A92287:110
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly…
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly presented.
London: printed by G.M. for Ralph Smith, 1645
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And last of all, there is no act of such authority and government put forth in it, which the Proposition intendeth; which will appear, if we either consider the occasion and rise of it, or the issue and result of it.
And last of all, there is no act of such authority and government put forth in it, which the Proposition intendeth; which will appeare, if wee either consider the occasion and rise of it, or the issue and result of it.
It was not a set or stated meeting by common agreement of the Churches, but Antioch sends to Jerusalem unknown to them; there are no summons sent to send up Delinquents, nor can we find these disturbers are sent to Jerusalem to be censured by those Ecclesiastical punishments in which, Government doth properly lye and consist; The subject matter sent to them for their decision was merely matter of Doctrine, about this question, verse 2. and about this word, verse 5. Namely, whether the Ceremonial Law was to be observed? Concerning which they wrote their judgements dogmatically, which they were called to do, being thus sent unto; Neither doth it argue that it was more then to determine this question doctrinally they came up for, because that Paul and Barnabas could have decided that before, being themselves Apostles, and that therefore their coming up was for discipline against Delinquents; for as the case stood, they listened not to Paul and Barnabas as Apostles, but pretended the judgment of the other Apostles; For indeed Paul and Barnabas did declare their judgements, the [Greek or Hebrew], or contention, ver. 3. being attributed unto them as contending against the false Teachers for the Truth; and so as even the Church of Antioch rested not in their decision: Otherwise Paul and Barnabas might have as Apostles censured those Delinquents without coming to Jerusalem, as well as by Apostolic authority have decided the question. For Apostolical power extended to Discipline as well as Doctrine. If it be said That even doctrinally to deliver the truth when it is done by a company of Elders hath authority or power in it, as when Christ said, Go and teach, all power is given unto me: It is granted an Authority exercised in doctrine and so to be in Synods, but yet not Jurisdiction, which the Proposition intends, which is when doctrines are delivered sub paena, under the penalty of that Ecclesiastical punishment of Excommunication if not received. One Minister alone hath a dogmatical authority as a Minister to rebuke, exhort, and yet acts of Jurisdiction are not his alone, but of others conjoined with him.