I can by no means approve of your Leaning on the Tool of a Foolish Shepherd, and your Living on the Lifeless Forms of any Liturgy. I cannot commend any Liturgy to you, except that which Baronius, taxed good old Agobardus for keeping to. I can do no other than tell you so, after a Bellarmine himself has confessed, That in old times, there was no Form of Prayer prescribed, for all to be ⟨p. 112⟩bound unto, but every One might make what Prayer he pleased, if but the Analogy of Faith were kept unto. And Chemnitius with a whole Army of Protestants, have irrefragably proved, That this Confession of Bellarmine is true; and, Apud Veteres Ordinem Celebrandi fuisse Arbitrarium. The Ancients all agree to it, That in the Earlier Days of Christianity, the Ministers prayed every where, As they were Able. Indeed, there was no General Imposition of any Service Book, until the Emperor Charlemagne at the Solicitation of the Pope, introduced it, with Persecution; which was not until the Entrance of the Ninth Century, when all manner of Superstitious Usages were brought into the Temple of GOD. Some Judicious Men have complained of the French Liturgy composed by the Excellent Calvin, for not having sufficient Collects of Thanksgiving, but being all Petition. And whereas these three Things, Confession, and Petition, and Thanksgiving belong to every complete Prayer, I have heard some enquire whether according to this Rule, there can be readily found One complete Prayer, in another Liturgy, which I cannot commend unto you, for such a Model of Perfection, as its admirers have esteemed it. But waving here those many and weighty Exceptions against the English Common Prayer-Book, which will forever cause Myriads of Considerate Christians to be dissatisfied with it, I will only Quote some Words that I find falling from the Pen of an English Nobleman. There may be too great a Restraint, [he says] put upon Men, whom GOD hath distinguished by giving them not only good Sense, but a Powerful Utterance too. When ⟨p. 113⟩a Man so Qualified, endued with Learning too, and above all, adorned with a Good Life, breaks out into a Warm and Well-delivered Prayer before his Sermon, it has the Appearance of a Divine Rapture; He raises and leads the Hearts of the Assembly in another Manner, than the most composed or best studied Form of Set Words, can ever do:
I can by no means approve of your Leaning on the Tool of a Foolish Shepherd, and your Living on the Lifeless Forms of any Liturgy. I cannot commend any Liturgy to you, except that which Baronius, taxed good old Agobardus for keeping to. I can do no other than tell you so, after a Bellarmine himself has confessed, That in old times, there was no Form of Prayer prescribed, for all to be ⟨p. 112⟩bound unto, but every One might make what Prayer he pleased, if but the Analogy of Faith were kept unto. And Chemnitius with a whole Army of Protestants, have irrefragably proved, That this Confession of Bellarmine is true; and, Apud Veteres Ordinem Celebrandi fuisse Arbitrarium. The Ancients all agree to it, That in the Earlier Days of Christianity, the Ministers prayed every where, As they were Able. Indeed, there was no General Imposition of any Service Beok, until the Emperor Charlemaigne at the Sollicitation of the Pope, introduced it, with Persecution; which was not until the Entrance of the Ninth Century, when all manner of Superstitious Usages were brought into the Temple of GOD. Some Judicious Men have complained of the French Liturgy composed by the Excellent Calvin, for not having sufficient Collects of Thanksgiving, but being all Petition. And whereas these three Things, Confession, and Petition, and Thanksgiving belong to every complete Prayer, I have heard some enquire whether according to this Rule, there can be readily found One complete Prayer, in another Liturgy, which I cannot commend unto you, for such a Model of Perfection, as its admirers have esteemed it. But waving here those many and weighty Exceptions against the English Common Prayer-Book, which will forever cause Myriads of Considerate Christians to be dissatissied with it, I will only Quote some Words that I find falling from the Pen of an English Nobleman. There may be too great a Restraint, [he says] put upon Men, whom GOD hath distinguished by giving them not only good Sense, but a Powerful Utterance too. When ⟨p. 113⟩a Man so Qualified, endued with Learning too, and above all, adorned with a Good Life, breaks out into a Warm and Well-delivered Prayer before his Sermon, it has the Appearance of a Divine Rapture; He raises and leads the Hearts of the Assembly in another Manner, than the most composed or best studied Form of Set Words, can ever do: