B20729:35
A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England,…
A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England, to Mr. Williams, a preacher there wherein is showed that those ought to be received into the Church who are Godly, though they do not see nor expressly bewail all the pollutions in church-fellowship, ministry, worship, government.A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England, to Mr. Williams, a preacher there wherein is shewed that those ought to be received into the Church who are Godly, though they doe not see nor expressely bewaile all the pollutions in church-fellowship, ministery, worship, government.
London: printed for Benjamin Allen, 1643
Letter: A Letter of Mr. John Cottons, Teacher of the Church in Boston, in New England.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This I take to be the true and genuine meaning of the place, which if you apply to the point in hand, will reach nothing near to your purpose. Hypocrites in the Church, and godly Christians themselves, whilst they attend to the world more then to the things of God, their persons, their labours, their civill oblations are all unclean in the sight of God; therefore the Church of Christ cannot be constituted of such, or if it do consist of such, the people of God must separate from them. You might well have gathered, therefore, the Church of Christ and the members thereof must separate themselves from their hypocrisy, and inordinate love of this world, or else they and their duties will still be unclean in the sight of God, notwithstanding their Church estate. This collection tendeth to edification, the other to dissipation and destruction of the Church, and of them that wrest blood in stead of milk from the breasts of holy Scripture.
This I take to be the true and genuine meaning of the place, which if you apply to the point in hand, will reach nothing neare to your purpose. Hypocrites in the Church, and godly Christians themselves, whilst they attend to the world more then to the things of God, their persons, their labours, their civill oblations are all uncleane in the sight of God; therefore the Church of Christ cannot be constituted of such, or if it doe consist of such, the people of God must separate from them. You might well have gathered, therefore, the Church of Christ and the members thereof must separate themselves from their hypocrisie, and inordinate love of this world, or else they and their duties will still be uncleane in the sight of God, notwithstanding their Church estate. This collection tendeth to edification, the other to dissipation and destruction of the Church, and of them that wrest blood in stead of milke from the breasts of holy Scripture.
The second stumbling block or offence which you take at the way of these Churches is, that you conceive us to walk betwixt Christ and Antichrist. First, in practising separation here, and not repenting of our preaching and printing against it in our own country. Secondly, in reproaching your self at Salem and others for separation. Thirdly, in particular, that my self have conceived and spoken, that separation is a way that God hath not prospered as if (say you) the truth of the Churches way depended upon countenance of men, or upon outward peace and liberty.