A90288:253
A sermon preached to the Honourable House of Commons, in Parliament assembled
A sermon preached to the Honourable House of Commons, in Parliament assembled: on January 31. A day of solemn humiliation. With a discourse about toleration, and the duty of the civill magistrate about religion, thereunto annexed. Humbly presented to them, and all peace-loving men of this nation. / By John Owen, pastor of the Church of Christ, which is at Coggeshall in Essex.A sermon preached to the Honourable House of Commons, in Parliament assembled: on January 31. A day of solemne humiliation. With a discourse about toleration, and the duty of the civill magistrate about religion, thereunto annexed. Humbly presented to them, and all peace-loving men of this nation. / By John Owen, pastor of the Church of Christ, which is at Coggeshall in Essex.
London: printed by Matthew Simmons for Henry Cripps, 1649
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This if occasion were, might be easily demonstrated from Paulus Diaconus and others. After this, from about the year 850. about which time the Iconolatrae, having ensnared the West by polity, the posterity of Charles the Great, who had stoutly opposed the worship of Images, complying with the Popes, the Fathers of that Worship for their own ends, and wearied the East by cruelty, that Contest growing towards an End, the whole power of punishing for Religion, became subservient to the Dictates of the Pope, the Kings of the Earth giving their power to the Beast, (unto which point things had ⟨p. 61⟩been working all along) from thence I say, until the death of Servctus in Geneva, the pursuit of Gentilis Blandeata, and some other mad men in Helvetia, for the space well nigh of 700 years, the chiefest season of the Reign of Satan and Antichrist, all punishing for Religion, was managed by the Authority of Rome, and against the poor witnesses of Jesus, prophesying in sackcloth, in the several Regions of the West. And what streams of blood were poured out, what Millions of Martyrs slain in that space, is known to all. Hence Bellarmine boasteth that the Albigenses were extinguished by the Sword. De Laic. cap. 22. It is true there were Laws enacted of old by Theodosius, Valentinian, Martian, as C. de haereticis, L. Manichaeis, L. Arriani. L. Unicuique; which last provideth for the death of Seducers, but yet truly, though they were made by Catholics, and in the favour of Catholics, yet considering to what end they were used, I can look upon them no otherwise, but as very bottom stones of the Tower of Babel.
This if occasion were, might be easily demonstrated from Paulus Diaconus and others. After this, from about the year 850. about which time the Iconolatrae, having ensnared the West by politie, the posterity of Charles the Great, who had stoutly opposed the worship of Images, complying with the Popes, the Fathers of that Worship for their owne ends, and wearied the East by cruelty, that Contest growing towards an End, the whole power of punishing for Religion, became subservient to the Dictates of the Pope, the Kings of the Earth giving their power to the Beast, (unto which point things had ⟨p. 61⟩been working all along) from thence I say, untill the death of Servctus in Geneva, the pursuit of Gentilis Blandeata, and some other mad men in Helvetia, for the space well nigh of 700 years, the chiefest season of the Reigne of Sathan and Antichrist, all punishing for Religion, was managed by the Authority of Rome, and against the poore witnesses of Jesus, prophecying in sackcloth, in the severall Regions of the West. And what streames of blood were poured out, what Millions of Martyrs slaine in that space, is knowne to all. Hence Bellarmine boasteth that the Albigenses were extinguished by the Sword. De Laic. cap. 22. It is true there were Lawes enacted of old by Theodosius, Valentinian, Martian, as C. de haereticis, L. Manichaeis, L. Arriani. L. Ʋnicuique; which last provideth for the death of Seducers, but yet truely, though they were made by Catholicks, and in the favour of Catholicks, yet considering to what end they were used, I can look upon them no otherwise, but as very bottome stones of the Tower of Babel.
