A92287:54
The reasons of the Dissenting Brethren against the third proposition, concerning presbyterial government· Humbly presented.
London: printed by G.M. for Ralph Smith, 1645
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. In the beginnings of that Church, their meetings are set out to us by two Adjuncts. First, that they met [Greek or Hebrew], with one accord in the same duty of prayer, Acts Chap. 1. Verse 14. And secondly, [Greek or Hebrew], together in one and the same company, Verse 15. Which therefore is there and usually translated in one place. And that here by these words the intent of the Holy Ghost is to show their meeting in one and the same Assembly, is evident. For whereas in the 15 Verse 'tis said, Peter stood up in the middest of them, as therefore being present together in one company, he adds, And the number of them that were [Greek or Hebrew], that is, Present together in company, were an hundred and twenty.
1. In the beginnings of that Church, their meetings are set out to us by two Adjuncts. First, that they met 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, with one accord in the same duty of prayer, Acts Chap. 1. Verse 14. And secondly, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, together in one and the same company, Verse 15. Which therefore is there and usually translated in one place. And that here by these words the intent of the Holy Ghost is to shew their meeting in one and the same Assembly, is evident. For whereas in the 15 Verse 'tis said, Peter stood up in the middest of them, as therefore being present together in one company, he addes, And the number of them that were 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is, Present together in company, were an hundred and twenty.
2. Then Chap. 2. Verse 1. Another meeting of theirs for worship at Pentecost is continued to be expressed in the same phrases a second time, They were all with one accord in one place.
3. Then when about three thousand, yet still some of their meetings then for some acts of worship are recorded to have been as before with one accord, as joining unanimously in the same duty, and in stead of that former expression [Greek or Hebrew] used of the former meetings, there is the mention of the place it self, where they met, set down to supply it, and so to interpret it, and shows it was still in one Assembly, Verse 46. They continued daily with one accord in the Temple, as mentioning the very place where they had their most frequent meetings which were for hearing, as being there altogether in one Assembly; and not as coming thither only for Jewish worship: For it is said of these as of the former meetings mentioned, which were proper to themselves, That they continued with one accord. And though they held these meetings in this place for preaching, that the Jews might be present to hear, &c. Yet that hindered not, but it was a Church meeting to them, wherein they continued with one accord; which expression is still used of all their Christian meetings throughout this Story, Acts 1. 14. Acts 4. 24. Acts 5. 12. Acts 15. 25.
3. Then when about three thousand, yet still some of their meetings then for some acts of worship are recorded to have been as before with one accord, as joyning unanimously in the same duty, and in stead of that former expression 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 used of the former meetings, there is the mention of the place it selfe, where they met, set downe to supply it, and so to interpret it, and shewes it was still in one Assembly, Verse 46. They continued daily with one accord in the Temple, as mentioning the very place where they had their most frequent meetings which were for hearing, as being there altogether in one Assembly; and not as comming thither only for Jewish worship: For it is said of these as of the former meetings mentioned, which were proper to themselves, That they continued with one accord. And though they held these meetings in this place for preaching, that the Jewes might be present to hear, &c. Yet that hindred not, but it was a Church meeting to them, wherein they continued with one accord; which expression is stil used of al their Christian meetings throughout this Story, Acts 1. 14. Acts 4. 24. Acts 5. 12. Acts 15. 25.
4. When there was a further addition to these, Chap. 5. Verse 1. (whether to five thousand or no is spoken to afterwards) yet in that Chapter, he making a description of their State, in almost all the very same particulars by which he had done it before, Chap. 2. from Verse 43. unto the end (as by the parallel comparing of these two passages of the Story will appear;) he lastly speaking of a meeting of theirs (which is the point in hand) as carefully puts in, as in the former. Verse 14. And they were all with one accord in Solomons Porch, the same words he had used Chap. 2. Verse 46. Their union and joining together with one accord being carefully indigitated, and the place named in stead of [Greek or Hebrew], as was observed before. And that the [All that met] were not the Apostles only, appears not only by the forementioned parallel of this with Chap. 2. Verse 46. where their being with one accord in the Temple, is spoken of all the multitude, and so here. But secondly, that all the Apostles should be met with one accord in any duty, and not the people who are said to continue in the Apostles Doctrine and Prayer, and [Greek or Hebrew] or with one accord still in the story of this Church referring to communion in some holy duty, as Chap. 1. Verse 14. and Chap. 4. Verse 24. is most unlikely. And Solomons Porch was a place large enough to hold them, and fitted for preaching and to hear, which in John 10. Verse 22. is called the Temple; and so is the place intended in Acts 2. Verse 46. They met in the Temple, that is, in the Porch of Solomon. It was the outer Court as Josephus lib. 20. cap. 8. It was the place where CHRIST used to walk and preach, and the Apostles also, Chap. 3. Verse 11. The multitude ran to Solomons Porch.
