First, Demonstrations.
pp. 36–429 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 36–429 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To sin, though out of simple ignorance, when that ignorance is but the causa sine qua non of sinning, that is, so as if a man had known it a sin, he had not done it, doth not yet make the fact not to be a sin, though it lesseneth it. For Luke 12. 48. He that did not know his Masters will, was beaten, when the thing committed was worthy of stripes, though he did not know so much, because the thing deserves it. And the reason is, because the Law being once promulged, as 1. to Adam it was, and put into his heart, as the common ark of mankind; though the tables be lost, yet our ignorance doth not make the Law of none effect. For the Law of nature for ever binds, that is, all that was written in Adams heart, because it was thereby then published in him, and to him for us. But positive laws, as I may call them, as to believe in Christ, &c. anew delivered, bind not, but where they are published. Josiah rent his clothes, when the book of the Law was found, because the ordinances were not kept, although they had not known the Law of many years; yet because ⟨p. 37⟩they ought to have known it, therefore for all their ignorance, he feared wrath would come upon all Israel. So also Lev. 5. 17. sins of ignorance were to be sacrificed for: yet however, it lesseneth the sin, therefore he shall be beaten with few stripes.
To sinne, though out of simple ignorance, when that ignorance is but the causa sine qua non of sinning, that is, so as if a man had knowne it a sinne, he had not done it, doth not yet make the fact not to be a sinne, though it lesseneth it. For Luke 12. 48. He that did not know his Masters will, was beaten, when the thing committed was worthy of stripes, though he did not know so much, because the thing deserves it. And the reason is, because the Law being once promulged, as 1. to Adam it was, and put into his heart, as the common ark of mankinde; though the tables be lost, yet our ignorance doth not make the Law of none effect. For the Law of nature for ever binds, that is, all that was written in Adams heart, because it was thereby then published in him, and to him for us. But positive lawes, as I may call them, as to beleeve in Christ, &c. anew delivered, bind not, but where they are publisht. Iosiah rent his clothes, when the booke of the Law was found, because the ordinances were not kept, although they had not knowne the Law of many yeares; yet because ⟨p. 37⟩they ought to have knowne it, therefore for all their ignorance, he feared wrath would come upon all Israel. So also Lev. 5. 17. sinnes of ignorance were to be sacrificed for: yet however, it lesseneth the sin, therefore he shall be beaten with few stripes.
And sure, if ignorance lesseneth them, knowledge aggravates; for contrariorum eadem est ratio: therefore he that knows, shall be beaten with many stripes. Yea such difference is there, that God is said to wink at sins of ignorance. Acts 17. 30. The time of this ignorance God winks at. Whiles they had no knowledge, God took no notice: yea and he abates something for such sins, because the creature hath a cloak, hath something to say for its self; (as Christ says, John 15. 22.) but when against knowledge, they have no cloak. Yea farther, Christ makes a sin of ignorance to be no sin, in comparison: So there, If I had not spoken and done those works never man did, they had had [no sin.] (That is) none in comparison, but now they have no cloak, 1no shelter to award the stripes, or plea to abate of them.
And sure, if ignorance lesseneth them, knowledge aggravates; for contrariorum eadem est ratio: therefore he that knowes, shall be beaten with many stripes. Yea such difference is there, that God is said to wink at sins of ignorance. Acts 17. 30. The time of this ignorance God winks at. Whiles they had no knowledge, God tooke no notice: yea and he abates something for such sinnes, because the creature hath a cloake, hath something to say for its selfe; (as Christ sayes, Iohn 15. 22.) but when against knowledge, they have no cloak. Yea farther, Christ makes a sinne of ignorance to be no sinne, in comparison: So there, If I had not spoken and done those workes never man did, they had had [no sinne.] (That is) none in comparison, but now they have no cloak, 1no shelter to award the stripes, or plea to abate of them.