This, then in its Latitude proving so pernicious to the profession of the Gospel, having for so long driven the Woman into the Wilderness, and truth into corners, being the main Engine whereby the Tower of Babel was built, and that, which at this day they cry Grace unto, as the foundation stone of the whole Antichristian Fabric (see Becanus de fide baereticis servanda, Bell. de Laicis, &c.) we had need be cautious, what use we make (as one terms it well) of the Broom of Antichrist, to sweep the Church of Christ. Whither that we are in the Truth, and they blinded with Error, of whom we have spoken, be a sufficient Plea, we shall see anon. In the mean time, we may do well to remember, what Lewis the twelfth of France said, yea swore concerning the Inhabitants of Mirindoll, whom by the instigation of his Prelates he had ordered to be slain, when news was brought him, what was their conversation and way of life, Let them be Heretics if you please (saith he) but assuredly they are better then me, and my Catholics. Take heed least the punished, be better then the punishers.
This, then in its Latitude proving so pernicious to the profession of the Gospell, having for so long driven the Woman into the Wildernesse, and truth into corners, being the maine Engine whereby the Tower of Babel was built, and that, which at this day they cry Grace unto, as the foundation stone of the whole Antichristian Fabrick (see Becanus de fide baereticis servanda, Bell. de Laicis, &c.) we had need be cautious, what use we make (as one tearmes it well) of the Broome of Antichrist, to sweep the Church of Christ. Whither that wee are in the Truth, and they blinded with Error, of whom wee have spoken, be a sufficient Plea, we shall see anon. In the meane time, we may doe well to remember, what Lewes the twelth of France said, yea swore concerning the Inhabitants of Mirindoll, whom by the instigation of his Prelates he had ordered to be slaine, when newes was brought him, what was their conversation and way of life, Let them be Hereticks if you please (saith he) but assuredly they are better then me, and my Catholicks. Take heed least the punished, be better then the punishers.
Let me add to this Observation only this, that the attempt ⟨p. 62⟩to suppress any Opinions whatsoever by Force, hath been for the most part fruitless; for either some few particular persons, are proceeded against, or else greater multitudes: If some particulars only, the Ashes of one, hath always proved the seed of many Opinionatiists: Examples are innumerable, take one, which is boasted of, as a pattern of severity taken from Antiquity. About the year 390. Priscillianus, a Manichee, and a Gnostic, by the procurement of Ithacius and Idacius, two Bishops, was put to death by Maximus, an usurping Emperor, who ruled for a season, having slain Gratianus; (as that kind of men, would always close with any Authority, that might serve their own Ends.) Now what was the issue thereof; Martinus a Catholic Bishop renounces their Communion who did it: The Historian, that reports it, giving this censure of the whole, Sic pessimo exemplo, sublati sunt homines luce indignissimi, though the men (Priscillian and his Companions) were most unworthy to live, yet their sentence to death, was most unjust. But no matter for this, was not the Heresy suppressed thereby? See what the same Historian, who wrote not long after, and was able to testify the event, says of it (it is Severus Sulpitius, lib. 2. Eccles. Hist.) Non solum non repressa est haeresis (sayes he) sed confirmata, & Latius propagata est, &c. The heresy was so far from being suppressed hereby, that it was confirmed and propagated: His followers who before honoured him as a Saint, now adore him as a Martyr: The like in all Ages hath been the issue, of the like endeavours.
Let me add to this Observation onely this, that the attempt ⟨p. 62⟩to suppresse any Opinions whatsoever by Force, hath been for the most part fruitlesse; for either some few particular persons, are proceeded against, or else greater multitudes: If some particulars only, the Ashes of one, hath alwayes proved the seed of many Opinionatiists: Examples are innumerable, take one, which is boasted of, as a patterne of severity taken from Antiquity. About the yeare 390. Priscillianus, a Manichee, and a Gnosticke, by the procurement of Ithacius and Idacius, two Bishops, was put to death by Maximus, an usurping Emperour, who ruled for a season, having slaine Gratianus; (as that kind of men, would always close with any Authority, that might serve their owne Ends.) Now what was the issue thereof; Martinus a Catholick Bishop renounces their Communion who did it: The Historian, that reports it, giving this censure of the whole, Sic pessimo exemplo, sublati sunt homines luce indignissimi, though the men (Priscillian and his Companions) were most unworthy to live, yet their sentence to death, was most unjust. But no matter for this, was not the Heresie suppressed thereby? See what the same Historian, who wrote not long after, and was able to testifie the event, sayes of it (it is Severus Sulpitius, lib. 2. Eccles. Hist.) Non solum non repressa est haeresis (sayes he) sed confirmata, & Latius propagata est, &c. The heresie was so farre from being suppressed hereby, that it was confirmed and propagated: His followers who before honoured him as a Saint, now adore him as a Martyr: The like in all Ages hath been the issue, of the like indeavours.
