N00041:115
Another essay for investigation of the truth, in answer to two questions, concerning I.…
Another essay for investigation of the truth, in answer to two questions, concerning I. The subject of baptism. II. The consociation of churches. / By John Davenport B. of D. and Pastor of the Church of Christ, at New-Haven, in New-England. ; [Twenty-four lines of quotations]
printed by Samuel Green and Marmaduke Johnson, 1663
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Reply. 1. It remains to be proved, that the Parents in question are children of the Covenant: They were children of the Covenant in their infancy and minority and bound thereby, when they became a ••ul•, to covenant for themselves and their seed, in their own persons, being fitly qualified, as their godly Parents did before them: If they, being grown up to be men, perform not this Covenant, they cannot fitly be called Children of the Covenant, but Transgressors of the Covenant, and Breakers of it. 2. The Argument is fallacious: Some children of the Covenant have had the beginnings of grace manifestly wrought in them in younger years. Therefore all persons of this sort, showing nothing to the contrary, are, in charity, or to Ecclesiastical reputation, visible Believers. This Argument is to be denied: both because it argues from some Particulars, to infer a General affirmatively; and from that which is positively manifest, in some, to prove the same to be in others, in whom it is not positively manifest, but o•el• they show nothing to the contrary: which makes them at best but Negative Christians, which is not to be Christian indeed.
Reply. 1. It remains to be proved, that the Parents in question are children of the Covenant: They were children of the Covenant in their infancy and minority and bound thereby, when they became a ••ul•, to covenant for themselves and their seed, in their own persons, being fitly qualified, as their godly Parents did before them: If they, being grown up to be men, perform not this Covenant, they cannot fitly be called Children of the Covenant, but Transgressours of the Covenant, and Breakers of it. 2. The Argument is fallacious: Some children of the Covenant have had the beginnings of grace manifestly wrought in them in younger years. Therefore all persons of this sort, shewing nothing to the contrary, are, in charity, or to Ecclesiastical reputation, visible Believers. This Argument is to be denied: both because it argues from some Particulars, to infer a General affirmatively; and from that which is positively manifest, in some, to prove the same to be in others, in whom it is not positively manifest, but o•el• they shew nothing to the contrary: which makes them at best but Negative Christians, which is not to be Christian indeed.