There is difference betwixt Error, Schism, and Heresy. Error is when one holds a wrong opinion alone: schism, when many consent in their opinion: heresy runs further, and contends to root out the truth. Error offends, but separates not: Schism offends and separates: Heresy offends, separates, and rageth; making the party good vi & armis; if not with arguments of reason, yet with arguments of steel and iron. Error is weak, Schism strong, Heresy obstinate. Error goes out, and often comes in again; Schism comes not in, but makes a new Church: ⟨p. 380⟩Heresy makes not a new Church, but no Church. Error untiles the house, Schism pulls down the walls, but Heresy overturns the foundation. Error is as a child, Schism a wild stripling, Heresy an old dotard. Error will hear reason, Schism will wrangle against it, Heresy will defy it. Error is a member blistered, Schism a member festered, Heresy a member cut off. He that returns quickly from error, is not a Schismatic: he that returns from Schism, is not an Heretic. Error is reproved and pitied, Schism is reproved and punished, Heresy is reproved and excommunicated. Schism is in the same faith, Heresy makes another faith. Though they may be thus distinguished, yet without Gods preventing grace, one will run into another: error will prove a Schism, and schismatical follies will prove stigmatical furies. When Augustine said, Errare possum, haereticum esse non possum; I may err, I cannot be an Heretic: it proceeded from the confident persuasion of Gods mercy, and the resolution of his own heart, to adhere constantly to the truth. The Heretic exceeds the Schismatic: the one hates only peace, the other hates truth. Psal. 120.6. My soul hath long dwelt with him the hateth peace. But, Psal. 139.21 Do not I hate them, O Lord, that hate thee? He may dwell with them that hate peace: he will not endure them that hate the truth. All faults are not of the same degree; there is a moat and a beam, there is stubble and lead. 1 Tim. 6.3. If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to the words of Christ, If he consent not, that is Schismatical: if he Teach otherwise, that is Heretical. Matth. 5.19. Whosoever shall break one of the least Commandments, and teach men so, &c. If he break the Law, that is a personal sin: but if he teach so, that is a pestilent sin.
There is difference betwixt Error, Schisme, and Heresie. Error is when one holds a wrong opinion alone: schisme, when many consent in their opinion: heresie runs further, and contends to roote out the truth. Error offends, but separates not: Schisme offends and separates: Heresie offends, separates, and rageth; making the partie good vi & armis; if not with arguments of reason, yet with arguments of steele and iron. Error is weake, Schisme strong, Heresie obstinate. Error goes out, and often comes in againe; Schisme comes not in, but makes a new Church: ⟨p. 380⟩Heresie makes not a new Church, but no Church. Error untiles the house, Schisme pulls downe the walls, but Heresie overturnes the foundation. Error is as a child, Schisme a wild stripling, Heresie an old dotard. Error will heare reason, Schisme will wrangle against it, Heresie will defie it. Error is a member blistered, Schisme a member festered, Heresie a member cut off. He that returnes quickly from error, is not a Schismaticke: he that returnes from Schisme, is not an Hereticke. Error is reproved and pitied, Schisme is reproved and punished, Heresie is reproved and excommunicated. Schisme is in the same faith, Heresie makes another faith. Though they may be thus distinguished, yet without Gods preventing grace, one will run into another: error will prove a Schisme, and schismaticall follies will prove stigmaticall furies. When Augustine said, Errare possum, haereticum esse non possum; I may erre, I cannot be an Hereticke: it proceeded from the confident perswasion of Gods mercie, and the resolution of his owne heart, to adhere constantly to the truth. The Hereticke exceeds the Schismaticke: the one hates only peace, the other hates truth. Psal. 120.6. My soule hath long dwelt with him the hateth peace. But, Psal. 139.21 Doe not I hate them, O Lord, that hate thee? He may dwell with them that hate peace: he will not endure them that hate the truth. All faults are not of the same degree; there is a moate and a beame, there is stubble and lead. 1 Tim. 6.3. If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to the words of Christ, If hee consent not, that is Schismaticall: if hee Teach otherwise, that is Hereticall. Matth. 5.19. Whosoever shall breake one of the least Commandements, and teach men so, &c. If he breake the Law, that is a personall sinne: but if he teach so, that is a pestilent sinne.