A90287:87
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational…A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall…
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.
Oxford: printed by Henry Hall printer to the University for Thomas Robinson, 1657
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Alas, I do not in this place in the least intend to justify any separation, nor to show what pleas are sufficient to justify a separation, nor what corruption in the church separated from, is necessary ⟨p. 86⟩thereunto, nor at all regard the controversy his eye is always on; but only declare what is not comprised in the precise Scripture notion of Schism, as also how a Judgment is to be made of that which is so by me excluded, whither it be good or evil. Would he have been pleased to have spoken to the business in hand, or any thing to the present purpose, it must not have been by an inquiry into the grounds & reasons of separation, how far it may be justified by the plea mentioned, or how far not▪ when that plea is to be allowed, and when rejected; but this only was incumbent on him to prove! namely, that such a separation upon that plea, or the like, is called Schism in the Scripture, and as such a thing condemned. What my concernment is in the ensuing observations; that the Judaical Church was as corrupt as ours, that if a bare plea true or false will serve to justify men, all separatists may be justified, he himself will easily perceive: But however, I cannot but tell him by the way, that he who will dogmatize, in ⟨p. 87⟩this controversy from the Judaical Church, and the course of proceedings among them, to the direction and limitation of duty, as to the churches of the Gospel, considering the vast & important differences between t he constitutions of the one & the other, with the infallible obligation to certain principles, on the account of the typical institution in that Primitive Church, when there neither was nor could be any more in the world, must expect to bring other Arguments to compass his design, then the analogy pretended. For the justification of Separatists of the reason, if it will ensue, upon the examination for separation, and the circumstances of the separating, whereunto I refer them, let it follow, and let who will complain; But to fill up the measure of the mistake he is engaged in, he tells us pag. 75. that this is the pinch of the question, whither a man or a company of men may separate from a true Church, upon a plea of Corruption in it, true or false, & set up another Church, as to ordinances, renouncing that Church to be a true Church.
Alas, I do not in this place in the least intend to justify any separation, nor to shew what pleas are sufficient to justify a separation, nor what corruption in the church separated from, is necessary