But now, if this course be undertaken against Multitudes, what is or hath been the usual End of such undertakings? Take some examples of late days: Charles the fifth, the most mighty Emperor of Germany, undertakes by violence to extirpate the Lutherans and Calvinists out of the Empire. After a tedious War, the death of many thousands, the wasting of the Nation, in the close of all, himself is driven out of Germany; and the business left much where it begun: Sleid. Come. Philip of Spain will needs force the Inquisition upon the Netherlands? What is the issue? After the expense of an Ocean of blood, and more Coin then would have purchased ⟨p. 63⟩the Country twice over, his Posterity is totally deprived of all Sovereignty over those Parts.
But now, if this course be undertaken against Multitudes, what is or hath been the usuall End of such undertakings? Take some examples of late dayes: Charles the fifth, the most mighty Emperour of Germany, undertakes by violence to extirpate the Lutherans and Calvinists out of the Empire. After a tedious Warre, the death of many thousands, the wasting of the Nation, in the close of all, himselfe is driven out of Germany; and the businesse left much where it begun: Sleid. Com. Philip of Spaine will needs force the Inquisition upon the Netherlands? What is the issue? After the expence of an Ocean of blood, and more Coyne then would have purchased ⟨p. 63⟩the Countrey twice over, his Posterity is totally deprived of all Sovereignty over those Parts.
Patrick Hamilton, and George Wishard are put to death in Scotland, by the procurement of a Cardinal; the Cardinal is instantly murdered by some desperate young men, and a war raised there about Religion, which was never well quieted, until having hunted their Queen out of her native Kingdom, she had her head chopped off in England: History of Reformation in Scotland. The Wars, Seditions, Tumults, Murders, Massacres, Rapes, Burnings, &c. that followed the same attempt in France, cannot be thought of, without horror and detestation. Neither knew those things any End, until the present forbearance, was granted. Instances might be multiplied, but these things are known to all. If any shall say, all these Evils followed, the attempting to suppress Truth not Error, I shall answer him another time, being loath to do it, unless compelled: Only for the present I shall say, that Error hath as much right, to a forcible defence, as Truth.
Patrick Hamilton, and George Wishard are put to death in Scotland, by the procurement of a Cardinall; the Cardinall is instantly murthered by some desperate young men, and a war raised there about Religion, which was never well quieted, untill having hunted their Queene out of her native Kingdome, she had her head chopt off in England: History of Reformation in Scotland. The Warres, Seditions, Tumults, Murders, Massacres, Rapes, Burnings, &c. that followed the same attempt in France, cannot be thought of, without horror and detestation. Neither knew those things any End, untill the present forbearance, was granted. Instances might be multiplyed, but these things are knowne to all. If any shall say, all these Evils followed, the attempting to suppresse Truth not Errour, I shall answer him another time, being loath to doe it, unlesse compelled: Onely for the present I shall say, that Errour hath as much right, to a forceable defence, as Truth.
6. To stir us up yet further, to a serious consideration of the grounds and reasons which are laid down, for the inflicting of punishment upon any, for Exorbitancies in things of Religion (upon what hath been said) the perpetual coincidence of the causes by them held forth, who pretend to plead for just severity, with their pretences who have acted unjust persecution, would be well heeded.
6. To stirre us up yet further, to a serious consideration of the grounds and reasons which are laid downe, for the inflicting of punishment upon any, for Exorbitancies in things of Religion (upon what hath been said) the perpetuall coincidence of the causes by them held forth, who pretend to plead for just severity, with their pretences who have acted unjust persecution, would be well heeded.
The Position is laid down in General on both sides, that Erring persons are so, and so, to be dealt withal. That such is the power and duty of the Magistrate in such cases. The definition of Heresy is agreed on for the main; only the Papists place the Churches determination, where others thrust in the Heretics conviction (a thing much more obscure to bystanders and Judges also.) The appellations wherewith truth persecuted, and error pursued, are clothed, still the same. The consequents urged on all sides, of dishonour to God, trouble to the State, and the like not at all discrepant. The arguments for the one, and other, for the most part the same. Look what Reasons one Sect gives for the punishing of another, ⟨p. 64⟩the names being changed are retorted. He blasphemeth to the Heretic, who chargeth blasphemy upon him. We use no other Arguments, cite no other Texts, press no other consequencies for the punishing of other Heretics, then the Papists the wisest Heretics breathing, do for the punishment of us.
