A92147:653
A treatise of civil policy
A treatise of civil policy: being a resolution of forty three questions concerning prerogative, right and privilege, in reference to the supreme prince and the people. / By Samuel Rutherford professor of divinity of St Andrews in Scotland.A treatise of civil policy: being a resolution of forty three questions concerning prerogative, right and priviledge, in reference to the supream prince and the people. / By Samuel Rutherford professor of divintiy of St Andrews in Scotland.
London, : Printed and are to be sold by Simon Miller at the Star in St Pauls Church-yard near the West end., 1657 i.e. 1656
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. I understand not a difference betwixt forcible restraining and legal restraining: For he must mean by (legal) mans Law, ⟨p. 115⟩because he saith, It is a Law in the Covenant betwixt the Monarch, and his people. Now if this be not forcible, and physical, it is1 only Moral in the conscience of the King, and a Cypher, and a mere vanity, for God, not the people putteth a restraint of conscience on the King, that he may not oppress his poor subjects; but he shall sin against God, that is a poor restraint: the goodness of the King a sinful man inclined from the womb to all sin, and so to Tyranny, is no restraint. 2. There's no necessity, that the reserve be expressed in the Covenant between King, and people, more then in contract of marriage between a husband and a wife, beside her jointure; you should set down this clause in the contract, that if the husband attempt to kill the wife, or the wife the husband, in that case it shall be lawful to either of them to part companies: For Doct. Ferne saith, That personal defence is lawful in the people, if the Kings assault be 1. Sudden. 2. Without colour of Law. 3. Inevitable: Yet the reserve of this power of defence, is not necessarily to be expressed in the contract, betwixt King and people. Exigences of the Law of nature cannot be set down in positive Covenants, they are presupposed. 3. He saith, A reservation of power, whereby sovereignty is not secured, is unlawful. Lend me this Argument: The giving away of a power of defence, and a making the King absolute, is unlawful, because by it the people is not secured; but one man hath thereby the sword of God put2 in his hand, whereby ex officio, he may as King cut the throats of thousands, and be countable to none therefore, but to God only: now if the non-securing of the King, make a condition unlawful, the non-securing of a Kingdom and Church, yea, of the true religion (which are infinitely in worth above one single man) may far more make the condition unlawful. 4. A legal restraint on a King, is no more unprofitable, and a seminary of jealousies between King and people, then a legal restraint upon people; for the King out of a non-restraint, as out of seed, may more easily educe tyranny, and subversion of religion:
Answ. I understand not a difference betwixt forceable restraining and legall restraining: For he must mean by (legall) mans Law,