A90276:98
Of schism the true nature of it discovered and considered, with reference to the…Of schisme the true nature of it discovered and considered, with reference to the…
Of schism the true nature of it discovered and considered, with reference to the present differences in religion. / By John Owen D.D.Of schisme the true nature of it discovered and considered, with reference to the present differences in religion. / By John Owen D.D.
Oxford: printed by L.L. for T. Robinson, 1657
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. Apostasy or falling away from the faith of the Gospel; and thereupon forsaking the Congregations or Assemblies for the worship of God in Jesus Christ is mentioned Heb. 10. 25. [Greek or Hebrew], not wholly deserting the assembling our selves, as is the manner of some▪ A separation from, and relinquishment of the Communion of that Church, or those Churches, with whom men have assembled for the worship of God, is the guilt here charged on some by the Apostle. Upon what account they so separated themselves is declared v. 26. they sinned wilfully, after they had received the knowledge of the truth; thereby shipping out their necks from the yoke of Christ, v. 28. and drawing back to perdition v. 29. that is, they departed off to Judaism. I much question, whether any one would think fit ⟨p. 75⟩to call these men Schismatics? or whether we should so judge, or so speak of any, that in these days should forsake our Churches, and turn Mahometans; Such a departure makes men Apostates not Schismatics. Of this sort many are mentioned in the Scriptures. Nor are they accounted Schismatics, because the lesser crime is swallowed up and drowned in the greater, but because their sin is wholly of another nature.
1. Apostacy or falling away from the faith of the Gospell; and thereupon forsaking the Congregations or Assemblyes for the worship of God in Jesus Christ is mentioned Heb. 10. 25. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, not wholy deserting the assembling our selves, as is the manner of some▪ A separation from, and relinquishment of the Communion of that Church, or those Churches, with whom men have assembled for the worship of God, is the guilt here charged on some by the Apostle. Upon what account they so separated themselves is declared v. 26. they sinned willfully, after they had received the knowledge of the truth; thereby shipping out their necks from the yoke of Christ, v. 28. and drawing back to perdition v. 29. that is, they departed off to Judaisme. I much question, whether any one would think fit ⟨p. 75⟩to call these men Schismaticks? or whether we should so judge, or so speake of any, that in these dayes should forsake our Churches, and turne Mahumetans; Such a departure makes men Apostates not Schismaticks. Of this sort many are mentioned in the Scriptures. Nor are they accounted Schismaticks, because the lesser crime is swallowed up and drowned in the greater, but because their sin is wholly of another nature.
Of some,1 who withdraw themselves from Church communion, at least for a season, by their disorderly and irregular walking we have also mention. The Apostle calls them [Greek or Hebrew] 1 Thes. 5. 14. unruly, or disorderly persons, not abiding in obedience to the order prescribed by Christ in, and unto his Churches: and says, they walked [Greek or Hebrew] 2 Thess. 3 6. out of all Church order: whom he would have warned and avoided: so also [Greek or Hebrew] 2 Th. 3 2. persons that abide quietly in no place or station, but wandered up & down; whom whatever their profession be, he denies to have faith. That there were many of this sort in the Primitive times, who through a vain and slight spirit neglected, and fell off from Church Assemblies, when yet they would ⟨p. 76⟩not openly renounce the faith of Christ, is known. Of such disorderly persons we have many in our days wherein we live, whom we charge not with Schism, but vanity, folly, disobedience to the Precepts of Christ in general.
Of some,1 who withdraw themselves from Church communion, at least for a season, by their disorderly and irregular walking we have also mention. The Apostle calls them 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 1 Thes. 5. 14. unruly, or disorderly persons, not abiding in obedience to the order prescribed by Christ in, and unto his Churches: and sayes, they walked 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 2 Thess. 3 6. out of all Church order: whom he would have warned and avoided: so also 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 2 Th. 3 2. persons that abide quietly in no place or station, but wandred up & down; whom whatever their profession be, he denies to have faith. That there were many of this sort in the Primitive times, who through a vaine and slight spirit neglected, and fell off from Church Assemblyes, when yet they would ⟨p. 76⟩not openly renounce the faith of Christ, is known. Of such disorderly persons we have many in our dayes wherein we live, whom we charge not with Schisme, but vanity, folly, disobedience to the Precepts of Christ in generall.
- 1§. 5.
