But this is his Error, though every man be hereby ready to excuse himself,1 thinking the rebellion of the sensual Appetite not to be so great a matter. But to take his own words, he saith, the same as it is in Beasts; It is true, if it were with us, as it is with beasts, it were no sin, and so not a thing which gives us cause to be so much humbled: for in beasts the sensual Appetite hath no superior governor, but is supreme. To express it to you, Take an horse in a pasture that is loose, and free, if he run up and down and play, we find no fault with him, for he is loose; but if he doth this under the bridle, when the rider is on his back, will you not now reckon him a stiff-necked horse, and count it a fault in him, for there is a rider on his back. So for this sensual Appetite in beasts, where there is liberty, and no superior command to keep them in order, the beasts are not to be blamed. But take a man where God hath set reason above the sensual Appetite, and grace above reason to guide it; in him this sensual Appetite rebels against reason, which it should obey, and this shows it to be a great sin in men, considering that reason should be the rule to guide, and keep in the sensual Appetite, for God hath given it for that purpose. Indeed some desires are natural; Christ desired life, which was lawful, and a right object of desire; but take this withal, it was perfectly subjugated and brought under, and made obedient to the will of God, as his will was holy and sanctified: So we may ⟨p. 60⟩desire meat and drink, but many times the Law of God may forbid it, as in many cases it doth, for it may differ from the will of God, as it is holy, and yet in it self it may be right. Here is no more but subordination required. But when this runs out amiss, affecting of things inordinately, though you do suppress it, yet that affection is sinful, and you must be humbled for it; God sees it in you, and it is hateful, and abominable to him.
But this is his Errour, though every man be hereby ready to excuse himselfe,1 thinking the rebellion of the sensuall Appetite not to be so great a matter. But to take his owne words, he saith, the same as it is in Beasts; It is true, if it were with us, as it is with beasts, it were no sin, and so not a thing which gives us cause to be so much humbled: for in beasts the sensual Appetite hath no superiour governour, but is supreme. To expresse it to you, Take an horse in a pasture that is loose, and free, if he run up and downe and play, we finde no fault with him, for he is loose; but if he doth this under the bridle, when the rider is on his back, will you not now reckon him a stiffe-necked horse, and count it a fault in him, for there is a rider on his backe. So for this sensuall Appetite in beasts, where there is liberty, and no superiour command to keepe them in order, the beasts are not to be blamed. But take a man where God hath set reason above the sensuall Appetite, and grace above reason to guide it; in him this sensuall Appetite rebels against reason, which it should obey, and this shewes it to be a great sinne in men, considering that reason should be the rule to guide, and keepe in the sensuall Appetite, for God hath giv•n it for that purpose. Indeed some desires are naturall; Christ desired life, which was lawful, and a right object of desire; but take this withall, it was perfectly subjugated and brought under, and made obedient to the will of God, as his will was holy and sanctified: So we may ⟨p. 60⟩desire meat and drinke, but many times the Law of God may forbid it, as in many cases it doth, for it may differ from the will of God, as it is holy, and yet in it selfe it may be right. Here is no more but subordination required. But when this runnes out amisse, affecting of things inordinately, though you doe suppresse it, yet that affection is sinfull, and you must be humbled for it; God sees it in you, and it is hatefull, and abominable to him.
- 1Answ.