And that you may see the ground of this vast difference between sins of ignorance, and against knowledge,1 consider first, that if a man sin §1(suppose the act the same) out of ignorance merely, there may be a supposition, that if he had known it, he would not have done it; and that as soon as he doth know it, he would or might repent of it. So 1 Cor. 2. 8. If they had known, they had not crucified the Lord of Glory. The like ⟨p. 38⟩says Christ of Tyre, Sidon, and Gomorrah, that if the same things had been done in them, they would have repented. But now when a man knows it afore, and also considers it in the very committing it, and yet doth it, then there is no room for such a supposition, and less hope. For what is it that should reduce this man to repentance? is it not his knowledge? now if that had no power to keep him from his sin, then it may be judged, that it will not be of force to bring him to repentance for it; for by sinning the heart is made more hard, and the knowledge and the authority of it weakened and lessened, as all power is, when contemned and resisted, Rom. 1. 21. their foolish heart becomes darker. Aristotle himself hath a touch of this notion in the third of his Ethics, that if a man sin out of ignorance, when he knows it, he repents of it; if out of passion, when the passion is over, he is sorry for what he hath done: but when a man sins deliberately, and out of knowledge, it is a sign he is fixed and set in mischief; and therefore it is counted wickedness and malice. And hence it is, that those that have been enlightened with the highest kind of light, but that of saving grace, Heb. 6. 4, 5. and Heb. 10. If they sin wilfully after such a knowledge of the truth, God looks on them, as those that will never repent. And therefore likewise the school gives this as the reason why the Devils sin obstinately, and cannot repent, because of their full knowledge they sin with; they know all in the full latitude that it may be ⟨p. 39⟩known, and yet go on.
And that you may see the ground of this vast difference betweene sinnes of ignorance, and against knowledge,1 consider first, that if a man sin §1(suppose the act the same) out of ignorance meerly, there may be a supposition, that if hee had knowne it, he would not have done it; and that as soone as he doth know it, he would or might repent of it. So 1 Cor. 2. 8. If they had knowne, they had not crucified the Lord of Glory. The like ⟨p. 38⟩sayes Christ of Tyre, Sidon, and Gomorrha, that if the same things had beene done in them, they would have repented. But now when a man knowes it afore, and also considers it in the very committing it, and yet doth it, then there is no roome for such a supposition, and lesse hope. For what is it that should reduce this man to repentance? is it not his knowledge? now if that had no power to keepe him from his sinne, then it may be judged, that it will not be of force to bring him to repentance for it; for by sinning the heart is made more hard, and the knowledge and the authority of it weakned and lessened, as all power is, when contemned and resisted, Rom. 1. 21. their foolish heart becomes darker. Aristotle himselfe hath a touch of this notion in the third of his Ethicks, that if a man sinne out of ignorance, when he knowes it, he repents of it; if out of passion, when the passion is over, he is sorry for what he hath done: but when a man sinnes deliberately, and out of knowledge, it is a signe he is fixed and set in mischiefe; and therefore it is counted wickednesse and malice. And hence it is, that those that have beene enlightned with the highest kind of light, but that of saving grace, Heb. 6. 4, 5. and Heb. 10. If they sinne wilfully after such a knowledge of the truth, God lookes on them, as those that will never repent. And therefore likewise the schoole gives this as the reason why the Devills sinne obstinately, and cannot repent, because of their full knowledge they sinne with; they know all in the full latitude that it may be ⟨p. 39⟩knowne, and yet goe on.
Secondly, the vast difference that in Gods account §2is put between sins of knowledge, 1and of ignorance, will appear by the different respect and regard that God hath to them, in the repentance he requires and accepts for them; and that both in the acts of repentance, and also in the state of grace and repentance, upon which God accepts a man, or for want of which he rejecteth him.
Secondly, the vast difference that in Gods account §2is put betweene sinnes of knowledge, 1and of ignorance, will appeare by the different respect and regard that God hath to them, in the repentance he requires and accepts for them; and that both in the acts of repentance, and also in the state of grace and repentance, upon which God accepts a man, or for want of which he rejecteth him.
