N00898:24
Some remarks on a late sermon, preached at Boston in New England, by George…
Some remarks on a late sermon, preached at Boston in New England, by George Keith M.A. Showing that his pretended good rules in divinity, are not built on the foundation of the apostles & prophets. / By Increase Mather. ; [Four lines of quotations]Some remarks on a late sermon, preached at Boston in New England, by George Keith M.A. Shewing that his pretended good rules in divinity, are not built on the foundation of the apostles & prophets. / By Increase Mather. ; [Four lines of quotations]
Boston: printed for Nicholas Boone near the old meeting house, 1702
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Some REMARKS On a late Sermon Preached at Boston in New England.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sect. 5. The design of Mr. Ks. fourth Rule in Divinity is to Intimate, that the Dissenters ought to join, in Acts of Public worship with the Church, notwithstanding the great mixture of unsound Members in that Church, because the Prophets and Apostles did not separate from the Public Worship of God in the Jewish Church, when the matter of it was found. This Argument though often urged is not Cogent. It is Controverted among Learned men, whether there were any Ecclesiastical Discipline in the Jewish Church, except in cases wherein the Ceremonial Law was Transgressed, and that Moral Offences were Punishable only by the Civil Magistrate. Whereas it is otherwise under the Gospel, as all except Erastians, do willingly Confess. But suppose it be granted that Moral Transgressions in the Jewish ⟨p. 15⟩Church fell under Ecclesiastical Judicature, as the Jewish Writers1 tell us of above twenty crimes which they say were Censurable Evils, and it is certain that Heresies were so, Mr. K's reasoning is nevertheless invalid. For he cannot but know that the Dissenters from the Church of England find fault with some particulars in the matter of the Worship required by the Liturgy. They verily believe that such things are herein Commanded as God has forbidden. Whether they are mistaken in their Judgment the day will shortly declare. The Conformists say that the Ceremonies enjoined by the Common Prayer Book, are not commanded by Christ nor forbidden by him, but that they are of an indifferent nature. The Nonconformists believe that they are forbidden in the Second Commandment. I shall not here dispute that point, which has been so Elaborately handled by many others. Particularly by Mr. Bradshaw, and by Dr. Ames in his fresh Suit against Ceremonies. And by my Brother Samuel Mather, late Pastor of a Church in Dublin, and sometimes Senior Fellow of the College there. Particularly, Nonconformists complain of the Sign of the Cross in Baptism, as a corrupting addition to an Ordinance of Divine Worship. Dr. Taylor notwithstanding his Pleas for the Liturgy, confesseth that in respect of the Cross in Baptism, a Non instituted Ceremony ⟨p. 16⟩is made a part of External Worship. There are also many Nonconformists who suppose that if they should Kneel before Bread and Wine, they should be guilty of Idolatry.