The Position is laid downe in Generall on both sides, that Erring persons are so, and so, to be dealt withall. That such is the power and duty of the Magistrate in such cases. The definition of Heresie is agreed on for the maine; onely the Papists place the Churches determination, where others thrust in the Hereticks conviction (a thing much more obscure to bystanders and Judges also.) The appellations wherewith truth persecuted, and error pursued, are cloathed, still the same. The consequents urged on all sides, of dishonour to God, trouble to the State, and the like not at all discrepant. The arguments for the one, and other, for the most part the same. Looke what Reasons one Sect gives for the punishing of another, ⟨p. 64⟩the names being changed are retorted. He blasphemeth to the Hereticke, who chargeth blasphemy upon him. Wee use no other Arguments, cite no other Texts, presse no other consequencies for the punishing of other Hereticks, then the Papists the wisest Hereticks breathing, doe for the punishment of us.
No colour, no pretence, but hath been equally used in all hands: None can say, this is mine. To Luther's objection, that the Church of Christ never burned an Heretic, for Huss, and Hierome were none; Bellarmine answers, they were Heretics to them Catholics, which did suffice: de Laic. cap. 21. And indeed this Vicissitude of things is very pernicious. All Christians almost are Heretics to some enjoying Authority: (as Salvian said the case was, between the Homoousians and Arians in his time) and most of those enjoying authority, are persuaded it is their duty, to suppress them whom they account Heretics; and answerably have more or less acted, according to this persuasion, until by blood, Wars, and horrid devastations of Nations, some of them have been wearied: From the first Ceraysado against the Albigenses, through the War of the Hussites under Zifea and the Procopij, those dreadful Massacres, before recounted, what a stage of blood, hath Europe been made upon this account? I desire that to this point the Declaration of the Netherlands, at the beginning of their Troubles (whom Bellarmine affirms to have Petitioned for Liberty of Conscience, as he was writing de Haereticidio, the thing being long before granted at Spira, at the Convention of the States of the Empire, in the year 1526.) may be seriously considered.
No colour, no pretence, but hath been equally used in all hands: None can say, this is mine. To Luthers objection, that the Church of Christ never burned an Hereticke, for Husse, and Hierome were none; Bellarmine answers, they were Hereticks to them Catholicks, which did suffice: de Laic. cap. 21. And indeed this Vicissitude of things is very pernitious. All Christians almost are Hereticks to some enjoying Authority: (as Salvian said the case was, between the Homoousians and Arrians in his time) and most of those enjoying authority, are perswaded it is their duty, to suppresse them whom they account Hereticks; and answerably have more or lesse acted, according to this perswasion, untill by blood, Wars, and horrid devastations of Nations, some of them have been wearied: From the first Ceraysado against the Albigenses, through the Warre of the Hussites under Zifea and the Procopij, those dreadfull Massacres, before recounted, what a stage of blood, hath Europe been made upon this account? I desire that to this point the Declaration of the Netherlands, at the beginning of their Troubles (whom Bellarmine affirmes to have Petitioned for Liberty of Coscience, as he was writing de Haereticidio, the thing being long before granted at Spira, at the Convention of the States of the Empire, in the yeare 1526.) may be seriously considered.
