
Meat out of the eater, or, Hopes of unity in and by divided and…Meate out of the eater, or, Hopes of unity in and by divided and…
Meat out of the eater, or, Hopes of unity in and by divided and distracted times. Discovered in a sermon preached before the Honourable house of Commons at Margarets Westminster on their solemn day of fast, June 30. 1647. / By Tho: Manton Minister of Stoke-Newington.Meate out of the eater, or, Hopes of unity in and by divided and distracted times. Discovered in a sermon preached before the Honourable house of Commons at Margarets Westminster on their solemne day of fast, June 30. 1647. / By Tho: Manton Minister of Stoke-Newington.
London: printed by M.S. for Hanna Allen, 1647
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. When you deal with the errors of the time, (for certainly that is necessary, we must stablish our hearers in the present truths, 2 Pet. 1. 12.) do it with a great deal of caution, and wariness: though I would not prescribe, yet give me leave humbly to offer three things, which possibly may prevent some abuses.
3. When you deale with the errours of the time, (for certainly that is necessary, wee must stablish our hearers in the present truths, 2 Pet. 1. 12.) doe it with a great deale of caution, and warinesse: though I would not prescribe, yet give me leave humbly to offer three things, which possibly may prevent some abuses.
1. Beware of loose stings and general declamations against errors and heresies; these do but exulcerate minds, prejudice our testimony, and much hinder it from being received; this is a miscarriage on both sides; men urge their ways in loose flings, conceited nicks, and implications; general outcries of one side against superstitious antichristianism, and the men of the world, (words soon spoken) on the other side against errors, new lights, and new opinions. The word worketh most when it is most particular and demonstrative; thunder at a distance, doth not so much startle me, as a clap in my own Zenith; it is good to go by way of particular proof and argument against opinions; prove them to be errors, and then call them so; otherwise loose and general invectives, will make but superficial impressions. It is very observable, that when James had proved that conceit of Gods being the author of sin, to be an error, then he said, Jam. 1. 16. Err not, my beloved Brethren: He first disputeth, and then dissuadeth. It's very observable too, Mat. 23. from the 13. to the 33. verse, that our Saviour never denounceth a woe against the Pharisees, but he presently rendereth a reason for it; Woe to you Scribes and Pharisees hypocrites; for ye devour ⟨p. 42⟩widows houses, &c. Woe; for ye shut the Kingdom of God, &c. Usually ungrounded zeal stayeth in generals, and ordinarily 'tis out of deceit or weakness.
1. Beware of loose stings and generall declamations against errours and heresies; these doe but exulcerate minds, prejudice our testimony, and much hinder it from being received; this is a miscarriage on both sides; men urge their wayes in loose flings, conceited nickes, and implications; generall outcryes of one side against superstitious antichristianisme, and the men of the world, (words soone spoken) on the other side against errours, new lights, and new opinions. The word worketh most when it is most particular and demonstrative; thunder at a distance, doth not so much startle mee, as a clap in my own Zenith; it is good to goe by way of particular proofe and argument against opinions; proove them to be errours, and then call them so; otherwise loose and generall invectives, will make but superficiall impressions. It is very observable, that when James had prooved that conceit of Gods being the author of sin, to be an errour, then he said, Jam. 1. 16. Erre not, my beloved Brethren: He first disputeth, and then disswadeth. It's very observable too, Mat. 23. from the 13. to the 33. verse, that our Saviour never denounceth a woe against the Pharisees, but he presently rendreth a reason for it; Woe to you Scribes and Pharisees hypocrites; for yee devoure ⟨p. 42⟩widdowes houses, &c. Woe; for yee shut the Kingdome of God, &c. Usually ungrounded zeale stayeth in generalls, and ordinarily 'tis out of deceit or weaknesse.