4. When there was a further addition to these, Chap. 5. Verse 1. (whether to five thousand or no is spoken to afterwards) yet in that Chapter, he making a description of their State, in almost all the very same particulars by which he had done it before, Chap. 2. from Verse 43. unto the end (as by the paralell comparing of these two passages of the Story will appear;) he lastly speaking of a meeting of theirs (which is the point in hand) as carefully puts in, as in the former. Verse 14. And they were all with one accord in Solomons Porch, the same words he had used Chap. 2. Verse 46. Their union and joyning together with one accord being carefully indigitated, and the place named in stead of , as was observed before. And that the [All that met] were not the Apostles only, appears not only by the forementioned paralell of this with Chap. 2. Verse 46. where their being with one accord in the Temple, is spoken of all the multitude, and so here. But secondly, that all the Apostles should be met with one accord in any duty, and not the people who are said to continue in the Apostles Doctrine and Prayer, and or with one accord still in the story of this Church referring to communion in some holy duty, as Chap. 1. Verse 14. and Chap. 4. Verse 24. is most unlikely. And Solomons Porch was a place large enough to hold them, and fitted for preaching and to hear, which in
5. When again upon mention of this multiplication of Disciples, the Deacons are to be chosen, the Apostles called the multitude Chap. 6. Ver. 2. and not persons selected, but all; for Verse 5. they are called the whole multitude, and they are spoken to as together, For the saying pleased the whole, and the whole chose seven men out from among them, and set them before the Apostles, Ver▪ 6. as being in one place together, and they prayed (in which the multitude had an interest to join with them) and laid on them hands. And this meeting was certainly a Church meeting, and yet still in some one place; and therefore though it might follow that always they should not have met together in one, yet they both did and could.
5. When againe upon mention of this multiplication of Disciples, the Deacons are to be chosen, the Apostles called the multitude Chap. 6. Ver. 2. and not persons selected, but all; for Verse 5. they are called the whole multitude, and they are spoken to as together, For the saying pleased the whole, and the whole chose seven men out from among them, and set them before the Apostles, Ver▪ 6. as being in one place together, and they prayed (in which the multitude had an interest to joyne with them) and laid on them hands. And this meeting was certainly a Church meeting, and yet still in some one place; and therefore though it might follow that alwayes they should not have met together in one, yet they both did and could.
6. After that great dispersion mentioned Chap. 8. ver. 1. Then as they might more conveniently meet in one place and assembly, so that they did so, it is as carefully recorded, that so the Holy Ghost might hold forth this from the first unto the last mention of this Church, Acts 15. Acts 21. 22. The multitude must needs come together. And to interpret [Greek or Hebrew], or with one accord, which the Holy Ghost carries through all, to be intended of the joining of the same persons in the same act of worship (for which they still did meet) ⟨p. 17⟩is genuine; for it imports that which is the spirit and life of public worship, which of all other actions done by a multitude is to have the nearest union of spirits, as that wherein the Communion of Saints in worship consists. And then naming the place where they met also it must needs import Oneness of Assembly, which also holds forth in this example this duty▪ That as Saints when met in worship should join with one accord, so living in a place together, should as far as possibly may, join themselves to one Assembly; and this carries with it such an appearance as is not in the other sense. And that the Holy Ghost should in the same Story of the same Church set forth the unity of their first meetings, as in one and the same individual Assembly, by this expression of being in one, and with one accord, Acts▪ Chap. 1. Chap. 2. and in the next mention not far off, carry along one of the same expressions, namely [with one accord] and together therewith shall name the place of their meeting, and yet in the latter intend not One, but meetings in several companies in that place. This we humbly submit to better judgements.