7. For the necessity of courses of extremity, against erroneous Persons, for the upholding the Faith once delivered to the Saints, and the keeping the Churches in peace, it doth not appear to me to be so urgent as is pretended; for three hundred years, the Church had no assistance from any Magistrate against Heretics: and yet in all that space, there was not one long-lived, or far-spreading Heresy in comparison of those that followed. As the disease is spiritual, so was the remedy which in those days was applied; and the Lord ⟨p. 65⟩Jesus Christ, made it effectual. The Christians also of those days, disclaimed all thoughts of such proceedings. The expressions of the most Ancient, as Policarpus, Ignatius, Iraenaeus, concerning Heretics are sharp and cutting: Their avoiding of them being admonished, precise and severe; their confutations of them, laborious and diligent; their Church censures, and Ejections, piercing and sharp: Communion amongst the Churches, close, exact, and carefully preserved; so that a stubborn Heretic was thrust out of Christian society. But for corporal punishment to be inflicted on them, in their writings, not a syllable. Until Augustine was changed from his first resolution and persuasion, by the madness of Donatistical Circumcellions, this Doctrine had poor footing in Antiquity. And whether his reasons as to this point be convincing, let any impartial man, read his Epistle 50, and determine. What some say, the Christians would have been of another mind, had they enjoyed Christian Magistrates, is so suited to our present frame and temper, but so unworthy of them, that I should wrong them by a Defensative. What was their sense of them in a spiritual way is clear. John they say would not abide in a Bath, where Cerinthus the Heretic, infected with Judaism and Paganism was; saying, let us depart lest the building fall on us, where Cerinthus is: Iraen. lib. 3. cap. 3. Euseb. Eccles. Hist. lib. 3. cap. 25. Marcion meeting Polycarpus, and asking him whether he knew him or acknowledged him, his answer was, Yea, to be the first borne of the Devil, Euseb. lib. 4. cap. 14. Ignatius his Epistles are full of the like expressions. Iraeneus says, he would have no words with them, lib. 3. cap. 3.
7. For the necessity of courses of extremity, against erronious Persons, for the upholding the Faith once delivered to the Saints, and the keeping the Churches in peace, it doth not appeare to me to be so urgent as is pretended; for three hundred years, the Church had no assistance from any Magistrate against Hereticks: and yet in all that space, there was not one long-lived, or farre-spreading Heresie in comparison of those that followed. As the disease is spirituall, so was the remedy which in those dayes was applyed; and the Lord ⟨p. 65⟩Jesus Christ, made it effectuall. The Christians also of those dayes, disclaimed all thoughts of such proceedings. The expressions of the most Antient, as Policarpus, Ignatius, Iraenaeus, concerning Hereticks are sharpe and cutting: Their avoyding of them being admonished, precise and severe; their confutations of them, laborious and diligent; their Church censures, and Ejections, peircing and sharpe: Communion amongst the Churches, close, exact, and carefully preserved; so that a stubborne Heretick was thrust out of Christian society. But for corporall punishment to be inflicted on them, in their writings, not a syllable. Untill Augustine was changed from his first resolution and perswasion, by the madnesse of Donatisticall Circumcellions, this Doctrine had poore footing in Antiquity. And whether his reasons as to this point be convincing, let any impartiall man, read his Epistle 50, and determine. What some say, the Christians would have been of another minde, had they injoyed Christian Magistrates, is so suited to our present frame and temper, but so unworthy of them, that I should wrong them by a Defensative. What was their sense of them in a spirituall way is cleare. John they say would not abide in a Bath, where Cerinthus the Heretick, infected wtih Judaisme and Paganisme was; saying, let us depart lest the building fall on us, where Cerinthus is: Iraen. lib. 3. cap. 3. Euseb. Eccles. Hist. lib. 3. cap. 25. Marcion meeting Polycarpus, and asking him whether he knew him or acknowledged him, his answer was, Yea, to be the first borne of the Devill, Euseb. lib. 4. cap. 14. Ignatius his Epistles are full of the like expressions. Iraeneus sayes, he would have no words with them, lib. 3. cap. 3.