2. Deal herein with all soberness and meekness; we should do what we can to remove prejudices; men drink in truths when they are sweetly propounded; God was in the still voice; the small rain falleth sweetly upon the tender grass; men presently engage themselves to a fervour and heat, and that marreth all; 'tis but as oil to the flames. I remember a speech of Darius, when one of the Soldiers of the Camp railed against Alexander, he telleth him, I kept you to fight against Alexander, not to rail against him: Those Arrows of bitter words, are not the weapons of our warfare: Passion showeth we are angry more against the person then the error, too often it maketh us forsake the main controversy, and go on upon a wrong scent; one saith, he that speaketh to Kings, must speak [Greek or Hebrew], with silken words; he that speaketh to dissenters, had need make his speech as smooth and soft as may be; I am sure 'tis agreeable to the Apostles advice, In meekness instruct those that oppose themselves, 2 Tim. 2 25. And in the same place he showeth, that the servants of God must be gentle and patient.
2. Deale herein with all sobernesse and meeknesse; wee should doe what we can to remove prejudices; men drinke in truths when they are sweetly propounded; God was in the still voyce; the small raine falleth sweetly upon the tender grasse; men presently ingage themselves to a fervour and heate, and that marreth all; 'tis but as oyle to the flames. I remember a speech of Darius, when one of the Souldiers of the Campe rayled against Alexander, he telleth him, I kept you to fight against Alexander, not to rayle against him: Those Arrowes of bitter words, are not the weapons of our warfare: Passion sheweth wee are angry more against the person then the errour, too often it maketh us forsake the maine controversie, and goe on upon a wrongsent; one saith, he that speaketh to Kings, must speake 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, with silken words; he that speaketh to dissenters, had need make his speech as smooth and soft as may be; I am sure 'tis agreeable to the Apostles advice, In meeknesse instruct those that oppose themselves, 2 Tim. 2 25. And in the same place he sheweth, that the servants of God must be gentle and patient.
3. Take heed of aggravating and greatening matters, making them of more importance then indeed they are; former ages were possessed with this spirit, every lesser dissent and mistake, was made an heresy or error in the faith, as appeareth by their catalogues.
3. Take heed of aggravating and greatening matters, making them of more importance then indeed they are; former ages were possessed with this spirit, every lesser dissent and mistake, was made an heresie or errour in the faith, as appeareth by their catalogues.
Tertullian had but spoken two or three words, in favour of Montanus, and the Priests of Rome presently cried him up for a Montanist, and accordingly dealt with him: Quo protinus offensus (saith he* that wrote his life) prorsus in Montani parts transivit. I confess 'tis good to be watchful to dash Babylons brats, and take the little ⟨p. 43⟩foxes, Cant. 2. 15. (i. e.) To oppose the first and modest appearances of error; the party last amongst us began with words, and would have brought in things. Therefore I say, 'tis good to be watchful, however this will not justify rough dealing with those that vary from us, but in an expression and straining every thing to the worst sense, and most odious consequences, that it may appear to be heretical. Christs own words were mistaken and wrested into a sense which he would not own; he said, He would destroy the Temple in three days, Joh. 2. 19. He meant it of his body, they accused him of the same words; and yet they are called false witnesses, Mat. 26. 61. who accused him of it, because they wrested it to another sense, applying it to the material Temple. Many have a faculty of turning Eloi into Elijah, Molehills into Mountains, making men offenders for a word, and by false glosses causing innocent things to seem odious.
Tertullian had but spoken two or three words, in favour of Montanus, and the Priests of Rome presently cryed him up for a Montanist, and accordingly dealt with him: Quo protinus offensus (saith he* that wrote his life) prorsus in Montani partes transivit. I confesse 'tis good to be watchfull to dash Babylons brats, and take the little ⟨p. 43⟩foxes, Cant. 2. 15. (i. e.) To oppose the first and modest appearances of errour; the party last amongst us began with words, and would have brought in things. Therefore I say, 'tis good to be watchfull, however this will not justifie rough dealing with those that vary from us, but in an expression and straining every thing to the worst sence, and most odious consequences, that it may appeare to be hereticall. Christs own words were mistaken and wrested into a sence which he would not own; he said, He would destroy the Temple in three dayes, Joh. 2. 19. He meant it of his body, they accused him of the same words; and yet they are called false witnesses, Mat. 26. 61. who accused him of it, because they wrested it to another sence, applying it to the materiall Temple. Many have a faculty of turning Eloi into Elias, Molehils into Mountaines, making men offenders for a word, and by false glosses causing innocent things to seeme odious.
- *Pamelius in vitâ Tertulliani.
