N00041:8
Another essay for investigation of the truth, in answer to two questions, concerning I.…
Another essay for investigation of the truth, in answer to two questions, concerning I. The subject of baptism. II. The consociation of churches. / By John Davenport B. of D. and Pastor of the Church of Christ, at New-Haven, in New-England. ; [Twenty-four lines of quotations]
printed by Samuel Green and Marmaduke Johnson, 1663
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Suppose it were so; Is Truth bound up to Number? It was, indeed, a sore, Temptation to Luther, when it was Objected to him, Tune solus sapis? Is there never a wise man in the world but you […] It may be the same thing hath been as great a Temptation to some of us. In the Council of Constance, one of the Prelates said unto that blessed Martyr John Huss,h That he should never show himself so Arrogant, as to prefer his own Opinion above the Judgement of the whole Council. Yet the whole Council (though it were an Universal Council) erred, and this one good man held the Truth against so many. Which we do not mention, as though we would prefer our own Judgements above others; such a thought we abhor. Neither is it is our intentions, any ways to reflect upon those Honoured and Reverend Persons from whom we Dissented; nay, we look upon them as far better then our selves: only by this Instance given, we may see, that in a Council (nay, an Ecumenical Council) a few (nay one) may dissent from all the rest, and yet neither Ignorance nor Arrogance (but Truth and Conscience) be the ground of it. In the Nicene Council there was but one iPaphnutius, who opposed all the rest of the Synod, that had concluded upon a gross Error.
Answ. Suppose it were so; Is Truth bound up to Number? It was, indeed, a sore, Temptation to Luther, when it was Objected to him, Tune solus sapis? Is there never a wise man in the world but you 〈…〉 It may be the same thing hath been as great a Temptation to some of us. In the Council of Constance, one of the Prelates said unto that blessed Martyr John Husse,h That he should never shew himself so Arrogant, as to preferre his own Opinion above the Judgement of the whole Council. Yet the whole Council (though it were an Universal Council) erred, and this one good man held the Truth against so many. Which we do not mention, as though we would prefer our own Judgements above others; such a thought we abhor. Neither is it is our intentions, any wayes to reflect upon those Honoured and Reverend Persons from whom we Dissented; nay, we look upon them as far better then our selves: onely by this Instance given, we may see, that in a Council (nay, an Oecomenical Council) a few (nay one) may dissent from all the rest, and yet neither Ignorance nor Arrogance (but Truth and Conscience) be the ground of it. In the Nicen Council there was but one