N01303:45
Grace defended. A censure on the ungodliness, by which the glorious grace of God,…
Grace defended. A censure on the ungodliness, by which the glorious grace of God, is too commonly abused. A sermon preached on the twenty fifth day of December, 1712. Containing some seasonable admonitions of piety. And concluded, with a brief dissertation on that case, whether the penitent thief on the cross, be an example of one repenting at the last hour, and on such a repentance received unto mercy? / By Cotton Mather, D.D. ; [One line from Isaiah]
Boston: printed by B. Green for Samuel Gerrish, 1712
Conclusion: A Few Thoughts on that QUESTION; Whether the Penitent Thief on the Cross, be not an Exa…
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First, there is nothing in the Sacred History, to brand this Poor Man with the Character of an Unrepenting Sinner, at the Time of his being brought forth to his Execution. Two of the Evangelists, Matthew, and his Follower and Abridger Mark, indeed Speak in the Plural Number, as if both of the Thieves at first joined in the Reproaches of our Saviour. And if it were so, it may remain a Query, How far a true Penitent heartily bewailing of all his Wickedness, and believing in the Sacrifice of the Promised Messiah for the Pardon of it, might yet be so circumstanced, as to be kept Invincibly Ignorant, that our Blessed JESUS, was this Messiah? But then I concur with those more Judicious Writers, who do by no means allow, that the Thief whom we now have our Eye upon, did himself Reproach our Saviour. Drusius is displeased at them who make this objection of the Plural Number, and sayes, Apagi••, qui non didicistis Liter as Hebraicas. ⟨p. 28⟩They are ignorant of the Hebrew Style. [See Judg. XII. 7.] It is also observed as a peculiar, but perpetual way, taken by the Evangelist Matthew, in his Writing, That where Several Persons are joined, and One Speaks, and it is either in the Name of the rest, or the rest are Silent at it, he refers the Speeches or Actions of that One, unto the whole Number present, [A Notable Example, see Matth. XX. 30 with Mar. X. 46. And another, Matth. XXVI 8. with Joh. XII. 4.] Thus, we read of Things Written in the Prophets, when only One of the Prophets wrote them. Glassius will further satisfy you. Tis a frequent Synecdoche. This is indeed an Ancient Observation: and it leaves us cause to Suspect, as very Learned Expositors have conjectured, That the other Thief alone Reproached our Saviour, as Luke relates it, and this was wholly Silent at the First, until the Violence of his Companions Language, and the consideration of the astonishing Accidents than in his View, compelled him at once to rebuke his Companion, and Confess his Redeemer. I am far from thinking the Apostolical Constitutions, to be of that Antiquity and Authority which a famous Arian in our Days would assign unto them. Yet some things in them, are of such Antiquity, as to deserve that Reverence and Reception with us, which is due to the Opinion of the Ancients. And it is a little Confirmation of my Opinion in this case, that the Apostolical Constitutions do favour it.