4. Let me entreat you to improve your interests for brotherly and friendly collations; public Conferences cannot be had without tumult; and there is a prejudice against public Sermons; and again, private disputes are more for victory then truth, usually there is more of strife then love in them.* Tertullian saith of his private disputation with a Jew, both drew out their reasonings, and through the heat of contention, both went away unsatisfied. But now, if there were meetings instituted for the propounding of things rather by way of case then Controversy, and matters were carried not so much in a disputative way, but by way of friendly collation and loving discourse, it would much conduce to the ending of our differences; certainly, where such meetings have been set up, and wisely ordered, much good hath come by them; if we could allure Christians, the lot of whose dwellings is disposed among our Churches into these ⟨p. 44⟩Conferences, we should find them of much avail. I conceive much might be said out of Scripture for them; certainly we do not come together so often as we should, to comfort our selves with the mutual faith of one another, Rom. 1. 11, 12. I believe, that [Greek or Hebrew], spoken of, Heb. 10. 25. will infer some other mee• ing besides the public assembly; this benefit you would find by such a course, that your own would be stablished, others would be less violent, if brought to these friendly consultations, haply it may be a business that may engage you to much labour & self-denial, but that should not sway with a Christian Minister, whose work is not ended with an hours discourse in the Pulpit: We are very often calling for power to punish heretics; but let us sadly smite upon the thigh, and consider, if any of us, in private, have improved those loving courses, to gain them that have been in our power. Luther hath a pretty saying; Igne charitatis comburendi sunt haereticis, you talk of burning heretics, burn them first in the fire of love, or at least burn them with the fire of the Spirit. The Apostle speaketh of trying the work by fire, 1 Cor. 3. 13. Rational and friendly conviction will do much, at least it will beget a sweet and brotherly correspondence, and 'tis to be hoped, we shall find more meekness, where things are not carried in the way of a set disputation.
4. Let me intreate you to improve your interests for brotherly and friendly collations; publick Conferences cannot be had without tumult; and there is a prejudice against publick Sermons; and againe, private disputes are more for victory then truth, usually there is more of strife then love in them.* Tertullian saith of his private disputation with a Jew, both drew out their reasonings, and through the heate of contention, both went away unsatisfied. But now, if there were meetings instituted for the propounding of things rather by way of case then Controversie, and matters were carried not so much in a disputative way, but by way of friendly collation and loving discourse, it would much conduce to the ending of our differences; certainly, where such meetings have been set up, and wisely ordered, much good hath come by them; if we could allure Christians, the lot of whose dwellings is disposed among our Churches into these ⟨p. 44⟩Conferences, wee should finde them of much availe. I conceive much might be said out of Scripture for them; certainly wee doe not come together so often as we should, to comfort our selves with the mutuall faith of one another, Rom. 1. 11, 12. I beleeve, that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, spoken of, Heb. 10. 25. will inferre some other mee• ing besides the publick assembly; this benefit you would find by such a course, that your own would be stablished, others would be lesse violent, if brought to these friendly consultations, haply it may be a businesse that may ingage you to much labour & selfe-deniall, but that should not sway with a Christian Minister, whose worke is not ended with an houres discourse in the Pulpit: Wee are very often calling for power to punish heretickes; but let us sadly smite vpon the thigh, and consider, if any of us, in private, have improved those loving courses, to gaine them that have been in our power. Luther hath a pretty saying; Igne charitatis comburendi sunt haereticis, you talk of burning hereticks, burne them first in the fire of love, or at least burne them with the fire of the Spirit. The Apostle speaketh of trying the worke by fire, 1 Cor. 3. 13. Rationall and friendly conviction will do much, at least it will beget a sweet and brotherly correspondence, and 'tis to be hoped, wee shall finde more meeknesse, where things are not carried in the way of a set disputation.
- *Alternis vicibus con tentioso fume uterque diem in vesperā traxerant, obstrepentibus etiā quibusdā spectantibus singulorū nubilo quidā veritas obumbrabatur.Alternis vicibus cō tentioso fume uterque diem in vesperā traxerāt, obstrepentibus etiā quibusdā spectantibus singulorū nubilo quidā veritas obumbrabatur.
I have done with my address to the Ministry.
I have done with my addresse to the Ministry.
