A92287:37
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly…
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly presented.
London: printed by G.M. for Ralph Smith, 1645
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
If it be said, that they may part these duties among them, ubi Scriptura non distinguit, nec nos debemus distinguere. Now all those duties that are spoken of Elders to the flocks, they are without distinction, as in respect of the object to whom they are extended. Paul saith to those of Ephesus, Feed the flock. Peter the like to those he writes to, The flock, [Greek or Hebrew] respectively, To feed and to take the oversight of them. The author to the Hebrews, To watch over their souls; And to the Thessalonians, he describes them to be those that are over them, and labour and admonish them. When those Injunctions are thus laid upon all, how shall the conscience of Elders be able to part and distinguish their discharge of them, and to say, though I am an Elder in common to all in these Congregations, yet I am bound but to govern them in greater matters, and to admonish them as with others, when publicly met in a Consistory, and am bound to no other acts of Eldership; and yet to this particular Congregation, I am obliged to private admonition, rule, watchfulness, &c. Where hath the Scripture set these bounds, or thus parted them? And therefore certainly all these places hold forth singly, only the Elders and their duties of a particular Church fixed thereto, as knowing no other: 'Twas necessary Christ should have set the bounds and given the distinction, and not indifferently lay all these upon all. And either in these places the duties of Elders in a common Presbytery are contained, and that, under the notion of Elders to those, or they are not to be found in the New Testament; And all these may be brought in several Arguments alone by themselves against the main Proposition, though here they come in only as branches of the Minor.
If it be said, that they may part these duties among them, ubi Scriptura non distinguit, nec nos debemus distinguere. Now all those duties that are spoken of Elders to the flocks, they are without distinction, as in respect of the object to whom they are extended. Paul saith to those of Ephesus, Feed the flock. Peter the like to those he writes to, The flock, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 respectively, To feed and to take the oversight of them. The author to the Hebrewes, To watch over their soules; And to the Thessalonians, he describes them to be those that are over them, and labour and admonish them. When those Injunctions are thus laid upon all, how shall the conscience of Elders be able to part and distinguish their discharge of them, and to say, though I am an Elder in common to all in these Congregations, yet I am bound but to governe them in greater matters, and to admonish them as with others, when publickly met in a Consistorie, and am bound to no other acts of Eldership; and yet to this particular Congregation, I am obliged to private admonition, rule, watchfulnesse, &c. Where hath the Scripture set these bounds, or thus parted them? And therfore certainly all these places hold forth singly, only the Elders and their duties of a particular Church fixed thereto, as knowing no other: 'Twas necessary Christ should have set the bounds and given the distinction, and not indifferently lay all these upon all. And either in these places the duties of Elders in a common Presbyterie are contained, and that, under the notion of Elders to those, or they are not to be found in the New Testament; And all these may be brought in severall Arguments alone by themselves against the maine Proposition, though here they come in only as branches of the Minor.