N05663:247
A careful and strict enquiry into the modern prevailing notions of that freedom of…
A careful and strict enquiry into the modern prevailing notions of that freedom of will, which is supposed to be essential to moral agency, virtue and vice, reward and punishment, praise and blame. By Jonathan Edwards, A.M. Pastor of the church in Stockbridge. ; [One line from Romans]A careful and strict enquiry into the modern prevailing notions of that freedom of will, which is supposed to be essential to moral agency, vertue and vice, reward and punishment, praise and blame. By Jonathan Edwards, A.M. Pastor of the church in Stockbridge. ; [One line from Romans]
printed by S. Kneeland, 1754
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
If any should suppose, that Mr. Chubb, when he speaks of Motive as a passive Ground of Action, don't mean passive with Regard to that Volition which it is the Ground of, but some other antecedent Volition▪ (tho' his Purpose and Argument, and whole Discourse, will by no Means allow of such a Supposition) yet it would not help the Matter in the least. For, (1.) If we suppose there to be an Act of Volition or Choice, by which the Soul chooses to yield to the Invitation of a Motive to another Volition, by which the Soul chooses something else; both these supposed Volitions are in Effect the very same. A Volition, or choosing to yield to the Force of a Motive inviting to choose something, comes to just the same Thing as choosing the Thing which the Motive invites to, as I observed before. So that here can be no Room to help the Matter, by a Distinction of two Volitions. (2.) If the Motive be passive with Respect, not to the same Volition that the Motive excites to, but one truly distinct and prior; yet, by Mr. Chubb, that prior Volition can't take Place, without a Motive or Excitement, as a previous Ground of it's Existence. For he insists, that it is absurd to suppose any Volition should take Place without some previous Motive to induce it. So that at last it comes to just the same Absurdity: for •f every Volition must have a previous Motive, then the very first in the whole Series must be excited by a previous Motive; and yet the Motive to that first Volition is passive; but can't be passive with Regard to another antecedent Volition, because, by the Supposition, it is the very first: Therefore if it be passive with Respect to any Volition, it must be so with Regard to that very Volition that it is the Ground of, and that is excited by it.
If any should suppose, that Mr. Chubb, when he speaks of Motive as a passive Ground of Action, don't mean passive with Regard to that Volition which it is the Ground of, but some other antecedent Volition▪ (tho' his Purpose and Argument, and whole Discourse, will by no Means allow of such a Supposition) yet it would not help the Matter in the least. For, (1.) If we suppose there to be an Act of Volition or Choice, by which the Soul chuses to yield to the Invitation of a Motive to another Volition, by which the Soul chuses something else; both these supposed Volitions are in Effect the very same. A Volition, or chusing to yield to the Force of a Motive inviting to chuse something, comes to just the same Thing as chusing the Thing which the Motive invites to, as I observed before. So that here can be no Room to help the Matter, by a Distinction of two Volitions. (2.) If the Motive be passive with Respect, not to the same Volition that the Motive excites to, but one truly distinct and prior; yet, by Mr. Chubb, that prior Volition can't take Place, without a Motive or Excitement, as a previous Ground of it's Existence. For he insists, that it is absurd to suppose any Volition should take Place without some previous Motive to induce it. So that at last it comes to just the same Absurdity: for f every Volition must have a previous Motive, then the very first in the whole Series must be excited by a previous Motive; and yet the Motive to that first Volition is passive; but can't be passive with Regard to another antecedent Volition, because, by the Supposition, it is the very first: Therefore if it be passive with Respect to any Volition, it must be so with Regard to that very Volition that it is the Ground of, and that is excited by it.