6. After that great dispersion mentioned Chap. 8. ver. 1. Then as they might more conveniently meet in one place and assembly, so that they did so, it is as carefully recorded, that so the Holy Ghost might hold forth this from the first unto the last mention of this Church, Acts 15. Acts 21. 22. The multitude must needs come together. And to interpret , or with one accord, which the Holy Ghost carries through all, to be intended of the joyning of the same persons in the same act of worship (for which they still did meet)
1. For the mention of five thousand, Chap. 4. Verse 4. This cannot be evinced from that place that the five thousand were a new number added to the three thousand. The words are these, Howbeit many of them that heard the word, believed, and the number of the men was about five thousand. But that this number of five thousand should refer to them that believed, is not certain; seeing both the Greek will bear it and favour it, as well to be meant of the number that heard, as of the men that believed; and of the two, that former is the more probable, that he should say of the men that heard they were five thousand, and that of them that heard many believed, this sounds well, and is no way forced; but five thousand men to be converted at once, is that which was never afore nor since. And the great conversion that our Divines have instanced in, is the three thousand, Acts Chap. 2. and not in this five thousand. And if the scope of the Holy Ghost therein, why the number of the men that heard should be here reckoned to be five thousand be asked after, it was to show what had occasioned the persecution which he had spoken of in the Verse before. Namely this, that such a multitude of the people should be taught and preached to; this fretted the Pharisees that came upon Peter and John; and with this agrees1 the second Verse, that they were grieved they taught the people; the effect whereof is, that many of them that heard believed, notwithstanding this persecution, but how many of these is not certain. And Beza and Calvin ⟨p. 18⟩and many others of our protestant Writers judge this number not to be of this new accession of Converts, but the total number including the former, and the [Greek or Hebrew], although translated men, is when put alone (as there) all one with [Greek or Hebrew] Females, as well as Males, which especially may be so taken, because it is spoken of such a promiscuous auditory. And if any should affirm it meant of Males only, and them now converted, it would make a greater Miracle then any other recorded, especially when the people are said to be converted, Verse 2. that did alike run to see the Miracle.
1. For the mention of five thousand, Chap. 4. Verse 4. This cannot be evinced from that place that the five thousand were a new number added to the three thousand. The words are these, Howbeit many of them that heard the word, believed, and the number of the men was about five thousand. But that this number of five thousand should refer to them that believed, is not certaine; seeing both the Greek will bear it and favour it, as well to be meant of the number that heard, as of the men that believed; and of the two, that former is the more probable, that he should say of the men that heard they were five thousand, and that of them that heard many believed, this sounds well, and is no way forced; but five thousand men to be converted at once, is that which was never afore nor since. And the great conversion that our Divines have instanced in, is the three thousand, Acts Chap. 2. and not in this five thousand. And if the scope of the Holy Ghost therein, why the number of the men that heard should be here reckoned to be five thousand be asked after, it was to shew what had occasioned the persecution which he had spoken of in the Verse before. Namely this, that such a multitude of the people should be taught and preached to; this fretted the Pharisees that came upon Peter and John; and with this agrees
2 Exception is, That it may be supposed that all that are mentioned to be converted remained not constant members of that Church abiding at Jerusalem until the dispersion; and so, though the Holy Ghosts scope may be to show the increase of Converts to the faith, yet not of such as continued all that while at Jerusalem; and our reasons for that are these.
2 Exception is, That it may be supposed that all that are mentioned to be converted remained not constant members of that Church abiding at Jerusalem untill the dispersion; and so, though the Holy Ghosts scope may be to shew the increase of Converts to the faith, yet not of such as continued all that while at Jerusalem; and our reasons for that are these.
First those three thousand who were converted, Chap. 2. were not settled dwellers at Jerusalem, but strangers, Commorants of the ten Tribes, which were dispersed in all those Countries mentioned in the 2 Chapter, Verse 9. who came up to the feast of Pentecost, as the manner of the Jews was, Acts 21. 20, 27, 28. Jews that lived in Asia came to the feast of Pentecost as Paul also did, compared with Acts 20. 16. And the word which is translated Dwellers at Jerusalem, is interpreted by an eminent Critic, Sojourners at Jerusalem during this Feast, although the word1 signifies both, and to that end quotes the Septuagint in 1. Kings 17. 