First, the patrons & maintainers of them, do appoint set times of fasting, which are, necessarily to be kept, upon pain of mortal sin. And abstinence from flesh (with them) is made a matter of conscience. Now to prescribe set times necessarily to be observed, is contrary to that liberty, which the Church of God and the governors thereof have for this purpose, only upon special occasion. When the question was moved to our Saviour, by Johns Disciples, Why they and the Pharisees fasted often, whereas his fasted not; Answer was given in this manner, Can the children of the marriage chamber mourn, as long as the bridegroom is with them? But the days will come, when the bridegroom shall be taken away from them, and then shall they fast, Mat. 9. 15. From whence we may gather, that times of fasting must be, according to the times of mourning. For Christ gives them to understand, that they were to fast, as occasions of mourning were offered. As therefore, there can be appointed no set time for mourning, no more can there be enjoined a set time for fasting; but must be ⟨p. 434⟩left to the liberty of the Church, to be prescribed, as God shall give occasion. Again, the Apostle reproveth the Church of Galatia, for observing set days, and months, & times, and years, in way of Religion. Gal. 4. 10. Montanus the Heretic is thought (in 1Ecclesiastical stories) to have been the first, that made laws for set-fasting. And the Churches of God in ancienter times, fasted of their own accords freely, not enforced by law or commandment, but as time and occasion served.
First, the patrons & maintainers of them, doe appoint set times of fasting, which are, necessarily to be kept, vpon paine of mortall sinne. And abstinence from flesh (with them) is made a matter of conscience. Now to prescribe set times necessarily to be obserued, is contrarie to that libertie, which the Church of God and the gouernours thereof haue for this purpose, onely vpon speciall occasion. When the question was mooued to our Saviour, by Iohns Disciples, Why they and the Pharises fasted often, whereas his fasted not; Answer was giuen in this manner, Can the children of the marriage chamber mourne, as long as the bridegrome is with them? But the daies will come, when the bridegrome shall be taken away from them, and then shall they fast, Mat. 9. 15. From whence we may gather, that times of fasting must be, according to the times of mourning. For Christ giues them to vnderstand, that they were to fast, as occasions of mourning were offered. As therefore, there can be appointed no set time for mourning, no more can there be enioyned a set time for fasting; but must be ⟨p. 434⟩left to the libertie of the Church, to be prescribed, as God shall giue occasion. Againe, the Apostle reprooueth the Church of Galatia, for obseruing set daies, and moneths, & times, and yeares, in way of Religion. Gal. 4. 10. Montanus the Hereticke is thought (in 1Ecclesiasticall stories) to haue beene the first, that made lawes for set-fasting. And the Churches of God in ancienter times, fasted of their own accords freely, not inforced by law or commandement, but as time and occasion serued.
- 1Euseb. Hist. Eccl. l. 5. c. 17.