For first; Whereas he saith, they had no mind to have published their Thoughts about it, &c. but that they were obstructed in their Desires and Attempts to have a friendly Debate, &c. We ⟨p. 10⟩reply; What was the reason that before any Person, that was contrary-minded to that Practice of theirs, had said or printed any thing publicly against it, that this Opinion of theirs concerning Singing, was preached up, and frequently and vehemently pressed by several of them in variety of Assemblies; and asserted in Print, to the view of all Men, by Mr. Keach, in his Treatise called Gold Refined, and in his great Book of Scripture Tropes and Metaphors; and by Mr. H. C. in a select Treatise on that Subject, though with more Sobriety than any we have seen since, that hath been published on that Controversy by any of them? Had they no mind to publish their Dissertations about it? Was their public Preaching and public Printing for it, against their Minds; which was done by them before any Person did openly contradict them in it? Who can believe it? And all this before there was any motion or mention of a friendly Debate about it that we know of; neither as yet, do we know of any such Motion seriously made, except it were for a Liberty to introduce it by a major Vote in a Church of Christ, &c. which was long after they had endeavoured to promote it by their Endeavours aforesaid. If we were blame-worthy in this matter, it was in being so long silent, wher• by they took the opportunity to leaven so many honest Souls, and to beguile so many Churches (i• their Number be so many as they boast of) with this irregular Doctrine and Practice; hereby it was that to such a height of Confidence Mr. Keach was come, (who makes Breaches more than he repairs any) that when one did but once preach on that Subject of Singing in the Church to which he belongs ⟨p. 11⟩on a Lord's Day, far enough off from Mr. Keach's Congregation; because he did it not according to his Sentiments, he coming the next day or shortly after, in much affection to visit him, Mr. Keach (having heard of his Preaching, as before mentioned) immediately falls upon him, as soon as ever he came into Mr. Keach's House, with a most severe and very uncivil passionate Reprimand, for daring to preach after that manner, contrary to his Judgment; as if he had the preeminence over all. But when Mr.
For first; Whereas he saith, they had no mind to have publish'd their Thoughts about it, &c. but that they were obstructed in their Desires and Attempts to have a friendly Debate, &c. We ⟨p. 10⟩reply; What was the reason that before any Person, that was contrary-minded to that Practice of theirs, had said or printed any thing publickly against it, that this Opinion of theirs concerning Singing, was preach'd up, and frequently and vehemently prest by several of them in variety of Assemblies; and asserted in Print, to the view of all Men, by Mr. Keach, in his Treatise call'd Gold Refin'd, and in his great Book of Scripture Tropes and Metaphors; and by Mr. H. C. in a select Treatise on that Subject, though with more Sobriety than any we have seen since, that hath been published on that Controversy by any of them? Had they no mind to publish their Dissertations about it? Was their publick Preaching and publick Printing for it, against their Minds; which was done by them before any Person did openly contradict them in it? Who can believe it? And all this before there was any motion or mention of a friendly Debate about it that we know of; neither as yet, do we know of any such Motion seriously made, except it were for a Liberty to introduce it by a major Vote in a Church of Christ, &c. which was long after they had endeavoured to promote it by their Endeavours aforesaid. If we were blame-worthy in this matter, it was in being so long silent, wher• by they took the opportunity to leaven so many honest Souls, and to beguile so many Churches (i• their Number be so many as they boast of) with this irregular Doctrine and Practice; hereby it was that to such a heigth of Confidence Mr. Keach was come, (who makes Breaches more than he repairs any) that when one did but once preach on that Subject of Singing in the Church to which he belongs ⟨p. 11⟩on a Lord's Day, far enough off from Mr. Keach's Congregation; because he did it not according to his Sentiments, he coming the next day or shortly after, in much affection to visit him, Mr. Keach (having heard of his Preaching, as before mention'd) immediately falls upon him, as soon as ever he came into Mr. Keach's House, with a most severe and very uncivil passionate Reprimand, for daring to preach after that manner, contrary to his Judgment; as if he had the preheminence over all. But when Mr.