A92287:43
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly…
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly presented.
London: printed by G.M. for Ralph Smith, 1645
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
IN regard that the main Argumentation of such as contend for a Presbyterial government (as in their writings and otherwayes appears) is from the mention of the Elders of such and such a Church as, Jerusalem, &c. having many Congregations (as they suppose) the consequence of the Major was taken so much for granted as on all sides agreed on, as it was less insisted upon the first day; but being denied and answered thus, that they bear not the relation ⟨p. 12⟩of Elders, but of a Presbyterie, because, quod convenit toti quâ toti non convenit cuilibet party; And that if Elders, yet in sensu composito non diviso, As a Colonel is a Colonel to a particular Regiment, but in a Council of War, not so to all Regiments: A head of a particular Tribe is an head to his own Tribe divisively, but not so to all the Tribes, and the like.
IN regard that the maine Argumentation of such as contend for a Presbyteriall government (as in their writings and otherwayes appeares) is from the mention of the Elders of such and such a Church as, Jerusalem, &c. having many Congregations (as they suppose) the consequence of the Major was taken so much for granted as on all sides agreed on, as it was lesse insisted upon the first day; but being denied and answered thus, that they bear not the relation ⟨p. 12⟩of Elders, but of a Presbyterie, because, quod convenit toti quâ toti non convenit cuilibet parti; And that if Elders, yet in sensu composito non diviso, As a Colonell is a Colonell to a particular Regiment, but in a Councell of War, not so to all Regiments: A head of a particular Tribe is an head to his own Tribe divisively, but not so to all the Tribes, and the like.
For that Logical Axiom, 'tis true, quod convenit toti quâ toti non convenit cuilibet party, and so here, that which doth competere toti, to the whole of these Elders, belongs not to every part; for take them all as met together, they are a Presbytery, and accordingly each Elder is not a Presbytery to all these Congregations, nor doth the Argument suppose it, but only that if they be a common Presbytery to all these Congregations, that they then bear the relation of Elders. As take an heap of stones, 'tis true each stone is not an heap of stones, but each stone is a stone in that heap. So this Company of Elders, must be supposed both a Presbytery, and also Elders to this whole people and every member of them: which is farther proved thus;