Thirdly, Give me leave to speak a word to your selves, not as if I would prescribe to you, but only humbly offer two or three Considerations to your thoughts, it may be, I may not show so much discretion in it, yet if I do affection, I have my aim, which is not so much to direct you, as to draw you into a consultation about these matters, and therefore I humbly propose the business to your care; think of the Churches unity, you have covenanted ⟨p. 45⟩to endeavour that the Lord be one, and his Name one. Consider, civill peace depends much upon Church peace; Religion is called so a religando, it being the greatest bond to link men together; contrary opinions in Religion, usually cause much alienation of affection, and great disturbances in the Common-wealth. Therefore this matter appertaineth to you in reference to unity; I humbly desire,
Thirdly, Give me leave to speak a word to your selves, not as if I would prescribe to you, but onely humbly offer two or three Considerations to your thoughts, it may be, I may not shew so much discretion in it, yet if I do affection, I have my aime, which is not so much to direct you, as to draw you into a consultation about these matters, and therefore I humbly propose the businesse to your care; think of the Churches unity, you have covenanted ⟨p. 45⟩to endeavour that the Lord be one, and his Name one. Consider, civill peace depends much upon Church peace; Religion is called so a religando, it being the greatest bond to linck men together; contrary opinions in Religion, usually cause much alienation of affection, and great disturbances in the Common-wealth. Therefore this matter appertaineth to you in reference to unitie; I humbly desire,
1. That you would seriously do your utmost to draw things to an agreement; you have appointed a Committee of accommodation already, we do not know what is done, suppose you did try once again. When* the Remonstrants troubled the Churches of the Low Countries, there were often Collations, and they did select men once and again and again to consider how to compose the differences: 'tis true, those endeavours did not succeed, because those meetings were made up of the most violent sticklers, and the Arminians by the means of Utenbogardus had the secret encouragement and countenance of some of the Magistrates, that nothing should be done to their disservice and disadvantage, and so both parties strove to make the best of their opinion and faction; but now if you would be pleased to try once again, God knows what will be the success, I suppose there can be no danger in trying. Call some men together, whose eminency for the power of godliness will make the matter the more venerable, entertained with the more reverence and awe; when the people smell self and interest in any endeavours, they have the less majesty with them. Call men, through age and experience versed in such a work, men of a moderate and sober spirit, who prefer the interest of religion before that of a party; blessed be God, England doth not want such, call them together to think of ways of reconciliation; though many thirst & ⟨p. 46⟩pant after it, yet cannot effect it, being but private men, and so not so much regarded, and in bodies & assemblies they cannot so well drive it on; men of middle interests, being always suspected, have a prejudice upon their endeavours; and indeed good men cannot be imagined to be so without all touch and sense of their own particular opinion, as not to dispute, stickle, & engage for it in such bodies and assemblies: but now if such were called together by your authority, to make it their only work to provide for the advantage of religion, and to compose the differences; possibly and by the blessing of God, much good might be done, however, you will manifest that you have not been wanting to your duty, and therefore weigh it in your thoughts.
1. That you would seriously do your utmost to draw things to an agreement; you have appointed a Committee of accommodation already, we do not know what is done, suppose you did try once againe. When* the Remonstrants troubled the Churches of the Low Countryes, there were often Collations, and they did select men once and againe and againe to consider how to compose the differences: 'tis true, those endeavours did not succeed, because those meetings were made up of the most violent sticklers, and the Arminians by the means of Vtenbogardus had the secret incouragement and countenance of some of the Magistrates, that nothing should be done to their disservice and disadvantage, and so both parties strove to make the best of their opinion and faction; but now if you would be pleased to try once againe, God knows what will be the successe, I suppose there can be no danger in trying. Call some men together, whose eminency for the power of godlinesse will make the matter the more venerable, entertained with the more reverence and awe; when the people smell selfe and interest in any endeavours, they have the less majesty with them. Call men, through age and experience versed in such a work, men of a moderate and sober spirit, who preferre the interest of religion before that of a party; blessed be God, England doth not want such, call them together to think of wayes of reconciliation; though many thirst & ⟨p. 46⟩pant after it, yet cannot effect it, being but private men, and so not so much regarded, and in bodies & assemblies they cannot so well drive it on; men of middle interests, being always suspected, have a prejudice upon their endeavours; and indeed good men cannot be imagined to be so without all touch and sense of their own particular opinion, as not to dispute, stickle, & ingage for it in such bodies and assemblies: but now if such were called together by your authority, to make it their onely worke to provide for the advantage of religion, and to compose the differences; possibly and by the blessing of God, much good might be done, however, you will manifest that you have not been wanting to your duty, and therefore weigh it in your thoughts.
