N00598:11
The answer of several ministers in and near Boston, to that case of conscience,…
The answer of several ministers in and near Boston, to that case of conscience, whether it is lawful for a man to marry his wives own sister?
printed by Bartholomew Green, 1695
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. There is in the Scripture an express Prohibition of Marriage with such as are no nearer akin than a Mans Wives Sister is. To instance. A Man may not Marry his Brothers Wife Lev. 18. 16. and 20. 21 Math. 14. 4. Which Implies ⟨p. 5⟩that a man may not Marry his Wives Sister, who is as near akin to him as his Brothers Wife. Persons not named in the Law, if they have the same nearness with those expressly and in terms forbidden to join in Marriage Relation together, are comprehended in that Law. When the Law expressly forbids the Nephew to Marry the Aunt, it implies that the Uncle may not Marry the Niece, because an Uncles Wife and an Aunts Husband are equally akin. It is (as Dr. Hall in his Cases of Conscience has well noted) easy to observe, that all the several•ies of the degrees prohibited run still upon the Male, under which the exorbitances of the other Sex are comprehended. Thus though a Mans Marrying his Wives Sister is not in so many express Words and Syllables prohibited, by clear implication and necessary Consequence it is so. It is a very weak Argument, to say, inasmuch as Marrying with the Wives Sister is not in terms forbidden in the 18 Chapter of Leviticus, that therefore it is lawful. A Mans Marrying with his own Daughter is not expressly forbidden in that Law: But since it is said, he may not Marry his Daughter in Law or his Sons Wife, Verse […] by necessary deduction it follows, that he may not Marry his own Daughter. It is not in express terms said, that a Woman shall not Marry two Brothers: and it is certainly as lawful for a Woman to Marry two Brothers as for a Man two Sisters. Yet this is so highly against the light of Nature as well as Scripture, as that it ⟨p. 6⟩was of old decreed in the Neocaesarian Council, that whosoever should do so, should be rejected unto death.
2. There is in the Scripture an express Prohibition of Marriage with such as are no nearer akin than a Mans Wives Sister is. To instance. A Man may not Marry his Brothers Wife