A92140:22
A free disputation against pretended liberty of conscience tending to resolve doubts moved
A free disputation against pretended liberty of conscience tending to resolve doubts moved by Mr. John Goodwin, John Baptist, Dr. Jer. Taylor, the Belgic Arminians, Socinians, and other authors contending for lawless liberty, or licentious toleration of sects and heresies. / By Samuel Rutherfurd professor of divinity in the University of St. Andrews.A free disputation against pretended liberty of conscience tending to resolve doubts moved by Mr. John Goodwin, John Baptist, Dr. Jer. Taylor, the Belgick Arminians, Socinians, and other authors contending for lawlesse liberty, or licentious toleration of sects and heresies. / By Samuel Rutherfurd professor of divinity in the University of St. Andrews.
London: printed by R.I. for Andrew Crook, 1649
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Chap. 4. The State of the question of compulsion of Conscience and toleration p. 46. Opinions cannot be compelled, nor the mind or will in the elicit acts ibid. ⟨image 5⟩The question is, Whether the Magistrate may compulsorily restrain the external act of the outward man in religion. ibid. Shame and fear of rebukes, by Pastors and Church-censures have the same compulsory influences on false Teachers, that the fear of public punishment by the Synod hath p. 47. Church censures are as compulsory on the Conscience, as coercing by the Sword p. 48 Some external actions of injustice flowing from mere conscience are punished justly, without any note of persecution by grant of Libertines, and why not all others also? p. 49 Ancient bonds of Liberty of Conscience p. 50 Discountenancing of men and negative punishing of them for their Conscience is punishing of them ibid. Ancient bonds p. 12. ibid. How Religion may be compelled, how not p. 51 One mans Religion remaining in the mind and will, may hurt or benefit the man himself, not any others: but true religion, as it comes forth into acts of teaching may edify and win others, and false religion may subvert the faith of others. ibid. The Magistrate does not command religious acts as service to God, but rather forbids their contraries, as disservice to Christian Societies ibid. How Tertullian and Lactantius are to be expounded of forcing to Heathen religion ibid. Though we can compel none to Religion it follows not that the Magistrate may not punish those that seduce others to a false religion ibid. Lactantius speaks of compulsion without all teaching p. 53 Those that are without the Church are not to be compelled ibid. Because the Magistrates compulsion makes Hypocrites it followeth note he should not punish Heretics, for so he should not punish murderers. p. 54 The Magistrate may by the sword curb such impediments, that keep men from embracing the truth, according to Augustine p. 56 Answer to Doctor Adam Stewart ibid. Impotency of free will objected by Master John Goodwin, no reason why the Magistrate ought not to punish seducing teachers, as of old the Donatists objected. ibid. State of the question more strictly proposed p.
Chap. 4. The State of the question of compulsion of Conscience and toleration p. 46. Opinions cannot be compelled, nor the mind or will in the elicite acts ibid. ⟨image 5⟩The question is, Whether the Magistrate may compulsorily restrain the externall act of the outward man in religion. ibid. Shame and feare of rebukes, by Pastors and Church-censures have the same compulsorie influences on false Teachers, that the fear of publike punishment by the Synod hath p. 47. Church censures are as compulsorie on the Conscience, as coercing by the Sword p. 48 Some externall actions of injustice flowing from meer conscience are punished justly, without any note of persecution by grant of Libertines, and why not all others also? p. 49 Ancient bonds of Libertie of Conscience p. 50 Discountenancing of men and negative punishing of them for their Conscience is punishing of them ibid. Ancient bonds p. 12. ibid. How Religion may be compelled, how not p. 51 One mans Religion remaining in the mind and will, may hurt or benefit the man himself, not any others: but true religion, as it comes forth into acts of teaching may edifie and win others, and false religion may subvert the faith of others. ibid. The Magistrate does not command religious acts as service to God, but rather forbids their contraries, as disservice to Christian Societies ibid. How Tertullian and Lactantius are to be expounded of forcing to Heathen religion ibid. Though we can compel none to Religion it follows not that the Magistrate may not punish those that seduce others to a false religion ibid. Lactantius speakes of compulsion without all teaching p. 53 Those that are without the Church are not to be compelled ibid. Because the Magistrates compulsion makes Hypocrites it followeth note hee should not punish Hereticks, for so he should not punish murtherers. p. 54 The Magistrate may by the sword curbe such impediments, that keep men from embracing the truth, according to Augustine p. 56 Answer to Doctor Adam Stewart ibid. Impotencie of free will objected by Master John Goodwin, no reason why the Magistrate ought not to punish seducing teachers, as of old the Donatists objected. ibid. State of the question more strictly proposed p.