A90287:88
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational…A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall…
A review of the true nature of schism, with a vindication of the Congregational churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.A review of the true nature of schisme, with a vindication of the Congregationall churches in England, from the imputation thereof unjustly charged on them by Mr D. Cawdrey, preacher of the Word at Billing in Northampton-shire. / By John Owen D.D.
Oxford: printed by Henry Hall printer to the University for Thomas Robinson, 1657
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This (saith he) is plainly our case at present, with the Doctor and his Associates; truly I do not know that ever I was necessitated to a more sad and fruitless employment in this kind of labour and travail. Is that the question in present agitation? is any thing, word, title, or iota spoken to it? is it my present business to state the difference between the Presbyterians and Independents? do I any where do it upon this account? do I not every where positively deny that there is any such separation made? nay can common honesty allow such a state of a question, if that were the business in hand to be put upon me? are their ordinances and churches so denied by me as is pretended? what I have often said, must again be repeated, The Reverend Author hath his eye so fixed on the difference between the Presbyterians and the Independents, that he is at every turn lead out of the way into such mistakes, as it was not possible he should otherwise be overtaken withal; this is perhaps mentis gratissimus error: But I hope it would ⟨p. 89⟩be no death to him to be delivered from it. When I laid down the principles which it was his good will to oppose, I had many things under consideration, as to the settling of Conscience in respect of manifold oppositions; and to tell him the truth, least valued that which he is pleased to manage, and to look upon as my sole intendment; if it be not possible to deliver him from this strong imagination, that carries the images and species of Independency always before his eyes, we shall scarce speak ad idem in this whole discourse. I desire then that he would take notice, that as the state of the controversy he proposes, doth no more relate to that which peculiarly is pretended to lie under his consideration, then any other thing whatever that he might have mentioned; so when the peculiar difference between him and the Independents comes to be managed, scarce any one term of his state will be allowed. Exceptions are in the next place attempted to be put in to my assertion, that there is no example in the Scripture of any one ⟨p. 90⟩Churches departure from the union which they ought to hold with others, unless it be in some of their departures from the common faith, which is not Schism; much with the same success as formerly: let him produce one instance, and, En Herbam.
This (saith he) is plainely our case at present, with the Doctor and his Associates; truly I do not know that ever I was necessitated to a more sad and fruitlesse imployment in this kind of labour and travaile. Is that the question in present agitation? is any thing, word, title, or iota spoken to it? is it my present businesse to state the difference between the Presbyterians and Independents? do I any where do it upon this account? do I not every where positively deny that there is any such separation made? nay can common honesty allow such a state of a question, if that were the businesse in hand to be put upon me? are their ordinances and churches so denied by me as is pretended? what I have often said, must again be repeated, The Reverend Author hath his eye so fixed on the difference between the Presbyterians and the Independants, that he is at every turn lead out of the way into such mistakes, as it was not possible he should otherwise be overtaken withall; this is perhaps mentis gratissimus error: But I hope it would