First, when a man comes to perform the acts of repentance, and to humble himself for sin, and to turn from it, God exacteth not, that sins of ignorance should particularly be repented of. But if they be repented of but in the general, & in the lump, be they never so great, God accepts it. This is intimated Psal. 19. 12. Who can understand his error? cleanse me from my secret sins: that was confession enough. But sins of knowledge must be particularly repented of, and confessed, and that again and again, as David was forced to do for his murder and adultery, or a man shall never have pardon. Yea farther, greater difference will appear, in regard of the state of grace and repentance: for a man may lye in a sin he doth not know to be a sin, and yet be in the state of Grace, as the Patriarchs in Polygamy, and in divorcing their wives: but to lye in a sin of knowledge, is not compatible with grace: but unless a man maintaineth a constant fight against it, hateth it, confesseth it, forsaketh it, he cannot have mercy. This cannot stand with uprightness ⟨p. 40⟩of heart. A friend may keep correspondency with one, he suspects not to be an enemy unto his friend, and be true to his friendship notwithstanding: but if he knows him to be an enemy, he must break utterly with the one, if he leans to the other.
First, when a man comes to performe the acts of repentance, and to humble himselfe for sinne, and to turne from it, God exacteth not, that sins of ignorance should particularly be repented of. But if they be repented of but in the general, & in the lumpe, be they never so great, God accepts it. This is intimated Psal. 19. 12. Who can understand his errour? cleanse me from my secret sinnes: that was confession enough. But sinnes of knowledge must be particularly repented of, and confessed, and that againe and againe, as David was forced to doe for his murder and adultery, or a man shall never have pardon. Yea farther, greater difference will appeare, in regard of the state of grace and repentance: for a man may lye in a sinne he doth not know to be a sinne, and yet be in the state of Grace, as the Patriarchs in Poligamie, and in divorcing their wives: but to lye in a sinne of knowledge, is not compatible with grace: but unlesse a man maintaineth a constant fight against it, hateth it, confesseth it, forsaketh it, hee cannot have mercy. This cannot stand with uprightnesse ⟨p. 40⟩of heart. A friend may keepe correspondencie with one, hee suspects not to be an enemy unto his friend, and be true to his friendship notwithstanding: but if hee knowes him to be an enemie, he must break utterly with the one, if he leanes to the other.
Thirdly, yet farther in the third place, so vast is the difference,1 that some kind of sins committed out of and against knowledge, utterly exclude from mercy for time to come; which done out of ignorance, remained capable of, and might have obtained it; as persecuting the Saints, blaspheming Christ, &c. Pauls will was as much in those acts themselves, and as hearty as those that sin against the Holy Ghost: for he was made against the Church, and in these sins, as himself says, not sinning willingly herein only, but being carried on with fury, as hot and as forward as the Pharisees that sinned that sin: only says he, 1 Tim. 1. 13. I did it ignorantly, therefore I obtained mercy. Though it was ignorantly done, yet there was need of mercy: but yet in that he did it but ignorantly, there was a capacity and place for mercy, which otherwise had not been. But thus to sin after a man hath received the knowledge of the truth, shuts a man out from mercy, Heb. 10. and there is no more sacrifice for sin, for such sins; I say, such sins as these, thus directly against the Gospel, when committed with knowledge. For sins against the Law, though against knowledge, there was an atonement, as appears Levit. 6. from the 1. verse to the 8. where he instanceth ⟨p. 41⟩in forswearing: But to persecute the Saints, and Christs truth, with malice, after knowledge of it, there is no more sacrifice: not that simply the sin is so great in the act it self of persecution, for Paul did it out of ignorance; but because it is out of knowledge: so vast a difference doth knowledge and ignorance put between the guilt of the same sin.
