A92287:35
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly…
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly presented.
London: printed by G.M. for Ralph Smith, 1645
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And then how to proportion this, suppose it should not be maintenance, but honour and esteem, this people will not be able to judge, not only for that they cannot be present at their work and so cannot judge of it, but because either it must be proportioned to them as constant Preaching-Elders, or as Ruling; not as to Preaching Elders, for they labour not to them as such; the ground upon which it is required is, That they tread out their Corn, and to honour and esteem them as Ruling Elders only, were to honour preaching Elders below the rank and degree of their Office. So
And then how to proportion this, suppose it should not be maintenance, but honour and esteeme, this people will not be able to judge, not only for that they cannot be present at their worke and so cannot judge of it, but because either it must be proportioned to them as constant Preaching-Elders, or as Ruling; not as to Preaching Elders, for they labour not to them as such; the ground upon which it is required is, That they tread out their Corne, and to honour and esteeme them as Ruling Elders only, were to honour preaching Elders below the ranke and degree of their Office. So
Secondly, It brings the like Incongruities upon the performance of those duties of Elders, which the New Testament indifferently requires of all those that it acknowledgeth to be Elders unto a people, and therefore no such constant relation of Elders to so many Churches may be. As first, Praying with the sick, Send for the Elders of the Church to pray for them, James chap. 5. ver. 14. What, are these Elders of a Presbyterial Church bound hereto? this duty lies in common upon Elders of Churches, and how shall we distinguish when the Scripture doth not. Secondly, Visiting from house to house, as Paul in his example instructs the Elders of Ephesus, Acts chap. 20. ver. 20. Thirdly, Watching over mens souls, as those that must give an account, Heb. chap. 13. ver. 17. To watch, is not to stay till causes are brought by appeals or so from the Congregations, but personally to observe and oversee them, as souls committed to them, which they must give an account for. Fourthly, Of Preaching, If Preaching Elders in season and out of season. The Bishops, they said the flock was theirs, and the whole care committed to them: and to salve the incongruity of not being able to preach themselves to them, they professed a derivative delegated power to inferior Pastors, whom they called their Curates. This was plain dealing: but these Elders make all the whole flock theirs, and this from those