- *See the History of the Councel of Dort in •he Preface to the Reformed Churches.
2. That you would quicken your Ministers and Elders in their Provincial and Classical meetings, by some charge and command to think of ways how best to gain and deal with dissentients. The matter is not below the care of a Christian Magistrate.* Histories tell us how Constantine did beseech his Bishops to an agreement: oversee their Counsels, travail in the peace of the Churches. Socrates saith, he was affected with the schism of the Church as his own calamity. Well then, if you would be pleased to quicken them by your command and enable them by your authority, to find out and to act in such ways as may tend to the ending of the differences and controversies, much good might be done. I humbly conceive the true nature and intent of such meetings is not altogether or chiefly to give laws authoritatively to the particular Churches, as to consider how to compose differences that do arise in them; and 'twere sad if the Mint and Cummin were preferred above the weighty works, and the chief of their care were spent either in trivial disputes, or in making rules for their own, rather then in ⟨p. 47⟩studying all brotherly ways of gaining those that differ, and healing the breaches of the Church. This (I say) were sad indeed, the true intent and nature of these meetings being to give satisfaction, and to carry things with more clearness of demonstration, and to give out the sense of the Church in matters of difficulty; for indeed the less of a Court, and the more of a Council they have in them the better: therefore if you would command and chiefly commend these things of unity to their care & debates, some hope might arise that way.
2. That you would quicken your Ministers and Elders in their Provinciall and Classicall meetings, by some charge and command to think of waies how best to gain and deale with dissentients. The matter is not below the care of a Christian Magistrate.* Histories tell us how Constantine did beseech his Bishops to an agreement: oversee their Counsels, travaile in the peace of the Churches. Socrates saith, he was affected with the schisme of the Church as his own calamity. Well then, if you would be pleased to quicken them by your command and inable them by your authority, to find out and to act in such wayes as may tend to the ending of the differences and controversies, much good might be done. I humbly conceive the true nature and intent of such meetings is not altogether or chiefly to give laws authoritatively to the particular Churches, as to consider how to compose differences that do arise in them; and 'twere sad if the Mint and Commin were preferred above the weighty works, and the chiefe of their care were spent either in triviall disputes, or in making rules for their own, rather then in ⟨p. 47⟩studying all brotherly waies of gaining those that differ, and healing the breaches of the Church. This (I say) were sad indeed, the true intent and nature of these meetings being to give satisfaction, and to carry things with more clearnesse of demonstration, and to give out the sense of the Church in matters of difficulty; for indeed the lesse of a Court, and the more of a Councell they have in them the better: therefore if you would command and chiefly commend these things of unity to their care & debates, some hope might arise that way.
- *See Socrates Eccles. hist. lib. 1. cap. 7. in the Greek, et alios passim.
Thirdly, That you would take care that Ministers put out for scandal, may not be so easily taken in again, against those that are humbly penitent, and modestly ingenuous, no man would open his mouth, but for the others, I am persuaded they are and will be a great means of our troubles, partly as they occasion no small offence to the godly, the dead body of Amasa in the way to discourage the people of the Lord from going on to union and accord; the sons of Eli that cause many to abhor the offering of the Lord; partly as those that are very apt to be the cinifloes, that will blow up the coals of strife amongst us. The first stirs about religion in the Low Countries, were occasioned by the Ministers of the old Leaven, whom they were fain to take in out of necessity in that scarcity of Ministers, and to allow some of them, because of their parts in eminent places.* The story nameth Wiggerus, Collhaasius, and others, who kindled those sparks of trouble, which afterward were blown up by James Arminius into a great flame. Many observe that the Jesuits go over to the Lutherans, and foment differences between them & the reformed, & truly we may fear their influence, men that have the old malice & a new irritation, will stir in a way of revenge. The Lord guide you: I am sorry to hear the complaints that are abroad.
