A96223:29
The answer of the Assembly of DivinesThe ansvver of the Assembly of Divines
The answer of the Assembly of Divines by authority of Parliament now sitting at Westminster. Unto the reasons given in to this Assembly by the Dissenting Brethren, of their not bringing in a model of their way. And since published in print, under the title of A copy of a remonstrance. Which answer was humbly presented to the Right Honourable the House of Peers assembled in Parliament. Ordered by the Lords in Parliament assembled, that this answer be forthwith printed and published. Joh. Brown, cler. Parliamentorum.The ansvver of the Assembly of Divines by authority of Parliament now sitting at Westminster. Unto the reasons given in to this Assembly by the Dissenting Brethren, of their not bringing in a model of their way. And since published in print, under the title of A copy of a remonstrance. Which answer was humbly presented to the Right Honorable the House of Peers assembled in Parliament. Ordered by the Lords in Parliament assembled, that this answer be forthwith printed and published. Joh. Brown, cler. Parliamentorum.
London: printed by John Field for Ralph Smith, 1646
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
After many days spent in debate of those Propositions, and several Votes passed about them, our Brethren not being satisfied in the stating of them, especially of the latter, were oft desired several days by divers Brethren to propose how themselves would have it stated: Which they as oft declined, saying, They could not do it presently; to which it was at last replied, That though at the first motion they could not do it presently, yet now the Assembly had been already three days about the stating of a question; and this the fourth day, only to satisfy these Brethren, they now had had time to consider how they would have it stated: Hereupon, one of them stood up and spake to this purpose, I should not have said thus, but that I was called upon; But it is not so fair and rational a way, That as soon as we object rationally against the stating of a question, it should be said, Then bring in a better state. Yet we have brought in a Paper as followeth.
After many dayes spent in debate of those Propositions, and several Votes passed about them, our Brethren not being satisfied in the stating of them, especially of the latter, were oft desired several dayes by divers Brethren to propose how themselves would have it stated: Which they as oft declined, saying, They could not do it presently; to which it was at last replied, That though at the first motion they could not do it presently, yet now the Assembly had been already three dayes about the stating of a question; and this the fourth day, onely to satisfie these Brethren, they now had had time to consider how they would have it stated: Hereupon, one of them stood up and spake to this purpose, I should not have said thus, but that I was called upon; But it is not so fair and rational a way, That as soon as we object rationally against the stating of a question, it should be said, Then bring in a better state. Yet we have brought in a Paper as followeth.
For the second Proposition, That it is lawful according to the Word [that certain Ministers of the City of London, be desired to ordain Ministers in the vicinity jure fraternitatis] We conceive it doth really, and de facto set up a Presbytery before the Government, that is the ground thereof be disputed. For the sense of many of the Brethren in the debates, have represented this, saying, That it was but a mould for other places, to be perfected and continued; some affirming it to be a Presbytery, another, that it was a Presbytery both materially and formally, but not in the formality, and urged such Arguments as for a Presbytery; another, that it was the Seed of a Presbytery.