A90287:116
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational…A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall…
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.
Oxford: printed by Henry Hall printer to the University for Thomas Robinson, 1657
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But he comes in the next place to Arguments, wherein if he prove more happy then he hath done in Accusations, he will have great cause to rejoice. By a double Argument, as he says, he will prove that there may be Schism besides that in a particular Church. His first is this.
But he comes in the next place to Arguments, wherein if he prove more happy then he hath done in Accusations, he will have great cause to rejoyce. By a double Argument, as he saies, he will prove that there may be Schisme besides that in a particular Church. His first is this.
Schism is a breach of Union, but there may be a breach of union in the Catholic visible church. His second this; where there are differences raised in matter of faith professed, wherein the union of the Catholic ⟨p. 126⟩Church consists, there may be a breach of union, but there may be differences in the Catholic, or among the members of the Catholic church in matter of faith professed, Ergo. Having thus laid down his Arguments, he falls to conjecture what I will answer, and how I will evade; but it will quickly appear that he is no less unhappy in arguing and conjecturing, then he is, and was in accusing. For to consider his first Argument: if he will undertake to make it good as to its form, I will by the same way of arguing, engage my self to prove what he would be unwilling to find in a regular conclusion. But as to the matter of it, 1. Is Schism every breach of union? or is every breach of Union schism? Schism in the Ecclesiastical notion is granted to be in the present dispute, the breach of the union of a church, which it hath by the institution of Christ; and this not of any union of Christs institution, but of one certain kind of union; for as was proved, there is an union, whose breach can neither in the language of the Scripture, nor in reason, nor common ⟨p. 127⟩sense be called or accounted schism, nor ever was by any man in the world, nor can be without destroying the particular nature of schism, and allowing only the general notion of any separation, good or bad, in what kind soever. So that secondly, it is granted, not only that there may be a breach of union in the Catholic church, but also that there may be a breach of the union of the Catholic church, by a denial or relinquishment of the profession wherein it consists; but that this breach of union is schism, because schism is a breach of union, is as true, as that every man who hath two eyes, is every thing that hath two eyes. For his second, it is of the same importance with the first; there may be differences in the Catholic church, and breaches of union among the members of it, which are far enough from the breach of the union of that church, as such. Two professors may fall out and differ, and yet I think continue both of them professors still. Paul and Barnabas did so; Chrysostom and Epiphanius did so; Cyril and Theodoret did so.