Thirdly, That you would take care that Ministers put out for scandall, may not be so easily taken in againe, against those that are humbly penitent, and modestly ingenuous, no man would open his mouth, but for the others, I am perswaded they are and will be a great means of our troubles, partly as they occasion no small offence to the godly, the dead body of Amasa in the way to discourage the people of the Lord from going on to union and accord; the sons of Eli that cause many to abhor the offering of the Lord; partly as those that are very apt to be the cinifloes, that will blow up the coales of strife amongst us. The first stirs about religion in the Low Countryes, were occasioned by the Ministers of the old Leaven, whom they were faine to take in out of necessity in that scarcity of Ministers, and to allow some of them, because of their parts in eminēt places.* The story nameth Wiggerus, Collhaasius, and others, who kindled those sparks of trouble, which afterward were blown up by James Arminius into a great flame. Many observe that the Jesuites goe over to the Lutherans, and foment differences between them & the reformed, & truly we may feare their influence, men that have the old malice & a new irritation, will stirre in a way of revenge. The Lord guide you: I am sorry to heare the complaints that are abroad.
- *Amabi•em Bdlyicarum Ecclesiarū pacem atque harmoniam perturbare conati sunt o•im nō •ulli, qui deserto Papismo, sed fer mento ejus nondum plenae expurgato ad ecclesias nostras transicrant, carundemque ministerio in primâ ulâ ministrorū inopiâ admoti fuerant, C•sperus Co•lhasius Leidae, Hermanus Herbertus Goudae & Dordrecti▪ &c. vid. Historiam sin: Dord: in praes: ad ecclesias sub initio.Amabi•em Bdlyicarum Ecclesiarū pacem atque harmoniam perturbare conati sunt o•im nō •ulli, qui deserto Papismo, sed fer mēto ejus nōdum plenae expurgato ad ecclesias nostras trāsicrant, carundemque ministerio in primâ ulâ ministrorū inopiâ admoti fuerāt, C•sperus Co•lhasius Leidae, Hermanus Herbertus Goudae & Dordrecti▪ &c. vid. Historiam syn: Dord: in praes: ad ecclesias sub initio.
Fourthly, In the liberty that you give, use great caution, some things you may be forced to bear with for a time, take heed of endangering the truths of God, you ought to be tender of Christs little ones; woe to those that offend them, Mat. 18. 6. But you ought to be more tender of Christs truths▪ you owe somewhat to Christs Saints and servants: but I say again, more to his truths? Tis somewhat unheard of, that these two should come in contest and competition; however, you will find Christ more jealous of his ways then of his servants; of his truths then of his Saints: 'tis truth makes Saints, (Joh. 17. 17. Sanctify them by thy truth, thy word is truth;) and husbandmen are ever more careful of their seed-corn, then of the increase; and besides, we may be deceived in Saints, we do not know hearts, but we cannot so easily in truths, because there is a sure standard to measure them by. Therefore take heed of doing any thing against truth; 'tis a good old caution, In veste varietas sit scissura, non sit, though there be divers colours, yet let there be no rent in the Churches coat. I will not take upon me to state the matter, what liberty you may give, and how far; perhaps that may be unseasonable; however 'twill not (I hope) be too much presumption to present you with the most obvious miscarriages of Magistrates in this matter. Three sorts of men there are in the world, and concerning every one of them we may say,1 The way of peace they have not known.
Fourthly, In the liberty that you give, use great caution, some things you may be forced to beare with for a time, take heed of endangering the truths of God, you ought to be tender of Christs little ones; woe to those that offend them, Mat. 18. 6. But you ought to be more tender of Christs truths▪ you owe somewhat to Christs Saints and servāts: but I say again, more to his truths? Tis somewhat unheard of, that these two should come in contest and competition; however, you will find Christ more jealous of his ways then of his servants; of his truths then of his Saints: 'tis truth makes Saints, (Joh. 17. 17. Sanctifie them by thy truth, thy word is truth;) and husbandmen are ever more carefull of their seed-corne, then of the increase; and besides, we may be deceived in Saints, wee doe not know hearts, but we cannot so easily in truths, because there is a sure standard to measure them by. Therefore take heed of doing any thing against truth; 'tis a good old caution, In veste varietas sit scissura, non sit, though there be divers colours, yet let there be no rent in the Churches coate. I will not take upon me to state the matter, what libertie you may give, and how far; perhaps that may be unfeasonable; however 'twill not (I hope) be too much presumption to present you with the most obvious miscarriages of Magistrates in this matter. Three sorts of men there are in the world, and concerning every one of them wee may say,1 The way of peace they have not knowne.
