N04498:21
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr.…
An expostulatory letter from the Rev. Mr. Edwards of Northampton, to the Rev. Mr. Clap, Rector of Yale College in New-Haven, in reply to his late printed letter to him, relating to what he reported concerning the Rev. Mr. Whitefield, at Boston and Cambridge and elsewhere, as from Mr. Edwards; making the falsity of that report yet much more manifest. : [Two lines from Job]
Boston: printed by Kneeland and Green, 1745
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Now Sir, if it be really so, I would ask, Why, instead of reporting that you heard me say that Mr. Whitefield told me that he intended to turn out the bigger Part of the Ministers in the Country &c. you did not rather declare plainly and positively, at Boston and Cambridge and elsewhere, that Mr. Whitefield told you this Story of his Intentions? For you signify over and over in your two printed Letters, that it was your Opinion that he intended to turn out unconverted Ministers and introduce others, before you talked with me. And therefore by your own Account it is really true, that Mr. Whitefield told you all that you reported as from me (at least every Thing that was material, or worthy of any Notice in it) and you can't deny it with Truth, and without making absurd Distinctions, and strange Quibbling and Equivocation, yea, plain and flat Self-Contradiction. Surely it would have been more to your Purpose to have declared this Thing, as one that was an Ear-Witness; without having Recourse to a Report you had heard from another. Yea, and not only so, but you might have produced a great many Witnesses to vouch the Truth of the same, and might have said that you heard a great many Persons say that Mr. Whitefield told them so too. For you speak of the generality of others that were exactly of the same Opinion with you and me in this Point. (Letter 1st. p. 6. Letter 2d. p. 5.)
And there is another Difficulty that needs to be cleared up, with Respect to your Conduct in this Matter. — When you first appeared in this Controversy in Print you represent the Matter as tho' you and I were well agreed in our private Letters, and said the same Thing; and signify as much as that it appeared so to you on the Receipt of my Letters, and that therefore it appeared unaccountable to you that any Contradiction should be ⟨p. 13⟩insisted on between you and me (Letter 2d. at the Beginning) And this is almost the only Argument you have insisted on in both your printed Letters, that your Report is true. And yet in the Controversy, as it was managed between us in private Letters, a considerable Time before you appeared in public, this was never so much as once mentioned, or pretended. There is no Appearance in your private Letters to me, as tho' you supposed that you and I agreed in the least Measure, not a Lisp of my unaccountably insisting on a Contradiction where there was none, no Intimation of any Difficulty you found in my Letters of that Nature. Which is something strange, if it was so, that you did really then think that there was such an Agreement, and that I in Effect owned all, & you was then astonished at a Pretence of a Contradiction between you and me where there was none, but saw so great & manifest a Contradiction between the various Parts of my Letters, as you speak of. You represent as tho' you wrote to me in a friendly and pacific Manner; but then it was strange you did not mention that which you took so much Notice of, that you must think would tend above all Things to my Conviction. But there is not a Hint of any such Thing in your private pacific Letters (as you call 'em) either for my Conviction, or your Vindication; but when you come to appear in public, then you are full of it, for my Reproach, and insist on scarce any Thing else.