N04498:11
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr.…
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr. Clap, Rector of Yale College in New-Haven, in reply to his late printed letter to him, relating to what he reported concerning the Rev. Mr. Whitefield, at Boston and Cambridge and elsewhere, as from Mr. Edwards; making the falsity of that report yet much more manifest. : [Two lines from Job]
Boston: printed by Kneeland and Green, 1745
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And tho' it be true, that I had a Suspicion of Mr. Whitefield's aiming at People's forsaking unconverted Ministers; ⟨p. 6⟩and so it was not wholly impossible that I should mention it to you, going to Boston; and therefore I can't absolutely deny that, and have hitherto strained my Charity towards you to the utmost, with Respect to that Matter (tho' as I often said before, I had no Remembrance of it) yet the more I think of it, the more improbable it appears to me that I should; my Daughter, that was with me at the particular Time you fix upon, remembers nothing of it; and besides there is that in particular, that makes it very unlikely that I should say any Thing to you at that Time, of so much as that Suspicion, viz. That presently after Mr. Whitefield went from these Parts, being in Conversation with the Rev. Mr. Hopkins of Springfield, even the next Day after we parted with Mr. Whitefield at Windsor, Mr. Hopkins being my Brother-in-Law, and then appearing friendly to Mr. Whitefield, I mentioned that Suspicion to him (which is the only Time that I know of that I ever mentioned it to any Body, any otherwise than on its being reported from him, I might give an Account what I said to him) I gave him several Reasons of my Suspicion: (But that Mr. Whitefield had told me any such Thing, was not among these Reasons.) After this, before our forementioned Journey to Boston, I heard that Mr. Hopkins had reported it to others, and that the Report was carried to New-Haven to you and others there, and much taken Notice of by you; which gave me no small Uneasiness: I was not a little concerned, that what I had thus said privately to my Brother Hopkins, should be thus carried abroad, and especially that it should be handed to you. Now after this, it is not very likely that I should go, and more fully declare the same Thing to you myself; and especially that I should tell you much more than that; and that, which if it was true, I closely concealed from my ⟨p. 7⟩Brother Hopkins. Some of the Ministers of this County, that have lately signed a Testimony against Mr. Whitefield, had before heard Mr. Hopkins relate what I told him of my Suspicion, with the Reasons I gave him; and since this Controversy between you and me, have declared freely that it is a convincing Argument with them, that I never told you, that Mr.
And tho' it be true, that I had a Suspicion of Mr. Whitefield's aiming at People's forsaking unconverted Ministers;