Because ye desire your argument to be solved at your own request I will take some pain: God grant it may profit. Your argument containeth in it self the fallax which is called of Equivocation, for this word knowledge or this sentence: whom God did for know in the words of Paul, which be in your Major or first proposition, do not signify the self same thing that these words, but God knew all men before, which you put in your minor or second proposition. And so because that there be four terms which in the schools be called scopae dissolutae, the argument is deceitful and false, although the form appear good. Thus I trust in your own conscience you think your argument fully and rightly solved. but yet that neither ye shall have occasion to bark again, neither yet that the simple reader shall take pain to read these vain arguments without all fruit, I will add somewhat more, and will plainly prove my solution to be good. In the ⟨p. 117⟩first proposition I say, where saint Paul sayeth, whom God for• knew,1 the same he before ordained: that the holy Ghost meaneth of that fore knowledge of God which is joy •ed with his eternal love, which before all times he did •ear to his elect, as of the words of Christ Jesus and of the words of the same Apostle in divers places before is declared. And with this fore knowledge which is joined with his love by the which his elect were appointed to be made like fashioned to their head Christ Jesus,2 did never God fore know nor foresee Cain, Judas, nor none other reprobate to appertain to him. I do not deny but that as all things ever were present before the eyes of his Majesty, so did he both foreknow, foresee, and before ordain the end of all creatures: but other ways I say doeth God fore know his elect, of whom S. Paul only speaketh. If it doeth offend you that I affirm that God did never fore know the reprobate as he did his elect: I have my assurance of Christ Jesus, of his own plain words, saying, to the false prophets I never knew you, depart from me ye workers of iniquity.
Because ye desire your argumēt to be soluted at your own request I will take som paine: God grant it may profit. Your argument conteineth in it self the fallax which is called of Equiuocation, for this word knowledge or this sentence: whom God did for knowe in the wordes of Paul, which be in your Maior or first propositīon, do not signifie the self same thing that these wordes, but God knew all men before, which you put in your minor or second proposition. And so because that there be foure termes which in the schooles be called scopae dissolutae, the argument is deceatfull and fals, althogh the forme appere good. Thus I trust in your own cōscience you think your argument fully and rightly soluted. but yet that neither ve shall haue occasion to bark againe, neither yet that the simple reader shall take paine to reade these vaine argumentes withou• all frute, I will adde somwhat more, and will plainely proue my solution to be good. In the ⟨p. 117⟩first proposition I say, where saint Paul saieth, whom God for• knew,1 the same he before ordeined: that the holie Gost meaneth of that fore knowledge of God which is ioy •ed with his eternall loue, which before all tymes he did •ear to his elect, as of the wordes of Christ Iesus and of the wordes of the same Apostle in diuers places before is declared. And with this fore knowledge which is ioyned with his loue by the which his elect were appointed to be made like fashioned to their head Christ Iesus,2 did neuer God fore know nor foresee Cain, Iudas, nor none other reprobate to appertein to him. I do not denie but that as all thinges euer were present before the eies of his Maiestie, so did he both foreknow, foresee, and before ordein the ēd of all creatures: but other wies I say doeth God fore know his elect, of whō S. Paul onely speaketh. If it doeth offend you that I affirme that God did neuer fore know yc reprobate as he did his elect: I haue my assurāce of Christ Iesus, of his own plaine wordes, sayng, to the fals prophetes I neuer knew you, depart from me ye workers of iniquitie.
- 1Rom. 9.
- 2The difference of gode fore knowledge.