Men also separated themselves from the Churches of Christ upon the account of sensuality, 1that they might freely indulge to their lusts and live in all manner of pleasure all their days Jude 19. these are they that separate themselves, sensual, having not the spirit; Who are these? they that turn the grace of God into lasciviousness and that deny the Lord God, and our Saviour Jesus Christ, v. 4. that defile the flesh after the manner of Sodom and Gomorrah, v. 7, 8. that spoke evil of things they knew not, and in things they knew naturally as brute beasts they corrupted themselves v. 10. Sinning openly like beasts against the light of nature, so v. 12, 13, 16. these saith the Apostle are they that separate themselves, men given over to work all uncleanness with delight and greediness in the face of the Son, abusing themselves and justifying their Abominations with a pretence of the grace of God.
Men also separated themselves from the Churches of Christ upon the account of sensuality, 1that they might freely indulge to their lusts and live in all manner of pleasure all their dayes Jude 19. these are they that separate themselves, sensuall, having not the spirit; Who are these? they that turne the grace of God into lasciviousnesse and that deny the Lord God, and our Saviour Jesus Christ, v. 4. that defile the flesh after the manner of Sodom and Gomorrah, v. 7, 8. that spoke evill of things they knew not, and in things they knew naturally as bruit beasts they corrupted themselves v. 10. Sinning openly like beasts against the light of nature, so v. 12, 13, 16. these saith the Apostle are they that separate themselves, men given over to worke all uncleannesse with delight and greedinesse in the face of the Son, abusing themselves and justifying their Abominations with a pretence of the grace of God.
- 1§. 6.
That there is any blameable separation from,1 or relinquishment of any Church ⟨p. 77⟩or Churches of Christ, mentioned in the Scripture; but what may be referred to one of those heads, I am yet to learn. Now whether the men of these Abominations are to be accounted Schismatics, or their crime in separating themselves to be esteemed Schism, it is not hard to judge: If on any of these accounts, any persons have withdrawn themselves from the Communion of any Church of Christ, if they have on any motives of fear, or love apostatized from the faith of the Gospel, if they do it, by walking disorderly and loosely in their conversations, if they give themselves up to sensuality and uncleanness, and so be no more able to bear the society of them, whom God hath called to holiness and purity of life, and worship, they shall assuredly bear their own burden.
That there is any blameable separation from,1 or relinquishment of any Church ⟨p. 77⟩or Churches of Christ, mentioned in the Scripture; but what may be referred to one of those heads, I am yet to learne. Now whether the men of these Abominations are to be accounted Schismaticks, or their crime in separating themselves to be esteemed Schisme, it is not hard to judge: If on any of these accounts, any persons have withdrawn themselves from the Communion of any Church of Christ, if they have on any motives of feare, or love apostatized from the faith of the Gospell, if they doe it, by walking disorderly and loosely in their conversations, if they give themselves up to sensuality and uncleannesse, and so be no more able to beare the society of them, whom God hath called to holinesse and purity of life, and worship, they shall assuredly beare their own burthen.
- 1§. 7.
But none of these instances are comprehensive of the case inquired after;1 so that for a close of them, I say, for a man to withdraw or withhold himself from the communion external and visible of any Church or Churches, on the pretension and plea, be it true or otherwise, that the worship, Doctrine, discipline instituted by Christ is corrupted ⟨p. 78⟩among them, with which corruption he dares not defile himself, it is no where in the Scripture called Schism, no• is that case particularly exemplified, or expressly supposed, whereby a judgement may be made of the fact at large; but we are left upon the whole matter, to the guidance of such general principles and Rules, as are given us for that end and purpose.
But none of these instances are comprehensive of the case inquired after;1 so that for a close of them, I say, for a man to withdraw or withhold himselfe from the communion externall and visible of any Church or Churches, on the pretension and plea, be it true or otherwise, that the worship, Doctrine, discipline instituted by Christ is corrupted ⟨p. 78⟩among them, with which corruption he dares not defile himselfe, it is no where in the Scripture called Schisme, no• is that case particularly exemplified, or expressely supposed, whereby a judgement may be made of the fact at large; but we are left upon the whole matter, to the guidance of such generall principles and Rules, as are given us for that end and purpose.
- 1§. 8.
What may regularly, on the other hand,1 be deduced from the commands given to turn away from them, who have only a form of Godliness, 2 Tim. 3. 5. to withdraw from them that walk disorderly, 2 Thes. 3. 6. not to bear, nor endure in communion, men of corrupt principles, and wicked lives, Rev. 2. 14. but positively to separate from an Apostate Church, Rev. 18. 4: that in all things we may worship Christ according to his mind and appointment, what is the force of these commands [Greek or Hebrew], and the like, is without the compass of what I am now treating about.
