AGAIN, thou beatest against the same rock, which knowest not how to set hatred under the decree, & that so, that betwixt the decree and hatred, be interjected the cause of hatred, whose gus•tinesse remaineth in men themselves, as I have already said a thousand times. Again, albeit we willing lye confess the goodness of God to have appeared in the very work of creation, nor that God hath properly hated his own work, but his corruption, yet who will grant thee, that thou wouldest enforce by this argument, that God, because that for his singular goodness, he created the reprobate, therefore he did not predestinate them to his deserved hatred. But I will help thee here. For not only in the creation of the reprobate, but also in all their life, a certain unspeakable kindness ⟨p. 36⟩of God doeth often shine, insomuch, that if thou beholdest the present state of things, and ascendest no further, the Lord may rather seem to favour the wicked than the righteous: which cogitation much moved David, and deceived the Epicures. But what (sayeth the LORD) of all Reprobates in the person of Pharaoh, saying: Therefore (sayeth he) have I raised thee up, that is, have brought thee forth, that in thee I might declare my power, that is to say, in working mightily on thee. Nor yet am I ignorant, that there is not wanting those which otherwise expound the word of Exciting, which answereth to the Hebrew word: but the Apostles saying doeth sufficiently declare, that it is to be expounded so, that it ought to ascend to the very creation. Again, what way so ever thou doest expound it, truly it shall express the Lords benefits upon Pharaoh, whom notwithstanding he had from everlasting decreed to destroy, and that because he would. For why otherwise should Paul ascend to the will, and should not rather say, he hath pity on whom he pleaseth, and those that deserve this, or whom he foreknew would deserve, those he suffereth to be hardened. So also GOD from everlasting predestinated Esau to his hatred, but yet he blessed him in the plenty of the Earth, and dew of Heaven.
AGAINE, thou beatest againste the same rocke, whiche knowest not howe to set hatred vnder the decrée, & that so, that betwixte the decrée and hatred, be interiected the cause of hatred, whose gus•tinesse remaineth in menne themselues, as I haue already saide a thousand times. Againe, albeit wée willing lye confesse the goodnesse of God to haue appeared in the very worke of creation, nor that God hath properly hated his own worke, but his corruption, yet who will graunt thée, that thou wouldest enfore by this argument, that God, bicause that for his singular goodnesse, he created the reprobate, therfore he did not predestinate them to his deserued hatred. But I will helpe thée here. For not onely in the creation of the reprobate, but also in all their life, a certaine vnspeakle kindenesse ⟨p. 36⟩of God doeth often shine, insomuch, that if thou beholdest the presente state of thinges, and ascendest no further, the Lorde maye rather seeme to fauoure the wicked than the righteous: which cogitation muche moued Dauid, and deceyned the Epicures. But what (sayeth the LOKDE) of all Reprobates in the person of Pharao, saying: Therefore (sayeth hée) haue I raised thée vppe, that is, haue broughte thée foorthe, that in thée I might declare my power, that is to saye, in working mightily on thée. Nor yet am I ignorant, that there is not wanting those which otherwise expounde the word of Exciting, whyche aunswereth to the Hebrue worde: but the Apostles saying doeth sufficientlye declare, that it is to be expounded so, that it oughte to ascende to the very creation. Againe, what way so euer thou doest expounde it, truelye it shall expresse the Lordes benefites vppon Pharao, whome notwythstanding he hadde from euerlasting decréede to destroy, and that bycause he woulde. For why otherwise shoulde Paule ascende to the will, and shoulde not rather saye, hée hathe pitie on whome he pleaseth, and those that deserue this, or whome hée foreknewe woulde deserue, those he suffereth to bée hardened. So also GOD from euerlastyng predestinated Esau to hys hatred, but yet hée blessed hym in the plentye of the Earthe, and deawe of Heauen.