But ye say, So far, as a man doth evil, be he Pope, be he Bishop, ye defend him not. The Popes themselves, ye say, be men: and do not always behave themselves, as Angels. Yet notwithstanding, immediately after the say further, Al these were Popes, and Peters Successors, and Holy Fathers. This being true, it is no hard matter, for any Pope to be Holy. 1Pope John 12. was slain in Adultery: Pope Benedictus 9. lived without either Law, or Reason, and defiled Peters Chair, with all kind of shame. Sine Lege, & Ratione vixit, & Petri Sedem omnibus probris foedavit. And in the end he took mon•e enough, and sold the Popedom. Platyna saith, Popes then were elected, not for their Learning, and Holiness, but in respect of Money, and friendship. The Bishops in the Council of Constance pronounce thus of Pope John. 23. A tempore ivventutis suae fuit homo malae indolis, inuerecundus, impudicus, &c. Et adhuc dicitur, tenetur, creditur, & reputatur pro tali, & ut talis: From the time of his youth he hath evermore been a man of il disposition, unshamefaste, unchaste, unhonest, &c. And still hitherto he is named, holden, believed, taken, and reputed for ⟨p. 423⟩such a one, 2and as such a one. Somme of them have lived filthily with their own daughters, and some worse, and in more beastly disorder. Platyna calleth them Monstra, & Portenta, Monsters, and ugly, and horrible, and il shapen Creatures. Yet, say you, all these were Peters Successors, and Holy Fathers. And so must they needs be counted, although they had been a great deal worse. Dame Joan, I trow, ye will have foreprised out of this number. For notwithstanding she were a Holy Mother, yet ye may not well call her the Holy Father.
But ye saie, So far, as a man dooth euil, be he Pope, be he Bishop, ye defende him not. The Popes themselues, ye saie, be menne: and doo not alwaies behaue themselues, as Angels. Yet notwithstandinge, immediately after ye saie further, Al these vvere Popes, and Peters Successours, and Holy Fathers. This beinge true, it is no harde mater, for any Pope to be Holy. 1Pope Iohn 12. was slaine in Aduouterie: Pope Benedictus 9. liued without either Lawe, or Reason, and defiled Peters Chaire, with al kinde of shame. Sine Lege, & Ratione vixit, & Petri Sedem omnibus probris foedauit. And in the ende he tooke mon•e yenoughe, and solde the Popedome. Platyna saithe, Popes then were elected, not for theire Learninge, and Holinesse, but in respecte of Monie, and frendship. The Bishoppes in the Councel of Constance pronoūce thus of Pope Iohn. 23. A tēpore iuuentutis suae fuit homo malae indolis, inuerecūdus, impudicus, &c. Et adhuc dicitur, tenetur, creditur, & reputatur pro tali, & vt talis: From the time of his youth he hath euermore benne a man of il disposition, vnshamefaste, vnchaste, vnhoneste, &c. And stilhitherto he is named, holden, beleeued, taken, and reputed for ⟨p. 423⟩sutche a one, 2and as sutche a one. Somme of them haue liued filthily with theire owne daughters, and somme woorse, and in more beastly disorder. Platyna calleth them Monstra, & Portenta, Monsters, and ougle, and horrible, and il shapen Creatures. Yet, saie you, al these were Peters Successours, and Holy Fathers. And so muste they néedes be coumpted, although they had benne a great deale woorse. Dame Iohane, I trowe, ye wil haue foreprised out of this number. For notwithstandinge shée were a Holy Mother, yet ye maie not wel calle her the Holy Father.
- 1Platyna. Textor in Officina. Platyna. Platyna in Syluestro 3. Constantien. Concilium.
- 2The Pope is ever Holy.The Pope is euer Holy.