Tertullians Books testify for him at large, with what keenness of spirit he pursued the Heretics of his days (though before the End of them; he had the unhappiness to be almost one himself.) Cyprian cries out, Nulla cum talibus convivia, nulla colloquia, nulla commercia misceantur: Epist. 3. ad Cornel. Neither eat, nor talk, nor deal with them. Antonius the Hermit leaves Testimony when he was dying, That he never had peaceable conference with them all his days, Vita Anton▪ inter Oper. Athan. Surely, had these men perceived the mind of God for their Bodily punishment, they would not have failed ⟨p. 66⟩to signify their minds therein; but truly their expressions hold out rather the quite contrary. [Greek or Hebrew]: says Ignatius, Epist. ad Philad. Count them enemies and separate from them, but for beating or persecuting them, that is proper to the Heathen who know not God, nor our Saviour, do not you so. Tertullian in very many places, lays down general maxims tending to more Liberty then is now pleaded for; one or two places may be jointed at. Videte ne & hoc ad irreligiositatis elogium concurrat, adimere libertatem religionis, & interdicere Optionem divinitatis, ut non liceat mihi colere quem velim, sed cogar colere quem nolim. Nemose ab invito coli vellet, ne homo quidem: Apol. cap 23. And again to Scopula the Governor of Carthage to dissuade him from the Persecution he intended. Tamen humani juris & naturalis potestatis est unicuique quod putaverit colere: nec alii obest aut prodest alterius Religio: sed nec Religionis est, cogere Religionem, quae sponte, suscipi debeat, non vi; cum & hostiae ab animo libenii expostulantus; ita & si nos compuleritis ad sacrificandum, nihil praestabi is diis vestris, ab invitis enim sacrificia non disiderabunt. And I desire to know, whether that which he maketh to be the Plea of Christians, may not also be used by all erring persons. Totum quod in nos potestis, nostrum est Arbitrium. Certe si velim, Christianus sum, tunc ergo me damnabis si damnari velim. Cum vero quod in me potes, nisi velim, non potes, jam meae voluntatis est quod potes, non tuae potestatis. Apol. cap. ult. Hence was that Quaere of Lactantius: Quis imponet mihi necessitatem aut credendi quod nolim, aut quod velim non credendi: And long after these Gregory of Rome, Lib. 2. Ep. 52.
Tertullians Books testifie for him at large, with what keenesse of spirit he pursued the Hereticks of his dayes (though before the End of them; he had the unhappinesse to be almost one himself.) Cyprian cryes out, Nulla cum talibus convivia, nulla colloquia, nulla commercia misceantur: Epist. 3. ad Cornel. Neither eate, nor talke, nor deale with them. Antonius the Hermit leaves Testimony when he was dying, That he never had peaceable conference with them all his dayes, Vita Anton▪ inter Oper. Athan. Surely, had these men perceived the minde of God for their Bodily punishment, they would not have failed ⟨p. 66⟩to signifie their minds therein; but truely their expressions hold out rather the quite contrary. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: sayes Ignatius, Epist. ad Philad. Count them enemies and separate from them, but for beating or persecuting them, that is proper to the Heathen who know not God, nor our Saviour, doe not you so. Tertullian in very many places, layes downe generall maximes tending to more Liberty then is now pleaded for; one or two places may be jointed at. Videte ne & hoc ad irreligiositatis elogium concurrat, adimere libertatem religionis, & interdicere Optionem divinitatis, ut non liceat mihi colere quem velim, sed cogar colere quem nolim. Nemose ab invito coli vellet, ne homo quidem: Apol. cap 23. And againe to Scopula the Governour of Carthage to disswade him from the Persecution he intended. Tamen humani juris & naturalis potestatis est unicuique quod putaverit colere: nec alii obest aut prodest alterius Religio: sed nec Religionis est, cogere Religionem, quae sponte, suscipi debeat, non vi; cum & hostiae ab animo libenii expostulantus; ita & si nos compuleritis ad sacrificandum, nihil praestabi is diis vestris, ab invitis enim sacrificia non disiderabunt. And I desire to know, whether that which he maketh to be the Plea of Christians, may not also be used by all erring persons. Totum quod in nos potestis, nostrum est Arbitrium. Certe si velim, Christianus sum, tunc ergo me damnabis si damnari velim. Cum vero quod in me potes, nisi velim, non potes, jam meae voluntatis est quod potes, non tuae potestatis. Apol. cap. ult. Hence was that Quaere of Lactantius: Quis imponet mihi necessitatem aut credendi quod nolim, aut quod velim non credendi: And long after these Gregory of Rome, Lib. 2. Ep. 52.
tells us, Nova & inaudita est ista praedicatio, quae verberibus exigit fidem: To bea•e in Faith with stripes, was then, a new kind of Preaching. These and the like, were their Expressions.
tells us, Nova & inaudita est ista praedicatio, quae verberibus exigit fidem: To bea•e in Faith with stripes, was then, a new kinde of Preaching. These and the like, were their Expressions.
