Reply 1. The Tex•s alleged do not prove the Antecedent. 1 Abraham commanding his children and hou•h••• after him, to keep the w•y […] the Lord, &c. doth not necessarily infer Church-discipline: It being enjoyed to all Fathers of Families, in the National Church of […] De•. 6. 7. & 11. 19. and in the Congregational Churches of Christ, under the Gospel, […] 6. 4, 9. within their own Families, where they have not power to exercise Church-discipline: or, if any further thing was meant, ⟨p. 11⟩it may be applied to the command concerning Circumcision, as Gen. 17. 26,27. 2. That in Gen. 21. 9 where Ishmael, who was born after the flesh, persecuted Isaac who was born after the Sp••it, and was therefore cast out of the Church, in Abraham's Family, is improved by the Apostle to another purpose, in Gal. 4. 22—29. nor doth it prove their Proposition. For Ishmael was not circumcised at eight days old, but when he was thirteen years old: and therefore may be thought to be circumcised upon his personal taking hold of the Covenant, as other grown persons in the family did, there being nothing said in that story to evince the contrary. To which opinion Polycarpus Lyserus seemeth to incline. If it was so, then there is a manifest difference between Ishmaels case, and the children of confederates, baptized in infancy: for Ishmael was admitted into Church-fellowship and full communion, by his personal covenanting, whereupon he was circumcised being grown up to years of discretion, and so might be regularly excommunicated, which they who never were in full communion may not be. 2. To prove that children were under Mosaical discipline of ol•, they produce only one Text, Gal. 5. 3. where the Apostle speaking of circumcision, (not as it was given of God, and rightly used by Abraham, as a seal off the righteousness which is by […], Rom. 4. 11. but as it was abused by false Teachers, to establish justification by the works of the Law) […] to every man […] is circumcised, that be as a debtor to do the whole Law, and that […] […] Christ shall profit them nothing. Because he that seeketh Righteousness in Circumcision, is bound, by like reason, to seek it in other works of the Law. Therefore this text doth not prove that for which it is alleged, viz. that children circumcised in infancy, were, being grown up▪ under the external Mosaical Watch, Discipline, and Government of the Church.
Reply 1. The Tex•s alledged do not prove the Antecedent. 1 Abraham commanding his children and hou•h••• after him, to keep the w•y 〈…〉 the Lord, &c. doth not necessarily infer Church-discipline: It being enjoyed to all Fathers of Families, in the National Church of 〈…〉 De•. 6. 7. & 11. 19. and in the Congregational Church•s of Christ, under the Go•pel, 〈…〉 6. 4, 9. within their own Families, where they have not power to exercise Church-discipline: or, if any further thing was meant, ⟨p. 11⟩it may be applied to the command concerning Circumcision, as Gen. 17. 26,27. 2. That in Gen. 21. 9 where Ishmael, who was born after the flesh, persecuted Isaac who was born after the Sp••it, and was therefore cast out of the Church, in Abrahams Family, is improved by the Apostle to another purpose, in Gal. 4. 22—29. nor doth it prove their Proposition. For Ishmael was not circumcised at eight dayes old, but when he was thirteen years old: and therefore may be thought to be circumcised upon his personal taking hold of the Covenant, as other grown persons in the family did, there being nothing said in that story to evince the contrary. To which opinion Polycarpus Lyserus seemeth to incline. If it was so, then there is a manifest difference between Ishmaels case, and the children of confederates, baptized in infancy: for Ishmael was admitted into Church-fellowship and full communion, by his personal covenanting, whereupon he was circumcised being grown up to years of discretion, and so might be regularly excommunicated, which they who never were in full communion may not be. 2. To prove that children were under Mosaical discipline of ol•, they produce onely one Text, Gal. 5. 3. where the Apostle speaking of circumcision, (not as it was given of God, and rightly used by Abraham, as a seal off the righteousness which is by ,