B20729:38
A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England,…
A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England, to Mr. Williams, a preacher there wherein is showed that those ought to be received into the Church who are Godly, though they do not see nor expressly bewail all the pollutions in church-fellowship, ministry, worship, government.A letter of Mr. John Cottons, teacher of the Church in Boston in New-England, to Mr. Williams, a preacher there wherein is shewed that those ought to be received into the Church who are Godly, though they doe not see nor expressely bewaile all the pollutions in church-fellowship, ministery, worship, government.
London: printed for Benjamin Allen, 1643
Letter: A Letter of Mr. John Cottons, Teacher of the Church in Boston, in New England.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. I know no man that reproacheth Salem for their separation, nor do I believe that they do separate. Howsoever if any do reproach them for it, I think it a sin meet to be censured, but not with so deep a censure as to excommunicate all the Churches, or to separate from them before it do appear that they do tolerate their members in such their causeless reproachings. We confess the errors of men are to be contended against, not with reproaches, but the sword of the Spirit; but on the other side, the failings of the Churches (if any be found) are not forth with to be healed by separation. It is not Chirurgery, but Butchery, to heal every sore in a member with no other medicine but abscission from the body.
2. I know no man that reproacheth Salem for their separation, nor doe I beleeve that they doe separate. Howsoever if any doe reproach them for it, I thinke it a sinne meet to be censured, but not with so deepe a censure as to excommunicate all the Churches, or to separate from them before it doe appeare that they doe tolerate their members in such their causelesse reproachings. Wee confesse the errours of men are to be contended against, not with reproaches, but the sword of the Spirit; but on the other side, the failings of the Churches (if any be found) are not forth with to be healed by separation. It is not Chirurgery, but Butchery, to heale every sore in a member with no other medicine but abscission from the body.
3. For my self, I acknowledge the words which you mention, that the way of separation is not a way that God hath prospered. But you much mistake, when you think I speak it for want of their outward countenance, peace and liberty. The truth is, they find more favour in our native country then the way of reformation wherein we walk, which is commonly reproached by the name of Puritanism. The meetings of the Separatists may be known to the Officers in the Courts and winked at when the Conventicles of the puritans (as they call them) shall be hunted out with all diligence, and pursued with more violence then any law will justify. But I said that God had not prospered the way of separation, because he hath not blessed it either with peace amongst themselves, or with growth of grace; such as erring through simplicity and tenderness of conscience have grown in grace, have grown also to discern their lawful liberty to return to the hearing of the word from English Preachers.