Thirdly, yet farther in the third place, so vast is the difference,1 that some kind of sins committed out of and against knowledge, utterly exclude from mercy for time to come; which done out of ignorance, remained capable of, and might have obtained it; as persecuting the Saints, blaspheming Christ, &c. Pauls will was as much in those acts themselves, and as hearty as those that sin against the Holy Ghost: for he was made against the Church, and in these sins, as himselfe sayes, not sinning willingly herein onely, but being carried on with fury, as hot and as forward as the Pharisees that sinned that sinne: onely sayes hee, 1 Tim. 1. 13. I did it ignorantly, therefore I obtained mercie. Though it was ignorantly done, yet there was need of mercie: but yet in that he did it but ignorantly, there was a capacity and place for mercie, which otherwise had not beene. But thus to sin after a man hath received the knowledge of the truth, shuts a man out from mercie, Heb. 10. and there is no more sacrifice for sinne, for such sins; I say, such sins as these, thus directly against the Gospell, when committed with knowledge. For sins against the Law, though against knowledge, there was an atonement, as appeares Levit. 6. from the 1. verse to the 8. where hee instanceth ⟨p. 41⟩in forswearing: But to persecute the Saints, and Christs truth, with malice, after knowledge of it, there is no more sacrifice: not that simply the sin is so great in the act it selfe of persecution, for Paul did it out of ignorance; but because it is out of knowledge: so vast a difference doth knowledge and ignorance put betweene the guilt of the same sinne.
And therefore indeed,1 to conclude this in the §4last place, this is the highest step of the ladder, next to turning off: the very highest but that of sinning against the Holy Ghost: which must needs argue it the highest aggravation of sinning, when it ascends so high, when it brings a man to the brink, and next to falling into the bottomless pit, irrecoverably. And therefore to sin presumptuously (which is all one) and to sin against knowledge, (as appears Numb. 15. 26, 27, 28, 29, 30. it being there opposed to sinning out of ignorance, (such a sin as David did, of whom it is said, 2 Sam. 12. 9. that he despised the word of the Lord: which phrase also is used to express sins of presumption, ver. 31. of that 15. of Numbers) To sin, I say, presumptuously, is the highest step: So in Davids account, Psal. 19. 12, 13. For first he prays, Lord keep me from secret sins, (which he maketh sins of ignorance) and then next he prays against presumptuous sins, (which, as the opposition shows, are sins against knowledge:) For (says he) if they get dominion over me, I shall not be free from [that great offence.] That is, that unpardonable sin, which shall never be forgiven: so as these are nearest it ⟨p. 42⟩of any other: yet not so, as that every one that falls into such a sin commits it, but he is nigh to it, at the next step to it. For to commit that sin, but two things are required; light in the mind, and malice in the heart: not malice alone, unless there be light; for then that Apostle had sinned it: so as knowledge is the Parent of it, it is after receiving the knowledge of the truth, Heb. 10. 27, 28.
And therefore indeed,1 to conclude this in the §4last place, this is the highest step of the ladder, next to turning off: the very highest but that of sinning against the Holy Ghost: which must needs argue it the highest aggravation of sinning, when it ascends so high, when it brings a man to the brinck, and next to falling into the bottomlesse pit, irrecoverably. And therefore to sinne presumptuously (which is all one) and to sinne against knowledge, (as appears Numb. 15. 26, 27, 28, 29, 30. it being there opposed to sinning out of ignorance, (such a sinne as David did, of whom it is said, 2 Sam. 12. 9. that he despised the word of the Lord: which phrase also is used to expresse sinnes of presumption, ver. 31. of that 15. of Numbers) To sinne, I say, presumptuously, is the highest step: So in Davids account, Psal. 19. 12, 13. For first he prayes, Lord keepe me from secret sinnes, (which he maketh sinnes of ignorance) and then next he prayes against presumptuous sinnes, (which, as the opposition shewes, are sinnes against knowledge:) For (sayes he) if they get dominion over me, I shall not be free from [that great offence.] That is, that unpardonable sinne, which shall never be forgiven: so as these are neerest it ⟨p. 42⟩of any other: yet not so, as that every one that fals into such a sinne commits it, but he is nigh to it, at the next step to it. For to commit that sinne, but two things are required; light in the mind, and malice in the heart: not malice alone, unlesse there be light; for then that Apostle had sinned it: so as knowledge is the Parent of it, it is after receiving the knowledge of the truth, Heb. 10. 27, 28.