N04498:20
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr.…
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr. Clap, Rector of Yale College in New-Haven, in reply to his late printed letter to him, relating to what he reported concerning the Rev. Mr. Whitefield, at Boston and Cambridge and elsewhere, as from Mr. Edwards; making the falsity of that report yet much more manifest. : [Two lines from Job]
Boston: printed by Kneeland and Green, 1745
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But you say (p. 8 and 9.) It is an immaterial Circumstance what Countries the Ministers were to be brought from, and that it matters not whether I said one Word of Foreigners supplying the Pulpits of other Ministers, or no: And therefore insist upon it, that for me to say, that it was my Opinion, that Mr. Whitefield aimed at People's forsaking unconverted Ministers, and introducing converted Ministers, was for me to say, that it was my Opinion Mr. Whitefield intended all that you have represented; and not only this, but to say that Mr. Whitefield told me so; insomuch that to say otherwise is a flat Contradiction; and you represent that to make any Distinction is absurd.
But you say (p. 8 and 9.) It is an immaterial Circumstance what Countries the Ministers were to be brought from, and that it matters not whether I said one Word of Foreigners supplying the Pulpits of other Ministers, or no: And therefore insist upon it, that for me to say, that it was my Opinion, that Mr. Whitefield aim'd at People's forsaking unconverted Ministers, and introducing converted Ministers, was for me to say, that it was my Opinion Mr. Whitefield intended all that you have represented; and not only this, but to say that Mr. Whitefield told me so; insomuch that to say otherwise is a flat Contradiction; and you represent that to make any Distinction is absurd.
Now Sir, if it be really so, I would ask, Why, instead of reporting that you heard me say that Mr. Whitefield told me that he intended to turn out the bigger Part of the Ministers in the Country &c. you did not rather declare plainly and positively, at Boston and Cambridge and elsewhere, that Mr. Whitefield told you this Story of his Intentions? For you signify over and over in your two printed Letters, that it was your Opinion that he intended to turn out unconverted Ministers and introduce others, before you talked with me. And therefore by your own Account it is really true, that Mr. Whitefield told you all that you reported as from me (at least every Thing that was material, or worthy of any Notice in it) and you can't deny it with Truth, and without making absurd Distinctions, and strange Quibbling and Equivocation, yea, plain and flat Self-Contradiction. Surely it would have been more to your Purpose to have declared this Thing, as one that was an Ear-Witness; without having Recourse to a Report you had heard from another. Yea, and not only so, but you might have produced a great many Witnesses to vouch the Truth of the same, and might have said that you heard a great many Persons say that Mr. Whitefield told them so too. For you speak of the generality of others that were exactly of the same Opinion with you and me in this Point. (Letter 1st. p. 6. Letter 2d. p. 5.)