N00898:38
Some remarks on a late sermon, preached at Boston in New England, by George…
Some remarks on a late sermon, preached at Boston in New England, by George Keith M.A. Showing that his pretended good rules in divinity, are not built on the foundation of the apostles & prophets. / By Increase Mather. ; [Four lines of quotations]Some remarks on a late sermon, preached at Boston in New England, by George Keith M.A. Shewing that his pretended good rules in divinity, are not built on the foundation of the apostles & prophets. / By Increase Mather. ; [Four lines of quotations]
Boston: printed for Nicholas Boone near the old meeting house, 1702
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Some REMARKS On a late Sermon Preached at Boston in New England.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sect. 9. Mr. K's. Commendation of Vocal Praying with the Minister deserves a further Remark. He does on this account extol the Church of England above all other Churches. But he cannot be ignorant, that in Antiphons and Responses in Public Worship, the Church of Rome outdoes the Church of England. He says true, that the Reformed Churches in Holland, France, &c. have no such Custom among them; only he is a little mistaken about the Protestant Churches in Germany (k)for some of them do, though most of them do not Conform to that way of Worship. That it was not thus practised in the Apostles days, is indisputable. The highest Original pretended for it from Ignatius. Socrates (k)(though otherwise one of the best among Ecclesiastical Historians, however condemned by Bellarmin, Baronius, Possevinus, and other Popish Authors) reports that Ignatius had a Vision of Angels Singing after that manner, which caused him to introduce Antiphons into the Church in Antioch; but Judicious men esteem that Relation of Ignatius his Angelical Vision as fabulous. The•doret says, that Flavianus and Diodorus taught this way of Antiphonical Praying. Basil (who flourished Anno •70) found a difficulty in ⟨p. 29⟩persuading his Neocaesarienses to Conform to responsory praying by reason of the then Novelty of it. The Arians at Constantinople used that mode of Singing, which lest simple people should be taken therewith, and be seduced from the Truth thereby. Chrysostom appointed the like to he done by some of his people with Nocturnal Hymns, Ambrose (about the year 383) is reckoned to be the first that brou••t this way of pra•ing in to the Latin Church.(l) Cresp•tius (a Popish Author) being willing to prove that this mode of praying was used by Christians in the Primitive Times: He endeavours (as Mr. K. does) to confirm his notion by Pliny's, Carmen dicere sibi invicem; unto whom the most Learned