For if thou returnest to the foreknown frowardness of Esau, the Apostle resisteth, who, having called Jacob beloved, and therefore elect before he was borne, that we might know election, not only in time (as that which is eternal) but also in the order of causes to prevent all things, ⟨p. 29⟩and so that utterly no place be left for foresight, for faith or works, as those which are not causes, but fruits of election: So when he cometh to the opposite member, he utterly showeth by the like reason, that Esau was hated, and therefore vowed to destruction before he was borne, or had done any evil. That verily we also may understand in this behalf not only an eternal purpose of rejecting, but that it is superior to all causes of destruction. And that here is left no place to foresight, or corruption, or incredulity, or of evil works. For these in deed be causes of damnation, so only adherent to Esau, that God by no means be guilty of the crime, but yet are they causes of the eternal decree of Reprobation, not for going, but following. Other wise if these words of Paul, Before they were borne, & or ever they had done good or evil, you do otherwise in one part expound than in another, over and beside that general principle, that contraries have all one discipline, shall plentifully refel thee: there is none who will not see that apparent force is offered to the Apostles words, if one and the same sentence, and in the self words, should be racked into divers expositions. Which in deed shall be, if in one part you say that foresight is excluded, and in the other notwithstanding reserved. Finally, if the purpose of rejecting should have stood upon foresight, over and besides that the self things of necessity must have been foreseen on both parts, whence at the last the objections which follow should have sprung, in foredoing of which the Apostle so forcibly contendeth. For neither should the Elect have had whereof to complain, except they would complain of mercy: nor also the reprobate, if for their foreseen deserts they had been rejected. But it is one thing to ask why God hath hated, an other thing to ask why he hath Predestinate to hatred. All which ⟨p. 30⟩least happily thou thinkest I have devised, hear what Augustine hath thought of the same matter in his Enchiridion to Laurentius, Cap. 98.
For if thou returnest to the foreknowen frowardnesse of Esau, the Apostle resisteth, who, hauing called Iacob beloued, and therefore elect before he was borne, that we might knowe election, not onely in tyme (as that which is eternall) but also in the order of causes to preuent all things, ⟨p. 29⟩and so that vtterly no place be left for foresight, for faith or works, as those whiche are not causes, but fruites of election: So when he commeth to the opposite member, he vtterly sheweth by the like reason, that Esau was hated, and therefore vowed to destruction before he was borne, or had done any evill. That verely we also maye vnderstande in this behalfe not onely an eternall purpose of reiecting, but that it is superiour to all causes of destruction. And that héere is lefte no place to foresight, or corruption, or incredulitie, or of euill workes. For these in déede be causes of damnation, so onely adherent to Esau, that God by no meanes be guyltie of the cryme, but yet are they causes of the eternall decrée of Reprobation, not for going, but folowing. Other wise if these wordes of Paule, Before they were borne, & or euer they had done good or euill, you doe otherwise in one parte expounde than in another, ouer and beside that generall principle, that contraries haue all one discipline, shall plentifully refell thée: there is none who wyll not sée that apparant force is offered to the Apostles wordes, if one and the same sentence, and in the selfe wordes, should be racked into diuers expositions. Which in déede shall be, if in one parte you say that foresight is excluded, and in the other notwithstanding reserued. Finally, if the purpose of reiecting shoulde haue stoode vpon foresight, ouer and besides that the selfe things of necessitie muste haue béene foreséene on both partes, whence at the last the obiections whiche folowe shoulde haue sprong, in foredoing of which the Apostle so forceably contendeth. For neither should the Elect haue had whereof to complayne, except they would complayne of mercie: nor also the reprobate, if for their foreséene desertes they had bene reiected. But it is one thyng to aske why God hath hated, an other thing to aske why he hath Predestinate to hatered. All whiche ⟨p. 30⟩least happily thou thinkest I haue deuised, heare what Augustine hath thought of the same matter in his Enchiridion to Laurentius, Cap. 98.