¶ An other argument Sophistical.¶ An other argument Sophisticall.
pp. lxxvi5 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. lxxvi5 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Works which be against the law of God, are sin. Ergo. Good works are justice.
Workes which be againste the lawe of God, are sinne. Ergo. Good workes are iustice.
☞ This consequent must be true (say they) for they be contraries: bad works and good works. And the knowledge of ⟨p. lxxvi⟩the one contrary,1 is the knowledge and declaration of that other. Wherefore it followeth that by good works men are justified, for as much as good works be justice.
☞ This consequent must be true (saye they) for they be contraries: bad workes and good workes. And the knowlege of ⟨p. lxxvi⟩the one contrary,1 is the knowledge and declaration of that other. Wherefore it foloweth that by good workes men are iustified, for as much as good workes be iustice.
☞ This is very light and easy to be answered. It is true as they say, if that good works were a perfect obedience. But because they be far from a perfect obedience, you may soon perceive that the argument is not good, because they be not right contrary For naughty works are right nought in deed: but our good works, are not perfectly good works, for as much as they have much filthiness and corruption in them, where with they be corrupted. As by example. Pomponius Atticus: was both modest and just to the Citizens. But he doubteth of the governance and provision of god: he is without the fear of God, which marreth the rest of his virtues.
☞ This is very lyghte and easy to be answered. It is true as they say, if that good workes were a perfect obedience. But bycause they be farre frome a perfect obedience, you maye soone perceyue that the argument is nat good, bycause they be nat right contrary For noughty workes are right nought in dede: but our good workes, are nat perfectly good workes, for as much as they haue much fylthynes and corrupcion in them, wher with they be corrupted. As by example. Pomponius Artycus: was both modeste and iust to the Citezins. But he douteth of the gouernance and prouision of god: he is without the feare of God, whiche marreth the rest of his vertues.
¶ The which argument may soon beguile and deceive them which are not warned and taught the subtlety thereof. Therefore the consequent of this argument is false because they be not clean and directly contrary. Like answer shall you make to this argument that followeth.
¶ The whiche argumente may sone begyle and deceyue them whiche are nat warned and taughte the subtyltie therof. Therefore the consequent of thys argument is false bicause they be nat clene and directly contrary. Lyke answere shall you make to thys argumente that foloweth.