What may regularly, on the other hand,1 be deduced from the commands given to turne away from them, who have only a forme of Godlinesse, 2 Tim. 3. 5. to withdraw from them that walk disorderly, 2 Thes. 3. 6. not to beare, nor endure in communion, men of corrupt principles, and wicked lives, Rev. 2. 14. but positively to separate from an Apostate Church, Rev. 18. 4: that in all things we may worship Christ according to his mind and appointment, what is the force of these commands 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and the like, is without the compasse of what I am now treating about.
- 1§. 9.
Of one particular Church▪ departing from that communion with another,1 or others, be it what it will, which it ought to ⟨p. 79⟩hold, unless in the departing of some of them, in some things, from the common Faith, which is supposed not to relate to Schism, in the Scripture, we have no example. Diotrephes assuming an Authority over that Church, wherein he was placed, 3 Joh. 9, 10. and for a season hindering the brethren from the performance of the duty incumbent upon them, toward the great Apostle and others, makes the nearest approach to such a division: but yet in such a distance, that it is not at all to our purpose in hand. When I come to consider that communion, that Churches have, or ought to have among themselves, this will be more fully discussed. Neither is this my sense alone, that there is no instance of any such separation as that, which is the matter of our debate, to be found in the Scripture. It is confessed by others differing from me, in and about Church affairs. To leave all ordinary communion in any Church with dislike, where opposition, or offence offers it self, is to separate from such a Church in the Scripture sense; such separation was not in being in the Apostles time, say they, Pap••accom. p. 55. But how they came to know exactly the sense of the Scripture in & about things not mentioned in them, I know not. As I said before, ⟨p. 80⟩were I unwilling, I do not as yet understand how I may be compelled to carry on the notion of Schism any farther: Nor is there need of adding any thing to demonstrate how little the conscience of a godly man, walking peaceably in any particular Church society, is concerned in all the clamorous disputes of this Age about it; being built on false Hypotheses, presumptions, and notions, no other way considerable, but as received by tradition from our Fathers.
Of one particular Church▪ departing from that communion with another,1 or others, be it what it will, which it ought to ⟨p. 79⟩hold, unlesse in the departing of some of them, in some things, from the common Faith, which is supposed not to relate to Schisme, in the Scripture, we have no example. Diotrephes assuming an Authority over that Church, wherein he was placed, 3 Joh. 9, 10. and for a season hindering the brethren from the performance of the duty incumbent upon them, toward the great Apostle and others, makes the nearest approach to such a division: but yet in such a distance, that it is not at all to our purpose in hand. When I come to consider that communion, that Churches have, or ought to have among themselves, this will be more fully discussed. Neither is this my sence alone, that there is no instance of any such separation as that, which is the matter of our debate, to be found in the Scripture. It is confessed by others differing from me, in and about Church affaires. To leave all ordinary communion in any Church with dislike, where opposition, or offence offers it selfe, is to separate from such a Church in the Scripture sence; such separation was not in being in the Apostles time, say they, Pap••accom. p. 55. But how they came to know exactly the sence of the Scripture in & about things not mentioned in them, I know not. As I said before, ⟨p. 80⟩were I unwilling, I doe not as yet understand how I may be compelled to carry on the notion of Schisme any farther: Nor is there need of adding any thing to demonstrate how little the conscience of a godly man, walking peaceably in any particular Church society, is concerned in all the clamarous disputes of this Age about it; being built on false Hypotheses, presumptions, and notions, no other way considerable, but as received by tradition from our Fathers.
- 1§. 10.
But I shall for the sake of some carry on this Discourse to a fuller issue;1 There is another common notion of Schism, which pleads to an original from that spoken expressly of it, by a parity of reason, which tolerable in it self, hath been and is injuriously applied, and used, according as it hath fallen into the hands of men, who needed it as an engine to fix or improve them in the station wherein they are, or were; & wherewith they are pleased. Indeed being invented for several purposes, there is nothing more frequent then for men, who are scarce able to keep off the force of it from their own heads, whilst managed against them by them above; at the same time vigorously to apply it for the oppression of all under ⟨p. 81⟩them. What is on all hands consented unto, as its general nature, I shall freely grant, that I might have liberty and advantage thence to debate the restriction and application of it to the several purposes of men, prevailing themselves thereon.
But I shall for the sake of some carry on this Discourse to a fuller issue;1 There is another common notion of Schisme, which pleads to an originall from that spoken expressly of it, by a parity of reason, which tolerable in it selfe, hath been and is injuriously applyed, and used, according as it hath fallen into the hands of men, who needed it as an engine to fixe or improve them in the station wherein they are, or were; & wherewith they are pleased. Indeed being invented for severall purposes, there is nothing more frequent then for men, who are scarce able to keep off the force of it from their own heads, whilest mannaged against them by them above; at the same time vigorously to apply it for the oppression of all under ⟨p. 81⟩them. What is on all hands consented unto, as its generall nature, I shall freely grant, that I might have liberty and advantage thence to debate the restriction and application of it to the severall purposes of men, prevailing themselves thereon.
