Answ. Most true it is, that we do Maintain this, and must do so, till we see the contrary proved. Neither do we know that this Opinion contains any thing in it dissent any from Scripture or good Reason: Nor see we how some Arguments for the Affirmative can fairly be answered. Suppose we an English Fugitive that is become a Priest in Antwerp, or a Cardinal at Rome: Or suppose we a Turk who is an English-man by Birth; this Turk was baptized a Member of some Parish-Church (which those that we dispute against mountain to be true Churches, and we are far from denying of it universally) and he was never Censured by any Church for his Apostasy: now we demand, Whether this Turk be a Member of the Church of Christ, yea or no? To affirm it, would be gross; To say that Turks are Members of the Church of Christ, is in truth to speak Daggers. When the Arch-Flamin Whitgift said, that Papists and Atheists might still remain Members of the visible Church: Mr. Parker xtells him, That even a Vorstius would condemn him. And it is no new Doctrine in the Schools, to say, that yAn Heretical Apostate is no more a Member of the Church of Christ, then a Wound, a Sore, or a Brand, is a member of a man; which none can imagine. The truth of this none can doubt of, that is mediocritèr doctus in Scholastical Divinity, Therefore we conclude, that Church-members may become no Members by their own defection. ⟨image ?⟩And we humbly conceive (though with submission, at is fit, to better judgements) That thus much is held forth by these Scriptures, Hebr, 10. 25 1 Joh. 2. 19. Jude ver. 19. Agam, how came Esau to lose his Membership? We read not that he was Excommunicate: Therefore it remains, that he dis-Covenanted, and so dis-Membered himself. And how came the Children of Abraham by Keturah to lose their Membership? it was not by Censure. In like sort, when person, under the Gospel, do not come up to the terms of the Covenant, to show themselves to be Abraham's Children, by holding forth his Faith, and walking before the Lord in simplicity and goldy sincerity, we suppose that they are justly deemed Breakers of the Covenant, and have justly put themselves Out of that Covenant which their Parents (because of their then personal incapacity to act for themselves) made for them. Alas! that any should look upon us as Maintaining dangerous Opinions, because of this!
Answ. Most true it is, that we do Maintain this, and must do so, till we see the contrary proved. Neuher do we know that this Opinion contains any thing in it dissent any from Scripture or good Reason: Nor see we how some Arguments for the Affirmative can fairly be answered. Suppose we an English Fugitive that is become a Priest in Antwerp, or a Cardinal at Rome: Or suppose we a Turk who is an English-man by Birth; this Turk was baptized a Member of some Parish-Church (which those that we dispute against mountain to be true Churches, and we are farre from denying of it universally) and he was never Censured by any Church for his Apostacy: now we demand, Whether this Turk be a Member of the Church of Christ, yea or no? To affirm it, would be gross; To say that Turks are Members of the Church of Christ, is in truth to speak Daggers. When the Arch-Flamin Whitgift said, that Papists and Atheists might still remain Members of the visible Church: Mr. Parker xtells him, That even a Vorstius would condemn him. And it is no new Doctrine in the Schools, to say, that yAn Heretical Apostate is no more a Member of the Church of Christ, then a Wound, a Sore, or a Brand, is a member of a man; which none can imagine. The truth of this none can doubt of, that is mediocritèr doctus in Scholastical Divinity, Therefore we conclude, that Church-members may become no Members by their own defection. ⟨image ?⟩And we humbly conceive (though with submission, at is fit, to better judgements) That thus much is held forth by these Scriptures, Hebr, 10. 25 1 Joh. 2. 19. Jude ver. 19. Agam, how came Esau to lose his Membership? We reade not that he was Excommunicate: Therefore it remains, that he dis-Covenanted, and so dis-Membered himself. And how came the Children of Abraham by Keturah to lose their Membership? it was not by Censure. In like sort, when person, under the Gospel, do not come up to the terms of the Covenant, to shew themselves to be Abrahams Children, by holding forth his Faith, and walking before the Lord in simplicity and goldy sincerity, we suppose that they are justly deemed Breakers of the Covenant, and have justly put themselves Out of that Covenant which their Parents (because of their then personal incapacity to act for themselves) made for them. Alas! that any should look upon us as Maintaining dangerous Opinions, because of this!
- xDe Pol. Eccles l. 3. c. 16.
- yMorton Apol. […] Catec. par. 1. l. 1. c. 3.Morton Apol. 〈…〉 Catec. par. 1. l. 1. c. 3.