A97353:94
The second part of The nonconformists plea for peace being an account of their…
The second part of The nonconformists plea for peace being an account of their principles about civil and ecclesiastical authority and obedience ... : mostly written many years past, and now published to save our lives and the kingdoms peace, from the false and bloody plotters ... / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for John Hancock, 1680
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Therefore no man is to promise without fraud, nor to stand to his promise made, to give up this right (in civil sociation) unless for fear of greater evil or hope of greater good. As if a robber force us to promise him our goods, we may fraudulently promise and not perform it; yea if I mistakingly think I have promised a thing to ⟨p. 4⟩my hurt, I may break it: whence we conclude that Covenants can have no force but for our profit sake, which being taken away, the Covenant is taken away and remaineth void. Therefore in constituting Republics, it's foolish to require fidelity, further than you make sure, that Covenant-breaking shall prove the breakers hurt: For every man by natural right, may deal deceitfully, and is not bound to stand to his Covenants. He hath the supreme Right over all men, who hath the greatest power, by which he can retain them by force or fear of the greatest punishment: which Right he shall have no longer, than he keepeth the power of executing what he list: Otherwise he shall rule precariously, and no one that is stronger than he shall be bound to obey him, unless he will. And thus societies may be formed without any wrong to the right of nature: and he that hath most power is bound by no Law. And thus we are bound to execute all his commands that hath most power, be they most absurd: because reason bids us choose the less evil: But then this Right of commanding what they will, no longer belongeth to chief Powers, than they have chief power: which if they lose, they lose their Right of commanding, and it falls to him or them that get it and can keep it.
Therefore no man is to promise without fraud, nor to stand to his promise made, to give up this right (in civil sociation) unless for fear of greater evil or hope of greater good. As if a robber force us to promise him our goods, we may frandulently promise and not perform it; yea if I mistakingly think I have promised a thing to ⟨p. 4⟩my hurt, I may break it: whence we conclude that Covenants can have no force but for our profit sake, which being taken away, the Covenant is taken away and remaineth void. Therefore in constituting Republicks, it's foolish to require fidelity, further than you make sure, that Covenant-breaking shall prove the breakers hurt: For every man by natural right, may deal deceitfully, and is not bound to stand to his Covenants. He hath the supreme Right over all men, who hath the greatest power, by which he can retain them by force or fear of the greatest punishment: which Right he shall have no longer, than he keepeth the power of executing what he list: Otherwise he shall rule precariously, and no one that is stronger than he shall be bound to obey him, unless he will. And thus societies may be formed without any wrong to the right of nature: and he that hath most power is bound by no Law. And thus we are bound to execute all his commands that hath most power, be they most absurd: because reason bids us chuse the less evil: But then this Right of commanding what they will, no longer belongeth to chief Powers, than they have chief power: which if they lose, they lose their Right of commanding, and it falls to him or them that get it and can keep it.