- 1§. 11.
Let then the general demand be granted,1 that Schism is [Greek or Hebrew], the breach of Union; which I shall attend with one reasonable postulatum, namely, that this union be an union of the appointment of Jesus Christ; The consideration then of what, or what sort of union in reference to the worship of God according to the Gospel, is instituted & appointed by Jesus Christ, is the proper foundation of what I have farther to offer in this business. Let the breach of this if you please be accounted Schism, for being an evil, I shall not contend by what name or title it be distinguished. It is not pleaded, that any kind of relinquishment or desertion of any Church or Churches, is presently Schism, but only such a separation, as breaks the bond of Union instituted by Christ.
Let then the generall demand be granted,1 that Schisme is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, the breach of Ʋnion; which I shall attend with one reasonable postulatum, namely, that this union be an union of the appointment of Jesus Christ; The consideration then of what, or what sort of union in reference to the worship of God according to the Gospell, is instituted & appointed by Jesus Christ, is the proper foundation of what I have farther to offer in this businesse. Let the breach of this if you please be accounted Schisme, for being an evill, I shall not contend by what name or title it be distinguished. It is not pleaded, that any kind of relinquishment or desertion of any Church or Churches, is presently Schisme, but only such a separation, as breakes the bond of Ʋnion instituted by Christ.
- 1§. 12.
Now this union being instituted in the Church, according to the various acceptions of that word, so is it distinguished. Therefore for a discovery of the nature of ⟨p. 82⟩that which is particularly to be spoken to, and also its contrary, I must show
Now this union being instituted in the Church, according to the various acceptions of that word, so is it distinguished. Therefore for a discovery of the nature of ⟨p. 82⟩that which is particularly to be spoken to, and also its contrary, I must shew
1. The several considerations of the Church, wherein, and with which, union is to be preserved.
1. The severall considerations of the Church, wherein, and with which, union is to be preserved.
2. What that union is, and wherein it doth consist, which according to the mind of Christ we are to keep and observe with the Church, under the several notions of it respectively.
2. What that union is, and wherein it doth consist, which according to the minde of Christ we are to keep and observe with the Church, under the severall notions of it respectively.
3 And how that union is broken, and what is that sin whereby it is done.
3 And how that union is broken, and what is that sinne whereby it is done.
In handling this triple proposal, I desire that it may not be expected that I should much insist on any thing that falls in my way, though never so useful to my end and purpose, which hath been already proved and confirmed by others beyond all possibility of control; and such will many, if not most of the principles, that I proceed upon, appear to be.
In handling this triple proposall, I desire that it may not be expected that I should much insist on any thing that falls in my way, though never so usefull to my end and purpose, which hath been already proved and confirmed by others beyond all possibility of controule; and such will many, if not most of the principles, that I proceed upon, appeare to be.
CAP. IV.
Several Acceptations in the Scripture of the name Church. Of the Church Catholic properly so called. Of the Church visible. Perpetuity of particular Churches. A mistake rectified. The nature of the Church Catholic evinced. Bellarmine his description of the Church Catholic. Union of the Church Catholic wherein it consists. Union by way of consequence. Unity of Faith. Of Love. The Communion of the Catholic Church in, and with itself. The breach of the Union of the Church Catholic, wherein it consisteth. Not morally possible. Protestants not guilty of it. The Papal world out of interest in the Church Catholic. As partly profane. Miracles no evidence of Holiness. Partly ignorant. Self Justitiaries. Idolatrous. Worshippers of the Beast.
Severall Acceptations in the Scripture of the name Church. Of the Church Catholick properly so called. Of the Church visible. Perpetuity of particular Churches. A mistake rectifyed. The nature of the Church Catholick evinced. Bellarmine his description of the Church Catholick. Ʋnion of the Church Catholick wherein it consists. Ʋnion by way of consequence. Ʋnity of Faith. Of Love. The Communion of the Catholick Church in, and with itsselfe. The breach of the Ʋnion of the Church Catholick, wherein it consisteth. Not morally possible. Protestants not guilty of it. The Papall world out of interest in the Church Catholick. As partly profane. Miracles no evidence of Holinesse. Partly ignorant. Selfe Justitiaries. Idolatrous. Worshippers of the Beast.