1. Some are of a preposterous zeal in lesser differences, and are all for extremity and violence towards those from whom they differ in the least degree and circumstance; most of the censures inflicted by the late Bishops were because of Ceremonies, things not weighty in any regard, no not in their own esteem: some men breath out nothing but rage and threatenings upon the least dissent.
1. Some are of a preposterous zeale in lesser differences, and are all for extremity and violence towards those from whom they differ in the least degree and circumstance; most of the censures inflicted by the late Bishops were because of Ceremonies, things not weighty in any regard, no not in their own esteeme: some men breath out nothing but rage and threatnings upon the least dissent.
I remember I have read of Joab David's General, that when his teacher had falsely vowelled one word in the Hebrew he slew him; the place was that charge to destroy Zechan. He read it Zachar the males of Amalec: It is good to preserve truth, but small distempers will not need so violent a cure; 'tis as if a man should fire an house to destroy the mice in it. Union is good, but rigorous enforcements especially in trifles & things that lie far from the heart of Religion are not so warrantable. Paul is every where most zealous against errors, there is never an Epistle of his but hath some what against them: However none more earnest then he to bring circumcision and uncircumcision to a profession of brotherhood.
I remember I have read of Joab David's Generall, that when his teacher had falsely vowelled one word in the Hebrew hee slew him; the place was that charge to destroy Zechan. He read it Zachar the males of Amalec: It is good to preserve truth, but small distempers will not need so violent a cure; 'tis as if a man should fire an house to destroy the mice in it. Union is good, but rigorous inforcements especially in trifles & things that lie farre from the heart of Religion are not so warrantable. Paul is every where most zealous against errours, there is never an Epistle of his but hath some what against them: However none more earnest then he to bring circumcision and uncircumcision to a profession of brotherhood.
Secondly, Some are for medleys and compounds of religion, as if that would be peace: Thus Charles the fifth thought to please all by that wicked book called the Interim, it did a great deal of harm, and did not any way heal the difference; many of late amongst us and in other reformed Churches endeavoured to blend us & Rome, Babylon, and Zion together, God hateth those iniquos syncretismos profane mixtures, and intermysticall designs; unity consists in an agreement in the truth, not in a coagulation of errors, strings that are in tune must not be stirred, others must be set up to them: The disobedient must be brought up to the wisdom of the just, not that brought down to them, Luke 1. 17. when the language is pure the Soldier is one, Zeph. 3. 9. little hopes of agreement till you set up pure doctrine, unmixed discipline, the new cloth set upon the old will make the rent the greater, the world thinks the less purity the more unity; but 'tis otherwise, all the troubles are because Iron will not mix with Clay, Gods ways with man's inventions.
Secondly, Some are for medleyes and compounds of religion, as if that would be peace: Thus Charles the fifth thought to please all by that wicked booke called the Interim, it did a great deale of harme, and did not any way heale the difference; many of late amongst us and in other reformed Churches endeavored to blend us & Rome, Babilon, and Zion together, God hateth those iniquos syncretismos prophane mixtures, and intermysticall designes; unity consists in an agreement in the truth, not in a coagulation of errors, strings that are in tune must not be stirred, others must be set up to them: The disobedient must bee brought up to the wisedome of the just, not that brought downe to them, Luke 1. 17. when the language is pure the Souldier is one, Zeph. 3. 9. little hopes of agreement till you set up pure doctrine, unmixed disipline, the new cloth set upon the old will make the rent the greater, the world thinks the lesse purity the more unity; but 'tis otherwise, all the troubles are because Iron will not mixe with Clay, Gods waies with man's inventions.
