Our dissent from the Church of Rome in the doctrine of fasting stands in three things. I. They appoint and prescribe set times of fasting, as necessary to be kept: but we hold and teach that to prescribe the time of a religious fast, is in the liberty of the Church and the governors thereof, as special occasion shall be offered. When the disciples of John asked Christ, why they and the Pharisees fast often, but his disciples fasted not, he answered, Can the children of the marriage chamber mourn as long as the bridegroom is with them: but the days will come when the bridegroom shall be taken away from them, and then shall they fast, Math. 9.15. where he gives them to understand, that they must fast, as occasions of mourning are offered. Where also I gather, that a set time of fasting is no more to be enjoined then a set time of mourning. It was the opinion of Augustine, that neither Christ nor his Apostles, appointed any times of fasting. 1And Tertullian saith, that they of his time fasted of their own accords freely, without law or commandment, as occasions and times served. And Eusebius saith, that Montanus was the first that made laws of fasting. It is objected, that there is a set time of fasting prescribed, Levit. 16.29. Ans. This set and prescribed fast was commanded of God as a part of the legal worship which had his end in the death of Christ: therefore it doth not justify a set time of fasting in the new testament, where God hath left man to his own liberty, without giving the like commandment. It is again alleged, that Zechariah, 7.5. there were set times appointed for the celebration of religious fasts unto the Lord, the fifth and the seventh months. Ans. They were appointed upon occasion of the present afflictions of the Church in Babylon, and they ceased upon their deliverance. The like upon like occasion may we appoint. It is further objected, that some Churches of the Protestants observe set times of fasting. Ans. In some Churches there be set days and times of fasting, not upon necessity or for conscience or religions sake, but for politic or civill regards, whereas in the Romish Church it is held a mortal sin, to defer the set time of fasting till the next day following.
Our dissent from the Church of Rome in the doctrine of fasting stands in three things. I. They appoint and prescribe set times of fasting, as necessarie to be kept: but we hold and teach that to prescribe the time of a religious fast, is in the libertie of the Church and the gouernours thereof, as speciall occasion shall be offered. When the disciples of Iohn asked Christ, why they and the Pharises fast often, but his disciples fasted not, he answered, Can the children of the marriage chamber mourne as long as the bridegroome is with them: but the daies will come when the bridegroome shall be taken away from them, and then shall they fast, Math. 9.15. where he giues them to vnderstand, that they must fast, as occasions of mourning are offered. Where also I gather, that a set time of fasting is no more to be enioyned then a set time of mourning. It was the opinion of Augustine, that neither Christ nor his Apostles, appointed any times of fasting. 1And Tertullian saith, that they of his time fasted of their owne accordes freely, without law or commandement, as occasions and times serued. And Eusebius saith, that Montanus was the first that made lawes of fasting. It is obiected, that there is a set time of fasting prescribed, Leuit. 16.29. Ans. This set and prescribed fast was commanded of God as a part of the legall worship which had his ende in the death of Christ: therefore it doth not iustifie a set time of fasting in the new testament, where God hath left man to his owne libertie, without giuing the like commandement. It is againe alleadged, that Zacharie, 7.5. there were set times appointed for the celebration of religious fasts vnto the Lord, the fifth and the seauenth moneths. Ans. They were appointed vpon occasion of the present afflictions of the Church in Babylon, and they ceased vpon their deliuerance. The like vpon like occasion may we appoint. It is further obiected, that some Churches of the Protestants obserue set times of fasting. Ans. In some Churches there be set daies and times of fasting, not vpon necessitie or for conscience or •eligions sake, but for politicke or ciuill regardes, whereas in the Romish Church it is helde a mortall sinne, to deferre the set time of fasting till the next day following.
- 1Epist. 86. Contra Psychicos. Hist. l.5. c. 17.