T. G. No: you have said, though not enough, because bnothing at all to the point, not one tittle to make your Argument good, or to prove the main matter denied in it; yet a great deal ctoo much; because so much clean beside the matter. And here nothing but unsavoury stuff, unworthy to be answered.
You tell here of Mr. Gs. writing, which you never returned any answer to. Why pick you this alone out of it, letting pass many other things in it of more moment still unanswered?
But what is the fault here I marvel, that hath ⟨p. 242⟩moved Mr. Bs. choler thus much? I say, forsooth there is in play a controversy, and that it tendeth to victory. And is it not so in all games and sports ordinarily? Or doth not dcommon use of speech confirm as much? matter of desert, I think, is not usually much respected in play. Yet in those Games that Mr. B. condemneth there is euse of wit and Art to in managing what the Chance affordeth. I might add that there is in Game question, and controversy also, if with Mr. Bs. leave I may so speak, whether of the two shall lead, and who shall join either with other, either of which in some cases may well be termed a controversy, though it tend not directly unto victory, and which by Lot also is and may be lawfully decided, for ought Mr. B. hath hitherto to the contrary discovered.
But what kind of controversy or victory soever it be, that is in Game and disport, must they needs all be styled vainglorious fools, that in game strive, as we say, who shall beat either other. This favoureth too much of supercilious (for I will not say superstitious) either Stoicism or Pharisaism.
But his reason hereof is worth all: for that is it that is all in all with Mr. B. which if you once debar him of, fhe is as mute as a Fish, and standeth stone still, as gone at his wits end. It is a tempting of God, by putting him to dispose the Lot by his immediate providence, and thereby to humour such vain-glorious fools. This is the hhead and foot of all, the perpetual burden of Mr. Bs. song, which if you grant him, he is able to prove all that ever he would: but if it go, iall is gone with it.
T. G. No: you haue said, though not enough, because bnothing at all to the point, not one tittle to make your Argument good, or to proue the maine matter denied in it; yet a great deale ctoo much; because so much cleane beside the matter. And here nothing but vnsauoury stuffe, vnworthy to be answered.
You tell here of Mr. Gs. writing, which you neuer returned any answer to. Why picke you this alone out of it, letting passe many other things in it of more moment still vnanswered?
But what is the fault here I maruell, that hath ⟨p. 242⟩moued Mr. Bs. choler thus much? I say, forsooth there is in play a controuersie, and that it tendeth to victory. And is it not so in all games and sports ordinarily? Or doth not dcommon vse of speech confirme as much? matter of desert, I thinke, is not vsually much respected in play. Yet in those Games that Mr. B. condemneth there is evse of wit and Art to in managing what the Chance affordeth. I might adde that there is in Game question, and controuersie also, if with Mr. Bs. leaue I may so speake, whether of the two shall leade, and who shall ioyne either with other, either of which in some cases may well be termed a controuersie, though it tend not directly vnto victory, and which by Lot also is and may be lawfully decided, for ought Mr. B. hath hitherto to the contrary discouered.
But what kinde of controuersie or victory soeuer it be, that is in Game and disport, must they needs all be stiled vaineglorious fooles, that in game striue, as we say, who shall beat either other. This fauoureth too much of supercilious (for I will not say superstitious) either Stoicisme or Pharisaisme.
But his reason hereof is worth all: for that is it that is all in all with Mr. B. which if you once debarre him of, fhe is as mute as a Fish, and standeth stone still, as gone at his wits end. It is a tempting of God, by putting him to dispose the Lot by his immediate prouidence, and thereby to humour such vaine-glorious fooles. This is the hhead and foot of all, the perpetuall burden of Mr. Bs. song, which if you grant him, he is able to proue all that euer he would: but if it goe,
- b[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
- cQuomodo ille, Fortuna multis dat nimis, nulli satis. Martial.
- d[Greek or Hebrew]. Eustath. ad Il. [Greek or Hebrew]. ex Pausan. Lex. Attic. [Greek or Hebrew]. Pollux. l. 9. c. 7. [Greek or Hebrew]. Ibid. Vicissem velquinquaginta millia Aug. apud Sueton. c. 71. Aliquandò ut vineat, ludit assiduè aleam. Ibid. c. 70. Verū in rebus apertis argumentari tam sit stultū, quam in clarissimū Solē mortal lumen infer. Quint inst. l. 5. c. 12〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Eustath. ad Il. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. ex Pausan. Lex. Attic. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Pollux. l. 9. c. 7. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Ibid. Vicissem velquinquaginta millia Aug. apud Sueton. c. 71. Aliquandò ut vineat, ludit assiduè aleam. Ibid. c. 70. Verū in rebus apertis argumentari tam sit stultū, quam in clarissimū Solē mortale lumen inferre. Quint inst. l. 5. c. 12
- e[Greek or Hebrew]. Sophocl. Palā. [Greek or Hebrew]. Hesych.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Sophocl. Palā. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Hesych.
- f[Greek or Hebrew]. Lucian. Gallo.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Lucian. Gallo.
- gAd incitas redact'. Plaut. Trin. 2. 4.
- h[Greek or Hebrew]. Prora & puppis. Cic. epist. sam. l. 16. ep. 24.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Prora & puppis. Cic. epist. sam. l. 16. ep. 24.
- i[Greek or Hebrew]. Philostr. in Hero. c.