But they say, The Scriptures be dark: therefore we must seek the meaning of them in the Doctors. The Doctors agree not: Then must we weigh & try them ⟨p. 259⟩by the Master of the Sentences.1 The Master of the Sentences him self sometimes is not holden: then must we seek further to the School Doctors. The School Doctors can in no wise agree: there is Scotus against Thomas: and Occam against Scotus: and Alliacensis against Occam: the Nominals against the Reals: the Scholasticalles against the Canonists: the contention is greater, & the doubts darker, then ever they were before. Neither is there any resolution to be hoped for, but only of the Bishop of Rome: whom M. Harding calleth the supreme Judge:2 who, as one saith, is Doctor utriusque Legis, Authoritate, non Scientia, Doctour of both Laws, by Authority, not by knowledge. How be it, it appeareth his knowledge, and authority in such cases are both like. For not withstanding any his determination, the contention standeth still as it did before. Truely Alphonsus de Castro, 3a Doctor of the same side, saithe, Cum constet plures Papas adeò illiteratos esse, ut Grammaticam penitus ignorent, qui fit, ut sacras Literas interpretari possint? Seeing it is well known, that many Popes be so void of learning, that they be utterly ignorant of their Grammar, how may it be, that they can expound the holy Scriptures? Thus that supreme Judge, at whose only hands M. Harding would have all the world to seek for the very sense of God's word, as Alphonsus saith, may go to school to learn his Grammar. And what if the Pope be an Heretic, as Liberius was an Arian:4 Honorius an Eunomian: Anastasius was a Photinian: and as Lyra saith, Multi Papae inuenti sunt Apostatae, Many Popes have been renegades of the Faith: 5Or what if he be a sorcerer, and have league and conference with the Devil, as had Sylvester the second?6 Yet must we needs have recourse unto such a one, as unto the mouth of God, for the certain sense & meaning of God's word? Verily, in the old times, men that stood in doubt of any matter of learning, and would gladly be resolved, sought unto the best learned, and not unto the Pope.7 Pope Leo himself in a case of doubt, thought it good to confer with other Bishops. The Bishops of Numidia sent, not to the Bishop of Rome to be resolved, but unto S.
But they say, The Scriptures be darke: therfore we must séeke the meaning of them in the Doctours. The Doctours agrée not: Then must we weigh & trie them ⟨p. 259⟩by the Maister of the Sentences.1 The Maister of the Sentences him selfe sometimes is not holden: then muste we seeke further to the Schoole Doctours. The Schoole Doctours canne in no wise agrée: there is Scotus againste Thomas: and Occam against Scotus: and Alliacensis against Occam: the Nominales against the Reales: the Scholasticalles against the Canonistes: the contention is greater, & the doubtes darker, then euer they were before. Neither is there any resolution to be hoped for, but onely of the Bishop of Rome: whome M. Hardinge calleth the supreme Iudge:2 who, as one saithe, is Doctor vtriusque Legis, Authoritate, non Scientia, Doctour of bothe Lawes, by Authoritie, not by knowlege. How be it, it appeareth his knowlege, and authoritie in suche cases are bothe like. For not withstandinge any his determination, the contention standeth stil as it did before. Truely Alphonsus de Castro, 3a Doctour of the same side, saithe, Cum constet plures Papas adeò illiteratos esse, vt Grammaticam penitus ignorent, qui fit, vt sacras Literas interpretari possint? Seeinge it is wel knowen, that many Popes be so voide of learninge, that they be vtterly ignorant of their Grammar, how may it be, that thei can expounde the holy Scriptures? Thus that supreme Iudge, at whose onely handes M. Hardinge woulde haue al the worlde to seeke for the very sense of Goddes woorde, as Alphonsus saithe, may goe to schoole to learne his Grammar. And what if the Pope be an Heretique, as Liberius was an Arrian:4 Honorius an Eunomian: Anastasius was a Photinian: and as Lyra saithe, Multi Papae inuenti sunt Apostatae, Many Popes haue been rennegates of the Faithe: 5Or what if he be a •orcerer, and haue league and conference with the Diuel, as had Syluester the seconde?6 Yet must we needes haue recourse vnto suche a one, as vnto the mouthe of God, for the certaine sense & meaninge of Goddes woorde? Uerily, in the olde times, menne that stoode in doubte of any mater of learninge, and woulde gladly be resolued, sought vnto the best learned, and not vnto the Pope.
- 1Magister non •enetur.
- 2Baldus.
- 3Alphonsus de Castro li. 1. Ca. 4.
- 4Alphonsus de Castro li. 1. Ca. 4
- 5Nico. Lyra in Matthae. 16. ca.
- 6Platyna in Syluestro.
- 7Leo Episto. 37. ad Episcopum Ravennatem.Leo Episto. 37. ad Episcopum Rauennatem.