It is true, in the three first Centuries, many fond, foolish, corrupt Opinions, were broached by sundry brain sick men; but they laid little hold of the Churches, kept themselves in the breasts of some few disorderly Wanderers, and did very ⟨p. 67⟩little promote the Mystery of Iniquity: But afterwards, when the Roman Emperors, and the Great men of the Earth, under, and with them, began to interpose in the things of Religion, and were mutually wooed, instigated, and provoked by the Parties at variance (as indeed it is a shame to consider upon all meetings, assemblies, disputes councils, what running, what flattering, what insinuation at Court were used on all hands) what Root did diverse Heresies take (how far were they propagated? Witness Arianism, which had almost invaded the whole World.
It is true, in the three first Centuries, many fond, foolish, corrupt Opinions, were broached by sundry brain sick men; but they laid little hold of the Chrches, kept themselves in the breasts of some few disorderly Wanderers, and did very ⟨p. 67⟩little promote the Mysterie of Iniquity: But afterwards, when the Roman Emperours, and the Great men of the Earth, under, and with them, began to interpose in the things of Religion, and were mutually woed, instigated, and provoked by the Parties at variance (as indeed it is a shame to consider upon all meetings, assemblies, disputes councels, what running, what flattering, what insinuation at Court were used on all hands) what Roote did diverse Heresies take (how farre were they propagated? Witnesse Arrianisme, which had almost invaded the whole World.
Furthermore, by the ways which were invented oft from the Rule, for the extirpation of Errors, when by the Instigation of Prelates, the Emperors were, (to their own ruin) persuaded to them, the Man of sin walked to his Throne. Those very Laws, Edicts, and Declarations, which were obtained against erring Persons, did the Bishops of Rome invert and use against all the Witnesses of Jesus. The Devil durst not be so bold, as to employ that his grand Agent in his Apprenticeship against the Saints: But he first suffers him, to exercise his hand against Heretics, intending to make use of him afterwards to another purpose. In most of those contests, which the Roman Pontists had with their fellow Bishops, by which they insensibly advanced their own supremacy, it was the defence of Catholics they undertook, as in the case of Athanasius and others.
Furthermore, by the wayes which were invented oft from the Rule, for the extirpation of Errors, when by the Instigation of Prelates, the Emperours were, (to their owne ruin) perswaded to them, the Man of sinne walked to his Throne. Those very Lawes, Edicts, and Declarations, which were obtained against erring Persons, did the Bishops of Rome invert and use against all the Witnesses of Jesus. The Devill durst not be so bold, as to imploy that his grand Agent in his Apprentiship against the Saints: But he first suffers him, to exercise his hand against Hereticks, intending to make use of him afterwards to another purpose. In most of those contests, which the Roman Pontists had with their fellow Bishops, by which they insensibly advanced their owne supremacy, it was the defence of Catholicks they undertooke, as in the case of Athanasius and others.