20. where Elijah cries unto the Lord, saying, O Lord my God hast thou also brought evil upon the Widow, [Greek or Hebrew] with whom I sojourn only? and that which confirms it is, that they are said to be dwellers or inhabitants of Mesopotamia and Judea, and Cappadocia, Verse 9. They could not fixedly belong as dwellers to both, they were therefore rather sojourners in Jerusalem now at the Feast, though fixed dwellers in all those places: For if they were fixed dwellers in Jerusalem, to what end whilst they were at Jerusalem should the Evangelist tell us they were sojourners in Mesopotamia; and they must needs rather be dwellers there, because they are said to understand every one his own language. And that which strengthens this is, that in the Greek there is this difference in the words in Verses 5 and 9. in that they are said [Greek or Hebrew] in Jerusalem. As for the present there, yea, and as to come [Greek or Hebrew] from out of every Nation: but in the 9 Verse he changeth it, and says, [Greek or Hebrew], as inhabitants of Mesopotamia, and those other Countries ⟨p. 19⟩where their fixed possessions were. And therefore Verse 14. he calls them Men, Jews and Dwellers at Jerusalem, as two sorts, and Verse 22. Men of Israel; the stile given those of the ten Tribes scattered, Men devout, as Verse 5. who came up at those solemn times, having wives and children and their families at home, to whom they used after a time to return. Now although these were added and made members of that Church, and are said to continue in the Apostles doctrine: yet that will not necessarily imply that they continued all the time till the dispersion at Jerusalem;
but whilst they were there, they were [Greek or Hebrew], that is, they cleaved to the Apostles: but to think that many of them coming as strangers should not go down to their wives and children, which Nature taught them to provide for, and religion taught them to take care of their souls, or fetch them up to them: so as this might well be a fluid Church, ebbing and flowing as touching the residence of its members: yea, some of these were of Judea, Verse 9. and so of the Country about; and of them might be Churches erected in their proper dwellings is rationally supposable. For in that persecution in Acts 8. 1. it is said that Paul persecuted Disciples in other places then at Jerusalem, Acts 26. 10. Which things I also did at Jerusalem, (says he) and in other places at Damascus. And also it is confirmed by this, that upon the ceasing of Pauls persecution it is said Acts 9. 31. then had the Churches rest through Judea and Galilee, and are said to be at rest in distinction from the persecution raised, Chap. 8. 1.
but whilest they were there, they were 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is, they cleaved to the Apostles: but to think that many of them comming as strangers should not go downe to their wives and children, which Nature taught them to provide for, and religion taught them to take care of their soules, or fetch them up to them: so as this might well be a fluid Church, ebbing and flowing as touching the residence of its members: yea, some of these were of Judea, Verse 9. and so of the Country about; and of them might be Churches erected in their proper dwellings is rationally supposable. For in that persecution in Acts 8. 1. it is said that Paul persecuted Disciples in other places then at Hierusalem, Acts 26. 10. Which things I also did at Hierusalem, (saies he) and in other places at Damascus. And also it is confirmed by this, that upon the ceasing of Pauls persecution it is said Acts 9. 31. then had the Churches rest through Judea and Galilee, and are said to be at rest in distinction from the persecution raised, Chap. 8. 1.
3 Exception is, that they in those Countries and times had often great Assemblies consisting of many thousands hearers at once, that did and could hear, Luke 12. 1. Christ preached to Myriads, many thousands; and Acts 13. 45. almost a whole City came to hear the word of God by Paul. And at Charenton, how many thousands may and do hear, is well known; and so in many places of England. And Moses sometime spake in the ears of all the people, and so Ezra Chapter 10. Verse 9. and 10. And 'tis known by experience, that as in hot Countries they may see as far again, through the pureness of the air, so they may hear at a far greater distance, then in our colder Climate.
3 Exception is, that they in those Countries and times had often great Assemblies consisting of many thousands hearers at once, that did and could heare, Luke 12. 1. Christ preached to Myriads, many thousands; and Acts 13. 45. almost a whole City came to heare the word of God by Paul. And at Charenton, how many thousands may and do heare, is well knowne; and so in many places of England. And Moses sometime spake in the eares of all the people, and so Ezra Chapter 10. Verse 9. and 10. And 'tis knowne by experience, that as in hot Countries they may see as far againe, through the purenesse of the aire, so they may heare at a farre greater distance, then in our colder Climate.
4 Exception is, that this being the first Church, and whereof all the Apostles were the Officers, those therefore that dwelt there would certainly abide together as one Church without parting or dividing, even till they came to the utmost proportion that the constitution of a Church was capable of; and so Maximum quod sic, And continue together in one, for the more united strength and glory of holding forth the name of Christ in ⟨p. 20⟩one body, united for the honour of Religion and communicating in Ordinances together.
5 Exception is, that they had during all this time of their multitudes until the persecution of Paul arose, the greatest freedom and liberty even to the utmost; for the people magnified them, Chap. 5. Verse 12. they had favour with all the people, Chap. 2. Verse 47. Insomuch, that although the Rulers fell upon two of them, John and Peter, yet they were enforced to let them go, finding nothing how to punish them, because of the people, Chapter 4. 21. Besides that, it was no new thing amongst the Jews for Sects to have great multitudes to follow and cleave to them, and to preach in any place, as in Spain and Italy, and to baptize openly as John and Christ did.
