I.b.s answer
pp. 104–1051 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I. B. Now then to a fifth Argument à concessis, as Mr. G. 1termeth it, p. 135. Any thing indifferent is lawful matter of recreation. But Lottery is a thing indifferent. Lottery therefore may be made lawful matter of disport. The Proposition is confirmed by the words of Mr. Fennor. Christian, saith he, recreation is the exercise of some thing indifferent for the necessary refreshing of body or mind. The Assumption is also proved by Mr. Fennor. Indifferent in nature is that which is left free, so as we are not simply commanded or forbidden to use it. But such is Lottery, saith Mr. G. Not simply commanded. ⟨p. 105⟩For Prou. 18. 18. is rather a permission than a precept: or, Not so much a commandment, as an advice commending that as a prudent course. Nor any where forbidden as evil in it self.
I. B. Now then to a fifth Argument à concessis, as Mr. G. 1termeth it, p. 135. Any thing indifferent is lawfull matter of recreation. But Lottery is a thing indifferent. Lotterie therefore may be made lawfull matter of disport. The Proposition is confirmed by the words of Mr. Fennor. Christian, saith he, recreation is the exercise of some thing indifferent for the necessarie refreshing of bodie or minde. The Assumption is also proued by Mr. Fennor. Indifferent in nature is that which is left free, so as we are not simply commanded or forbidden to vse it. But such is Lotterie, saith Mr. G. Not simply commanded. ⟨p. 105⟩For Prou. 18. 18. is rather a permission than a precept: or, Not so much a commandement, as an aduice commending that as a prudent course. Nor any where forbidden as euill in it selfe.
- 1I. B. Answer.