N04498:18
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr.…
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr. Clap, Rector of Yale College in New-Haven, in reply to his late printed letter to him, relating to what he reported concerning the Rev. Mr. Whitefield, at Boston and Cambridge and elsewhere, as from Mr. Edwards; making the falsity of that report yet much more manifest. : [Two lines from Job]
Boston: printed by Kneeland and Green, 1745
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Supposing me to be of Opinion that Rector Clap has had a Design to do his utmost to ruin my Reputation, by artfully misleading the Minds of his unwary cursory Readers, into a Belief that I have evidently perjured my self, by flatly contradicting myself upon Oath, when he himself knew in his Heart that there was no real Contradiction at all; I say, supposing this to be my Opinion, I can declare it to be my Opinion with Truth: But can I therefore truly declare to others, that Mr. Clap told me that this very Thing was his Design? And if I should declare so, would not you resent it, as an injurious Falsehood and Slander? And if I should excuse my self, and say, No, I had that Opinion of you, and that was the same Thing as for me to hear you say so; would you then think there was no Distinction, and that it was a senseless Thing to pretend any?
Supposing me to be of Opinion that Rector Clap has had a Design to do his utmost to ruin my Reputation, by artfully misleading the Minds of his unwary cursory Readers, into a Belief that I have evidently perjured my self, by flatly contradicting myself upon Oath, when he himself knew in his Heart that there was no real Contradiction at all; I say, supposing this to be my Opinion, I can declare it to be my Opinion with Truth: But can I therefore truly declare to others, that Mr. Clap told me that this very Thing was his Design? And if I should declare so, would not you resent it, as an injurious Falshood and Slander? And if I should excuse my self, and say, No, I had that Opinion of you, and that was the same Thing as for me to hear you say so; would you then think there was no Distinction, and that it was a senseless Thing to pretend any?
And then besides, I not only don't say in my Letters, that Mr. Whitefield told me that he intended to do those Things that you reported, but am far from saying so much as that it was my Opinion that he intended those Things. My saying, it was my Opinion that Mr. Whitefield did aim at People's forsaking unconverted Ministers, and at the introducing of converted ones, is surely not the same Thing as to say, it was my Opinion that Mr. Whitefield intended to turn the bigger Part of the Ministers of the Country out of their Places, and bring over Ministers from England, Scotland, and Ireland, and place them in their Room. It is my Opinion of many Persons in the World, that I know of, that they are in the Opinion and Scheme