5 Exception is, that they had during all this time of their multitudes untill the persecution of Paul arose, the greatest freedome and liberty even to the utmost; for the people magnified them, Chap. 5. Verse 12. they had favour with all the people, Chap. 2. Verse 47. Insomuch, that although the Rulers fell upon two of them, John and Peter, yet they were enforced to let them go, finding nothing how to punish them, because of the people, Chapter 4. 21. Besides that, it was no new thing amongst the Jewes for Sects to have great multitudes to follow and cleave to them, and to preach in any place, as in Spaine and Italy, and to baptize openly as John and Christ did.
Thus having showed the multitudes not arising to that number, but, that they might meet in one, now after the dispersion much less, and to that end let the greatness of the Persecution be considered to demonstrate the greatness of this dispersion; Its called not a Persecution only, but a great Persecution, both extensively and intensively, for the extent of it to all sorts of persons, entering into every house, vers 3. and for the height of it, it being to imprisonment, even unto death, Chap. 22. 4. Acts 26. 10. It is also called, a making havoc of the Church, vers. 9. The object of this Persecution was not Preachers only but Christians of all sorts indifferently, for it is said indefinitely to be upon the Church, vers. 1. and vers. 3. It is called an entering into every house, hailing men and women: and in Chap. 26. Paul speaking of this very Persecution (wherein he had a special hand) says vers. 10. that he imprisoned many of the Saints (not Preachers only) and ver. 9. his aim was promiscuously against the Name of Jesus, and so any that professed his Name: Unto this end compare the varying the expression used by the Holy Ghost, ⟨p. 21⟩when speaking of this Persecution, and of another mentioned Acts 12. 1. there it is said, Herod stretched forth his hand to vex certain of the Church; but here it is against the Church in Jerusalem, Men and women in every house, and all except the Apostles; the word [Greek or Hebrew] [except] there is to show, that none of the Apostles were scattered, though the generality of others were; if men gifted fled away, then others also, except we suppose the people more courageous to stay by it then the Teachers. And whereas it is said, that these that were dispersed, went about preaching the word, vers. 4. First, It argueth not that Preachers only or chiefly were dispersed; for (as Calvin saith) it comes in to show what was the fruit of the dispersion; and we may well suppose women and whole families to have been scattered abroad, who yet preached not: And secondly, It was ordinary in those times, for men that were not by Office Ministers, occasionally to teach the word in private ways of converse, yea and otherwise; And that is not called teaching, which is by way of Sermon to a multitude, for vers. 25. of this chap. Philip in private conference taught the Eunuch, as Aquila and Priscilla taught Apollos;
First those three thousand who were converted, Chap. 2. were not setled dwellers at Jerusalem, but strangers, Commorants of the ten Tribes, which were dispersed in all those Countries mentioned in the 2 Chapter, Verse 9. who came up to the feast of Pentecost, as the manner of the Jewes was, Acts 21. 20, 27, 28. Jewes that lived in Asia came to the feast of Pentecost as Paul also did, compared with Acts 20. 16. And the word which is translated Dwellers at Jerusalem, is interpreted by an eminent Critick, Sojourners at Jerusalem during this Feast, although the word1 signifies both, and to that end quotes the Septuagint in 1. Kings 17. 20. where Elijah cries unto the Lord, saying, O Lord my God hast thou also brought evill upon the Widow, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 with whom I sojourne onely? and that which confirmes it is, that they are said to be dwellers or inhabitants of Mesopotamia and Judea, and Capadocea, Verse 9. They could not fixedly belong as dwellers to both, they were therefore rather sojourners in Jerusalem now at the Feast, though fixed dwellers in all those places: For if they were fixed dwellers in Jerusalem, to what end whilest they were at Jerusalem should the Evangelist tell us they were sojourners in Mesopotamia; and they must needs rather be dwellers there, because they are said to understand every one his own language. And that which strengthens this is, that in the Greek there is this difference in the words in Verses 5 and 9. in that they are said 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in Hierusalem. As for the present there, yea, and as to come 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 from out of every Nation: but in the 9 Verse he changeth it, and saies, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as inhabiters of Mesopotamia, and those other Countries ⟨p. 19⟩where their fixed possessions were. And therefore Verse 14. he cals them Men, Jewes and Dwellers at Jerusalem, as two sorts, and Verse 22. Men of Israel; the stile given those of the ten Tribes scattered, Men devout, as Verse 5. who came up at those solemne times, having wives and children and their families at home, to whom they used after a time to returne. Now although these were added and made members of that Church, and are said to continue in the Apostles doctrine: yet that will not necessarily imply that they continued all the time till the dispersion at Jerusalem;