B20729:31
A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England,…
A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England, to Mr. Williams, a preacher there wherein is showed that those ought to be received into the Church who are Godly, though they do not see nor expressly bewail all the pollutions in church-fellowship, ministry, worship, government.A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England, to Mr. Williams, a preacher there wherein is shewed that those ought to be received into the Church who are Godly, though they doe not see nor expressely bewaile all the pollutions in church-fellowship, ministery, worship, government.
London: printed for Benjamin Allen, 1643
Letter: A Letter of Mr. John Cottons, Teacher of the Church in Boston, in New England.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Now surely if your self had hearkened to your own desire, and had throughly weighed the Scripture, and had suffered the Lord to have held the scales himself, you would never have alleged this place to your purpose. Your purpose was to prove that Churches cannot be constituted by such persons as are unclean by antichristian pollutions, or if they be so constituted, they are not to be communicated with, but separated from: To prove this you allege this place; when the Prophet acknowledgeth the whole Church of the Jews to be unclean, and yet neither denieth them to be a Church truly constituted, nor stirreth up himself or others to separate from them.
Answ. Now surely if your selfe had hearkned to your owne desire, and had throughly weighed the Scripture, and had suffered the Lord to have held the scales himselfe, you would never have alledged this place to your purpose. Your purpose was to prove that Churches connot be constituted by such persons as are uncleane by antichristian pollutions, or if they be so constituted, they are not to be communicated with, but separated from: To prove this you alledge this place; when the Prophet acknowledgeth the whole Church of the Jewes to be uncleane, and yet neither denyeth them to be a Church truely constituted, nor stirreth up himselfe or others to separate from them.
If you say, why but they were unclean? I Answer, be it so, but were they therefore no Church truly constituted, or to be separated from? yea did not Haggai and Zechariah themselves communicate with them, and call others also to come out of Babel to communicate with them, even whilst Joshua the High Priest was still polluted with his unclean garments Zac. 2.6, 7. with 6.3.8.3. But if indeed you desire to know, what upon due weighing of the place, I conceive to be the meaning of it, you shall find it to be this; The occasion of the words arise ⟨p. 10⟩from a worldly distemper, which the time grew upon, all sorts of the members of that Church, who were so far carried away with care of their own outward accommodations, that while every man looked to his own house, and the ceiling of it, the Temple of the Lord and the building thereof was generally neglected of them all, Prince, Priest, and People, whence it was that God neither delighted in their spiritual services, nor in their bodily labours, but left them without a blessing in both,