Neither did the Christians of old, at once, steppe into the persuasion of punishing corporeally in case of Religion. Constantine makes a Decree at first, [Greek or Hebrew], that Liberty of worship is not to be denied, and therefore the Christians as others, should have Liberty to keep the faith of their Religion and heresy, Euseb. Eccles Hist. lib. 10. cap. 5. And in the same Edict he saith (how truly I know not, but yet Great Constantine said it) That it is most certain, that this is conducing to the peace of the Empire, that free Option and choice of Religion he left to all. Afterwards, when he begun a little further to engage himself in the business of Religion, being indeed wearied with the Petitions of Bishops and their Associates, for the persecution of one another, what troubles in a ⟨p. 68⟩few years did he intricate himself withal, perplexed he was in his spirit to see the untoward revengefulness of that sort of people; insomuch that he writes expressly to them, being assembled in Council at Tyre, That they had neither care of the truth, nor love to peace, nor conscience of scandal, nor would by any means be prevailed on to lay down their malice and animosities; Socrat. Hist. lib. 1. cap. 22. At length an Arian Priest curries favour with his Sister Constantia: She gets him into the Esteem of her Brother; after some insinuations of his, new Edicts, new Synods, new recallings, new Banishments of other persons, follow one upon the neck of another. Ruffin. Eccles. Hist. lib. 1. cap. 11. And when this knack was once found out, of promoting a Sect by Imperial favour, it is admirable to consider how those good Princes, Constantine and his Sons, were abused, misled, enraged, engaged into mutual Dissensions, by the Lies, flatteries, equivocations of such as called themselves Bishops, Ruff. lib. 1. cap. 15, 16, &c. As also how soon with the many, the whole business of Religion was hereupon turned into a matter, of external Pomp and Dominion. But it is besides my purpose, to rase into that Hell of confusion, which by this means, brake in upon the Churches in succeeding Ages. Only, for the following Imperial Edicts and Constitutions in the behalf of the faith Catholic, and for the punishing of Erring Persons, I desire to observe,
Neither did the Christians of old, at once, steppe into the perswasion of punishing corporeally in case of Religion. Constantine makes a Decree at first, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that Liberty of worship is not to be denyed, and therefore the Christians as others, should have Liberty to keep the faith of their Religion and heresie, Euseb. Eccles Hist. lib. 10. cap. 5. And in the same Edict he saith (how truely I know not, but yet Great Constantine said it) That it is most certaine, that this is conducing to the peace of the Empire, that free Option and choyce of Religion he left to all. Afterwards, when he begun a little further to ingage himselfe in the businesse of Religion, being indeed wearied with the Petitions of Bishops and their Associates, for the persecution of one another, what troubles in a ⟨p. 68⟩few yeares did he intricate himselfe withall, perplexed he was in his spirit to see the untoward revengefulnesse of that sort of people; insomuch that he writes expresly to them, being assembled in Counsell at Tyre, That they had neither care of the truth, nor love to peace, nor conscience of scandall, nor would by any meanes be prevailed on to lay downe their malice and animosities; Socrat. Hist. lib. 1. cap. 22. At length an Arrian Priest curryes favour with his Sister Constantia: Shee gets him into the Esteeme of her Brother; after some insinuations of his, new Edicts, new Synods, new recallings, new Banishments of other persons, follow one upon the neck of another. Ruffin. Eccles. Hist. lib. 1. cap. 11. And when this knack was once found out, of promoting a Sect by Imperiall favour, it is admirable to consider how those good Princes, Constantine and his Sonnes, were abused, misled, inraged, ingaged into mutuall Dissensions, by the Lyes, flatteries, equivocations of such as called themselves Bishops, Ruff. lib. 1. cap. 15, 16, &c. As also how soone with the many, the whole businesse of Religion was hereupon turned into a matter, of externall Pompe and Dominion. But it is besides my purpose, to rase into that Hell of confusion, which by this meanes, brake in upon the Churches in succeeding Ages. Onely, for the following Imperiall Edicts and Constitutions in the behalfe of the faith Catholicke, and for the punishing of Erring Persons, I desire to observe,
1. That the Emperors were stirred up to them, by Turbulent Priests, and aspiring Prelates; let the Popes letters to them witness this, Leo Epist. 75, &c.
1. That the Emperours were stirred up to them, by Turbulent Priests, and aspiring Prelates; let the Popes letters to them witnesse this, Leo Epist. 75, &c.
2. That they were still bottomed, upon such, and such, councils, that were not to be opposed or spoken against, when all of them were spent for the most part, about things quite besides and beyond the Scripture (as feastings, and fastings, and Bishops jurisdictions) and some of them, were the very ulcers, and impostumations of Christian Religion, as those of Nice and Ephesus, both the second; and in general all of them the Sea, upon which the Whore exalted her seat and throne; and these things did those good men, either deceived by the craft of Heretics, or wearied by the importunity of the Orthodox.
2. That they were still bottomed, upon such, and such, counsells, that were not to be opposed or spoken against, when all of them were spent for the most part, about things quite besides and beyond the Scripture (as feastings, and fastings, and Bishops jurisdictions) and some of them, were the very ulcers, and impostumations of Christian Religion, as those of Nice and Ephesus, both the second; and in generall all of them the Sea, upon which the Whore exalted her seat and throne; and these things did those good men, either deceived by the craft of Hereticks, or wearied by the importunity of the Orthodox.