Thirdly, Some drive at a promiscuous leave, and toleration of all opinions, and differences though never so ⟨p. 50⟩contrary to truth, as if this were the best way to bring things to any peace and quiet: oh consider how great a prejudice this is to Religion, this is the very way that Julian the Apostate took to destroy it, Socrates Scholasticus, Ammianus Marcellinus and others that write of him say that to ruin religion he would equally tolerate and countenance all parties. I shall but take notice of what* one saith that he was thoroughly set upon this as knowing it to be the ready way to bring all to naught, & indeed 'twas not only the policy of this subtle adversary, but of all the enemies of truth as the* margin will inform you. And indeed where it doth not destroy Religion it doth embase it, partly because men content themselves in having made a better choice then others about them; partly because men spend all the heat and first-borne of their strength and zeal in the contentions and let the practics go, certainly there would be but little security to truth and it's followers, where there is such a promiscuous toleration, where men are godly they cannot be so easily amassed into one body and confederacy with persons erroneous, they being bound up by conscience, and having religion of their sides, are not so flexible, and then the others cannot so well agree with them; for two different errors can better agree and cotton among themselves then one error and the nearest truth; darkness and darkness can better agree then light and darkness, always you will find it, men hate the nearest truth as being that light by which their deeds are reproved. The Eunomians & the Arians, though they held different errors (the one denied the Godhead of the Son, the other of the Spirit) could better agree with one another then with the Orthodox, the Pharisees and Herodians, though of different principles (the one being for, the other against the liberty of the Jews) yet both could conspire together to entrap Christ. Jebal ⟨p. 51⟩and Ammon and Amalec could better accord with one another then with Zion. In such a case truth would be worst provided for, always under fears of some Sicilian vespers or a Saint Bartholomew's matins, some sudden eruption of violent counsels and dangers hatched against it.
Thirdly, Some drive at a promiscuous leave, and toleration of all opinions, and differences though never so ⟨p. 50⟩contrary to truth, as if this were the best way to bring things to any peace and quiet: ôh consider how great a prejudice this is to Religion, this is the very way that Julian the Apostate tooke to destroy it, Socrates Scholasticus, Ammianus Marcellinus and others that write of him say that to ruine religion he would equally tolerate and countenance all parties. I shall but take notice of what* one saith that he was thoroughly set upon this as knowing it to be the ready way to bring all to naught, & indeed 'twas not onely the policy of this subtile adversary, but of all the enemies of truth as the* margine will informe you. And indeed where it doth not destroy Religion it doth imbase it, partly because men content themselves in having made a better choyse then others about them; partly because men spend all the heat and first-borne of their strength and zeale in the contentions and letthe practicks goe, certainely there would be but little security to truth and it's followers, where there is such a promiscuous toleration, where men are godly they cannot be so easily amassed into one body and confederacy with persons erroneous, they being bound up by conscience, and having religion of their sides, are not so flexible, and then the others cannot so well agree with them; for two different errours can better agree and cotton among themselves then one errour and the nearest truth; darknesse and darknesse can better agree then light and darknesse, alwayes you will find it, men hate the nearest truth as being that light by which their deeds are reproved. The Eunomians & the Arians, though they held different errours (the one denyed the Godhead of the Sonne, the other of the Spirit) could better agree with one another then with the Orthodox, the Pharises and Herodians, though of different principles (the one being for, the other against the liberty of the Jewes) yet both could conspire together to entrapp Christ. Iebal ⟨p. 51⟩and Ammon and Amalec could better accord with one another then with Zion. In such a case truth would be worst provided for, alwaies under feares of some Sirilian vespers or a Saint Bartholomewes mattens, some suddaine eruption of violent counsels and dangers hatched against it.
- *Quod a•e•at ideo ••st•nate ut dissentie•tem augente li••••iâ non […] minantem postea plebem, &c. Petrus Mo rentinus in praefat. in Juliani miso-pugenem.Quod a•e•at ideo ••st•nate ut dissentie•tem augente li••••iâ non 〈…〉 minantem postea plebem, &c. Petrus Mo rentinus in praefat. in Iuliani miso-pugenem.
- *Passim cum omni bus miscent nihil enim interest illis licet diversa tractantibus dum ad unius veritatis exp•g•atio•em exspirent. Per lib. de praescrip. adversus Haeret cap. 41. John 3. 20