A89732:639
A discussion of that great point in divinity, the sufferings of Christ; and the…
A discussion of that great point in divinity, the sufferings of Christ; and the question about his righteousness active, passive : and the imputation thereof. Being an answer to a dialogue entitled The meritorious price of redemption, justification, &c. / By John Norton teacher of the church at Ipswich in New-England. Who was appointed to draw up this answer by the general court.A discussion of that great point in divinity, the sufferings of Christ; and the question about his righteousnesse active, passive : and the imputation thereof. Being an answer to a dialogue intituled The meritorious price of redemption, justification, &c. / By John Norton teacher of the church at Ipswich in New-England. Who was appointed to draw up this answer by the generall court.
London: printed by A.M. for Geo. Calvert, 1653
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. It is manifest that as God according to his own free constitution doth not, so man according to Gods Law may not punish a person that is simply innocent, concerning such an one that Law holds. Deut. 24.16. The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, neither shall the children be put to death for the fathers. Every man shall be put to death for his own sin. But we must here distinguish between an inherent judicial guilt, and an extrinsical judicial guilt: if Thomas be judicially guilty of a capital crime inherently, though Peter be guiltless thereof inherently, yet if he be guilty thereof extrinsically, it seemeth to be no injustice for the Magistrate in case to put Peter to death for Thomas his crime.
Answ. It is manifest that as God according to his own free constitution doth not, so man according to Gods Law may not punish a person that is simply innocent, concerning such an one that Law holds. Deut. 24.16. The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, neither shall the children be put to death for the fathers. Every man shall be put to death for his own sin. But we must here distinguish between an inherent judiciall guilt, and an extrinsecal judiciall guilt: if Thomas be judicially guilty of a capitall crime inherently, though Peter be guiltlesse thereof inherently, yet if he be guilty thereof extrinsecally, it seemeth to be no injustice for the Magistrate in case to put Peter to death for Thomas his crime.
In some cases, saith D. Willet, 1by the Law of God the surety gave life for life, as the Prophet showeth unto Ahab by this Parable, A man was taken in battle and committed to another to keep, under this condition, ⟨p. 132⟩If he be lost, thy life shall go for his life, or else thou shalt pay a Talent of silver: A price of equal value to his life that went away. But in the application of this Parable, the Prophet leaveth out the Talent because God cannot be waged with money, and saith unto Ahab precisely, thy life shall go for his life, 1 Kin. 0.39.42. The justice whereof Ahab himself (not yet considering it to be his own case) readily acknowledgeth and pronounceth sentence accordingly, ver, 40.