A90287:60
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational…A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall…
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.
Oxford: printed by Henry Hall printer to the University for Thomas Robinson, 1657
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The first words he fixes on are the first of the Chapter. The thing whereof we ⟨p. 53⟩treat being a disorder in the instituted worship of God; whereunto he replies, It is an ill sign or omen, to stumble at the threshold in going out: these words are ambiguous, and may have a double sense, either that schism is to be found in matter of instituted worship only, or only in the differences made in the time of celebrating instituted worship, and neither of these is yet true, or yet proved, and so a mere begging of the thing in question: for saith he, Schism may be in, and about other matter besides instituted worship.
The first words he fixes on are the first of the Chapter. The thing whereof we ⟨p. 53⟩treat being a disorder in the instituted worship of God; whereunto he replyes, It is an ill signe or omen, to stumble at the threshold in going out: these words are ambiguous, and may have a double sence, either that schisme is to be found in matter of instituted worship onely, or onely in the differences made in the time of celebrating instituted worship, and neither of these is yet true, or yet proved, and so a mere begging of the thing in question: for saith he, Schisme may be in, and about other matter besides instituted worship.
What measure I am to expect for the future from this entrance or beginning, is not hard to conjecture. The truth is, the Reverend Author understood me not at all, in what I affirmed: I say not, that Schism in the Church is either about instituted worship, or only in the time of worship, but that the thing I treat of, is a disorder in the instituted worship of God, and so it is, if the being, and constitution of any Church be a part of God's worship: but when men are given to disputing, they think it incumbent on them ⟨p. 54⟩to question every word and expression, that may possibly give them an advantage: but we must, now we are engaged, take all in good part as it comes. Having nextly granted my request of standing to the sole determination of Scripture in the controversy about the nature of schism: he insists on the Scripture use and notion of the word, according to what I had proposed: only in the metaphorical sense of the word, as applied unto civill and political bodies, he endeavours to make it appear, that it doth not only denote the difference and division that falls among them in judgement, but their secession also into parties; which though he proves not from any of the instances produced, yet because he may not trouble himself any further in the like kind of needless labour; I do here inform him that if he suppose that I deny that to be a Schism, where there is a separation, and that because there is a separation, as though schism were in its whole nature exclusive of all separation, and lost its being when separation ensued, he hath taken