N05035:206
An humble inquiry into the rules of the Word of God, concerning the qualifications…
An humble inquiry into the rules of the Word of God, concerning the qualifications requisite to a complete standing and full communion in the visible Christian church. By Jonathan Edwards, A.M. Pastor of the First Church in Northampton. ; With an appendix by Mr. Foxcroft. ; [Ten lines of quotations]An humble inquiry into the rules of the Word of God, concerning the qualifications requisite to a compleat standing and full communion in the visible Christian church. By Jonathan Edwards, A.M. Pastor of the First Church in Northampton. ; With an appendix by Mr. Foxcroft. ; [Ten lines of quotations]
Boston: : Printed & sold by S. Kneeland in Queenstreet, 1749
Title page typeset from the transcription.
An Inquiry into the Qualifications for full Communion in the visibl… › Part 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
ANSW. I own, the Scripture calls the Members of the visible Church by the Name of Disciples. But I deny, it therefore follows that the Church which they are Members of, is duly and properly constituted of those who have not true Piety. Because, if this Consequence was good, then it would equally follow, that not only the visible, but also the invisible or mystical Church is properly constituted of those who have not unfeigned Faith and true Piety. For the Members of the mystical Church, as such, and to denote the special Character of such, are called Disciples; in Luke xiv. 26, 27, 33. and in Job. viii. 31. Chap. xiii. 35. and Chap. xv. 8. This shows, that in the Argument I am answering, there is no Connection between the Premisses and the Conclusion. For the Force of the Objection consists in this, that the Members of the visible Church are called Disciples in Scripture: This is the Sum total of the Premisses: And if there be any Connection between the Premisses and the Conclusion, it must lie in the Truth of this Proposition; The Church whose Members are called by the Name of Disciples, as signifying their State and Quality as Members of that Society, that Church is properly and fitly constituted, not only of Persons truly pious, but of others that have merely a common Faith and Virtue. But this Proposition, we have seen, is not true; and so there is no Connection between the former and latter Part of it, which are the same with the Premisses and Conclusion of this Argument.
ANSW. I own, the Scripture calls the Members of the visible Church by the Name of Disciples. But I deny, it therefore follows that the Church which they are Members of, is duly and properly constituted of those who have not true Piety. Because, if this Consequence was good, then it would equally follow, that not only the visible, but also the invisible or mystical Church is properly constituted of those who have not unfeigned Faith and true Piety. For the Members of the mystical Church, as such, and to denote the special Character of such, are called Disciples; in Luke xiv. 26, 27, 33. and in Job. viii. 31. Chap. xiii. 35. and Chap. xv. 8. This shews, that in the Argument I am answering, there is no Connection between the Premisses and the Conclusion. For the Force of the Objection consists in this, that the Members of the visible Church are called Disciples in Scripture: This is the Sum total of the Premisses: And if there be any Connection between the Premisses and the Conclusion, it must lie in the Truth of this Proposition; The Church whose Members are called by the Name of Disciples, as signifying their State and Quality as Members of that Society, that Church is properly and fitly constituted, not only of Persons truly pious, but of others that have meerly a common Faith and Vertue. But this Proposition, we have seen, is not true; and so there is no Connection between the former and latter Part of it, which are the same with the Premisses and Conclusion of this Argument.